Q: Car intermittently won't start -- this time won't even start when jump started

asked by on September 05, 2017

A few months ago I replaced my alternator and battery. So far it happened twice that the car won't start, with a few weeks in between. It happened after morning commute for both times (i.e. after parking in company lot for a whole day). The symptom is that the dashboard lights are on when the key is inserted, but are shut down when I turn the key to try to start the engine. I can't barely hear any cranking noise. Immediate after a starting attempt the battery seems completely dead (lights are all off) but after a while the lights turn back on, but the engine still can't be started. The first time I found another car to jump start my car and it was OK for a few weeks. This time nothing happens even though I'm connecting my battery to that of a Toyota 4-runner's. I guess something downstream of the battery is broken? Could be the wires connecting the starter, or the starter itself?

My car has 109500 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Electric Problems Inspection $79.99 - $99.99 Get a Quote

Hi Eric M. An issue like you’ve described is very difficult to diagnose without an onsite inspection. If you’re able to activate the starter on a consistent basis, then you can rule that component out as the source of your electrical problem. If the dash lights randomly turn on and off, and you have inconsistent operation of the ignition system, then the root issue may be related to the ignition cylinder itself. Sometimes an exposed wire or electrical short can cause this to occur, while in other instances, electrical wires and connections from the battery or alternator, connected or relayed to the ignition switch or relay can also cause these problems. This is a rather complex issue to attempt to diagnose and resolve, so you might want to have an experienced mechanic help you at your location.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Loss of all acceleration after hard acceleration and check engine like blinking

You could have an engine or transmission problem causing the computer to go into failsafe mode and limit power and would need to have the computer scanned for the failure codes stored for the cause of the problem. You may...

Car is smoking under the hood.

Hi there. The best way to know for sure where the leak is coming from and what is causing the smoke under the hood is to have a professional mobile mechanic come to your location to complete a smoke from...

08 impala has engine power reduced light on. Car starts

Hello, Unfortunately, this is a common issue in many Impalas. This can happen when the catalytic converter is clogged or has also been known to happen when the traction control system has encountered an error. This light comes on as...

For what reason is my car grinding and forcing itself to turn off at low RPM's?

Hi there. The battery could be low on a charge. Check the voltage of the battery and if it's lower than 12.4 volts it will need to charged or replaced. for the grinding noise that you are hearing, either the...

My car started shaking really bad.

Shaking or vibrating may be caused by many different things such as faulty spark plugs, poor fuel pressure or misfires. Other things such as a faulty idle air control valve may cause the engine idle to drop below the normal...

Cold start?

Hi there. Ambient temperature can affect any number of electrical components. There could be a poor electrical connection in the power distribution center. The fact that the check engine light is not coming on once the engine does start leads...

Engine was swapped. I need to know how to tell if they put 1.8 or 2.0 back in?

Each of those engine sizes have unique casting numbers embossed on the head, block, etc. The casting numbers for the 1.8L are Block Cast # 5M0; In-Line Head Cast # 5M0; Cam Cast # 5M0-5M0 or 4M5-4M5; and Crankshaft...

TCS (Traction Control System) light is sometimes on

Hello, most often this problem is due to a dirty or faulty wheel speed sensor. Wheel speed sensors provide critical information to both the ABS and traction control systems (TCS). To determine which wheel speed sensor is bad (or other...

Brakes catch first thing

For an issue like this, a certified mechanic will need to inspect the vehicle and determine exactly where the problem is located. However, it sounds to me like you have a problem with a sticking caliper or a fluid leak....

Related articles

The Top 5 Selling Cars in Kansas in 2012
Kansas Kansas sees a varied climate with all four seasons, which means drivers in the area choose a variety of vehicles. In years past, some of the front-runners have included the Ford F-150, Buick and Toyota Camry. 2012’s top five...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're a Dog Breeder or Trainer
These These days, dogs are more and more likely to travel with people than ever before. After all, what dog doesn’t ride in a car? As a breeder and trainer though, you’re probably more likely to carry along dogs than...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Honda Fit
The The 2012 Honda Fit is a fuel efficient car that has lots of head and legroom for drivers and passengers alike. In addition, its five door configuration holds large items like skis, bikes, and surfboards for those who love...