Q: Downsizing for winter tires

asked by on January 03, 2018

Hello there, I am getting a great deal on Michelin X-Ice i3 winter tires for 800 everything included. But the problem is that the original all season tires are sized 225/45R17 although the winter tires are 205/55R16. The mechanic told me its completely fine to change the sizes a bit and he said it’s even better to have smaller ( thinner ) tires in snow to get better traction. I am still concerned, can I install that size snow tires on my car! Plz help! The mechanic does the installation and everything for me but said he doesn’t do alignment. What is allignment? Is it mandatory? What happens if I don’t allign my tires and I experience no problems? Does YourMechanic do allignment services alone? And how much does it cost? Thx so much for your time and help!! I would really appreciate it!! Cheers from NYC!

Snow tire dimensions: 205/55R16

Original all-season dimensions: 225/45R17

Even though the rims are different sizes the two tires are very close in size for height and width and will not cause any issues using them. You do not need to have an alignment since this is for the suspension and as long as tires are balanced you will be ok.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

What does the air bag Light mean on the dash?
Your car has a number of air bags throughout the cabin designed to work with the seat belts to provide better safety for you and your passengers. The air bag Light in the dash is a readiness indicator. It should...
Maintenance light on
The maintenance light is designed to come on at certain intervals to remind you to service the car. If the car was serviced recently, sometimes they forget to reset the light. To reset it: turn the ignition on with the...
Security light on
From the description provided, it appears that your Saturn is experiencing a common issue that can be, in most cases, easily resolved. One trick you can try in the meantime, is to turn the key to the on position and...
Rear passenger tire has slight inward tilt
Any time there is abnormal wear on the tire, you know something is wrong. The fact that you can see the inward tilt of the wheel is not good. It could be a wheel bearing, but this would accompany a...
I can hear a rattling noise under my hood close to the outside of the motor
Hey there. I would not expect anything in or around the oil pan itself to make rattling noises that might be considered musical. Heat shields for exhaust manifolds and other metal brackets and shielding can make lots of rattling noises,...
All my light work when truck off start truck all lights work except headlights go out
If the headlights are working intermittently (i.e., turn off after you start the truck), there is a loose connection, faulty relay or switch, or other electrical problem in the headlight circuit. When the problem occurs, you can find the fault...
Battery light is on after a new battery
Hello, thank you for writing in. The vehicle may be having issues with the alternator or with the charging system's electrical wiring. Start by making sure all of your battery terminals, ground connections, wires to the alternator, and wires to...
crank no start - 2001 ford escort - 2.0l auto SOHC. Ignition wires will shock you, spark plug have gas on them
If you are getting spark and plugs are getting wet with fuel then you need to check engine compression in the engine. I have seen where the valve seats come loose and will cause the valve to stick in the...
Vdc light slip light wants to stall when push the gas
The near stalling when you push the gas pedal is a consequence of the air fuel ratio being off as the throttle admits more air to the intake. The causes of the "wrong" ratio lie somewhere in the fuel delivery...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Hyundai Sonata
Hyundai Hyundai has been making a real name for itself in the midsize sedan class in the past few years, and the 2012 Hyundai Sonata is no exception. With an attractive price tag, a great warranty, and a choice of...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Get Motion Sickness
For For people that suffer from motion sickness, even on the shortest car trip, riding in a vehicle can prove to be unbearable. What’s great is that there are a number of cars on the market that can help to...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're a Teacher
If If you are a teacher, probably foremost on your mind is getting to school on time. You would also probably like a used car that is easy on gas and not terribly expensive, and will hold your gym gear...