Q: Dealership says water pump needs replacing

asked by on March 22, 2018

Hi there, I recently went to a Toyota dealership and I mentioned there was a minor noise coming from the engine. They came back and said they thought I needed a water pump and an alternator. I guess I'm skeptical and certainly don't want to pay for something that isn't needed (especially something so expensive.) If I schedule these services through yourmechanic and the mechanic determines those repairs aren't necessary, what happens? I don't want to waste anyone's time, but also don't want to spend unnecessary money. Thank you.

My car has 85000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Car is making a noise Inspection $79.99 - $99.99 Get a Quote

With regard to the dealership, or any mechanic for that matter, simply ask for the evidence substantiating the diagnosis and proposed repair. In the case of an alternator, once the drive belt is removed from the engine, and the engine is run momentarily, the noise should completely disappear. That does not rule out other rotating components though (driven by the belt) as the source of noise and so the alternator itself must be examined further. In any event, with regard to the replacement of any component on a vehicle, there will always be available tangible evidence substantiating the replacement if the part is really faulty. If you do not obtain a rational or credible response once you request that evidence, that is your indication that there is nothing wrong with the part. Furthermore, any conscientious, professional mechanic who correctly diagnoses a faulty part will be glad to answer your questions, in any degree of detail that you desire, and provide tangible and understandable proof of the diagnostic. If he or she doesn’t, that is not an individual who has your best interests at heart. With regard to the water pump, assuming the pump is not operating dry, water pumps do not typically make noise. If the pump seal or bearing is failing, there is a weep hole adjacent to the pump bearing and the leakage through that weep hole will be noticeable (not necessarily zero leakage, but rather "excessive"). Any significant leakage (again, other than a de minimus leak) does warrant pump replacement. If you want the engine noise conclusively pinpointed, and then learn of the required corrective action (if any is required; not all noises represent failures), please request a vehicle noise diagnostic and the responding certified mechanic will definitely find the origin of the noise. If you have further questions or concerns, do not hesitate to re-contact YourMechanic as we are always here to help you.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $65/hr

What others are asking

Battery dying when I don't drive car very often

If you do not drive your vehicle very often, and when you do it is only a short drive, then yes the mechanic was correct. The battery will last a about a week before needing to be recharged with enough...

Chrysler Pacifica gauges go haywire - I'm told it's an "actuator valve" problem.

The electrical issues are likely caused by a faulty Body Control Module (BCM) and/or a deficient circuit ground and Controller Area Network connections to the PCM and other modules. You principally have an electrical problem and that should be resolved...

Electronics don't work after jumpstart

Jumping a vehicle is a great way to receive instant power. On the other hand this can cause electrical issues if not done correctly. Multiple fuses can blow leaving you with a loss of power to many components in your...

My catalytic converter is rattling and there is smoke coming from my car. Is the catalytic converter faulty?

It is possible the catalytic converter got hot enough to fail on the last trip you took before this started. No pressure from the exhaust is a good sign that the car can't breath. This may be because it cannot...

BMW 2010 x3 fuel filter

Poor mileage has many very common causes other than dirty fuel injectors. However, if a diagnostic (that is, actual tests) suggests that fuel injectors are dirty the only way they can be cleaned is by removing them from the engine...

After installing new spark plugs they soot up after 70 miles

High mileage engines leak oil into the combustion chamber through worn out valve stem oil seals, worn valve guides and ill fitting piston rings. If a substantial amount of oil is entering the combustion chamber the plugs will quickly foul....

Toyota Camry battery light and ABS light came on while driving. 10 minutes later made it home and cut off the car 20 minutes later

It sounds like you may have a weak battery, a failing voltage regulator or failing alternator. When the battery is very weak, this may inadvertently cause other warning lights to come on, such as the ABS light as a result...

When the engine is started, warning lights show up on the dash for a moment and then go away.

Hello. This is perfectly normal. These lights come on at this time as the computer is testing them. As long as the lights are going off once the vehicle is started then there are not any problems.

What does the downhill assist control system do?

If your car is equipped with the downhill assist control (DAC) system (optional equipment), you have the capability of driving down a steep grade without having to use the brakes. This is important because riding your brakes for a long...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Toyota Yaris
The The 2012 Toyota Yaris is a stylish car that offers a three door sedan and five door hatchback model. It has high-tech communication and audio features to make for an entertaining ride. Combined with its reliability and resale, the...
2012 Mazda CX-5 vs. 2012 Toyota RAV4: Which One Should I Buy?
Mid-size crossover SUVs are an excellent option when you need to take several friends along with you, or bring your kids along and yet still need to keep a tight leash on your purchase cost as well as your ongoing...
The Top 5 Selling Cars in Connecticut in 2012
Connecticut Connecticut offers plenty of rain and its fair share of snow during the winter months, which means drivers need vehicles that can handle these conditions. Top selling vehicles in previous years have included the Toyota Camry, Corolla and the...