Q: clutch or gearbox ?????

asked by on August 05, 2016

car broke down, rac towed to garage, quote £500 for clutch but told it probably is a gear box problem, if so is it a right off ?? car purchase £1,800.

My car has 82000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Without more information, such as the symptoms you experienced, it is nearly impossible to determine the cause of your concern. Usually a clutch will wear out before the gearbox.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Over revving and no power going up hill. .

Hi there. The problem lies within the gas pedal. The pedal position sensor has lost its counts and is telling the computer to rev up the engine to a higher count, but the sensor will not deactivate until the brakes...

what is that rickety noise my car makes?

Hello, thanks for writing in. There are a lot of components that will make strange noises on the vehicle. The best thing to do is have someone diagnose the sounds, or attempt to narrow it down yourself. The best way...

About to buy a 2014 / 60K mini countryman s - What are average annual repair costs?

Unfortunately repair costs can vary significantly based on not just the vehicle but also the location that you live in. The parts can be quite expensive for these vehicles as many parts are manufactured by BMW. Also depending on how...

Brake pressure

Hey there. It is possible that the master cylinder has worn out sufficiently that the brake fluid is leaking past the master cylinder piston and seals and into the power brake booster. This would cause a "no firm brake pedal"...

My transmission slips out of fear at high speed but not all the time.

This is a symptom of worn or damaged gears within the transmission. It can also be a mis-adjusted shifter linkage, not allowing the gear to fully engage. If your clutch is going bad, you will notice the engine accelerate faster...

Car abruptly stops in traffic, but engine still on - 2016 Subaru WRX

Hello. There may be a problem in your drivetrain causing such a hard stop. If your brakes were serviced recently, check to see if a fastener may have come loose and is causing the caliper to press against the wheel...

2004 Toyota Matrix won't go into gear

Check to make sure the shift cables are reinstalled correctly. Make sure when the clutch pedal is pushed that the clutch slave cylinder is pushing the shift fork correctly. If you still have issues then contact a qualified mechanic, such...

How Long Does a Clutch Slave Cylinder Last?

The clutch slave cylinder is part of the hydraulic clutch system that includes the hydraulic slave cylinder, master cylinder and metal, and plastic or rubber lines from the master cylinder to the slave cylinder. The slave cylinder may be mounted...

Do you have to remove the transmission to repair the clutch/flywheel on a 2011 Mini Cooper Countryman S?

You do have to remove the transmission transaxle to replace the clutch on this car. If problem did not start until you had clutch done then take back to where clutch was done.

Related articles

How a Clutch Engages and Disengages
In In your car transmission, the clutch is a device that works to engage and disengage the moving parts of your drive shaft. For purposes of this discussion, we’ll focus on manual transmissions. The moving parts are the transmission input...
How an Automatic Transmission Works
An An automatic transmission allows a vehicle engine to operate within a narrow speed range, just like a manual transmission does. As the engine achieves higher degrees of torque (torque is the rotational power of the engine), the gears in...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Clutch Safety Switch
If your manual car is not starting, starts while in gear, or has the Check Engine Light on, you may need to replace the clutch safety switch.