Q: Early shift issues in 2011 BMW 328I

asked by on April 11, 2016

I have a 2011 BMW 328I. Recently, it seems that it struggles shifting from first to second--plenty of power if I stay on the gas, it does shift easy. Just, in traffic, the early shift seems off right now. Any ideas?

BMWs unfortunately become endless money pits as they age, and within those cars, they have really high-tech transmission systems.

The first thing you will need to do is have a mechanic scan the car and take it on the road test, because there are all kinds of data from the engine and transmission that is stored inside that BMW and it will give you a good idea.

Unfortunately, that particular vehicle has a lot of transmission problems and a lot of times it needs to be taken down and the solenoids need to be replaced. They are so complicated that only a good mechanic should take a look into this. My advice is that next time, don’t buy something sized as BMW because they do have problems and they are very expensive to fix when they do break.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I remove and replace air filters in the climate controlled seats?
If your truck is equipped with climate controlled seats, they include air filters under each seat. These air filters need to be removed and replaced from time to time. To remove and replace the air filters. Get to the air...
Truck stalls
The idle air control valve on your car may be defective, causing the low idle. A couple checks would have to be done to determine if this is the case: your engine needs to be checked for any vacuum leaks,...
I'm considering buying another car and it's going to be an automatic. Is it worth it? I've never had one.
It depends. I personally like to drive the standard because you have more control, you get a tiny bit better gas mileage, and you can drive faster. It's a better driving experience. You've got to think about how far people...
Looking for a car that is good in winter
Hello. If you’re going to buy a Sante Fe (https://www.yourmechanic.com/cars/hyundai/santa-fe) that offers all wheel drive or four wheel drive (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/3-essential-things-to-know-about-four-wheel-drive-4wd), it should hold up pretty well in the harsh winter weather conditions. A Sante Fe with front wheel or four...
What can happen without using my fuel rail pressure sensor?
The fuel rail pressure sensor is used by the computer to regulate the fuel pressure by regulating the voltage to the fuel pump to slow it down or speed it up. If the pressure switch is bad then the computer...
Gear shift indicator won't go into park
Hello, thanks for writing in. There is an adjustment procedure for the shift indicator on your vehicle. Some shop repair manuals will outline how to make the adjustments, but it would be best to consult a certified mechanic that has...
Loss of power going uphill and acceleration issues on flat land
Hello. P0401 is the trouble code for insufficient EGR flow. This can occur for a few different reasons, and could be contributing to your performance issues. The EGR, short for exhaust gas re circulation, is a system designed to recirculate...
2007 yaris sputters and stalls in park
Hi there. In most cases, when your engine runs fine, but will sputter and die when you put it into park, it's an indication of a vacuum leak, mass air flow sensor or EGR valve problem. It could also indicate...
Excess Vibration Front Wheels; knocking sound when going over bumps
What you are describing sounds like a failing CV joint (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/axle-cv-shaft-assembly-replacement). A CV (Constant Velocity) joint is a shaft that connects the transmission to the wheels, essentially transferring the power from the drive train directly to the wheels. The CV...

Related articles

How Does a Transmission Filter Work?
The The transmission plays a hugely important role in how your vehicle functions. It's connected to the rear portion of your engine and transfers power from the engine to the wheels. Without a transmission, a vehicle simply cannot move. The...
What Is Direct Drive Gear?
Direct Direct drive is a type of transmission that allows for better gear shifting within a motor vehicle. Because fewer gears are connecting, the vehicle cruises better at a higher gear. That’s a fairly simple explanation, so let’s talk a...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Crankshaft Harmonic Balancer
Common signs include engine vibration, misaligned timing marks, and a separated harmonic balancer.