Q: Buying a lease vs. renting a car

asked by on April 13, 2016

These days--would you recommend to buy a lease or rent a car?

I’m cheap. I buy them, but I buy them used and I don’t pay much and I drive them for 10, 20 or 30 years. But, that’s just me. The problem with leasing a car is this: if you lease a car you are paying for a car for the rest of your life (or until you buy a car) by monthly payments. I buy used cars and I’ve been driving cars for 48 years, and granted I’m a mechanic. In the entire 48 years, on my own personal cars, I’ve spent less than 6500 dollars for them all when totaled together.

If you are leasing cars over a 48-year period, you’ve probably spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on that. Now, if you have a business and you can write the lease off, like doctors and lawyers in their Jaguars and BMWs and Mercedes, then go right ahead. It’s a free tax right-off for a business expense. But, you are going to be ripped if you lease a car, because you are paying all your life for a car. You should get a good used car or a new car that is going to last you for a long time and so that your investment goes towards your property.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I use the windshield wiper mist feature in a 2012 Chevrolet Equinox?
The windshield wiper mist feature is perfect for when there’s a one-time occurrence of moisture on your windshield. To use the mist feature, locate the windshield wiper lever that protrudes from the right side of your steering column. Pull the...
Car difficult to start, wants to die
Usually when a car is misfiring and running rough, there are a few different things that could be the cause. If the vehicle doesn't have enough air when starting or driving, the vehicle will want to misfire or stumble, there...
What is the price of a new 2008 jeep commander engine 3.7?
Sent CS a billing question on the price of a new 3.7L engine for a 2008 Jeep Commander.
My car will turn over, but dies a second later unless I keep my foot on the gas. It happened randomly, I drove it fine an hour bef
Hi there: It's possible that you have damage to your fuel pump, mass air flow sensor or a vacuum leak that is causing your 2002 Dodge Intrepid to stall quickly. The best way to know for certain is to have...
Barometric Pressure Sensor Error Code
The next step would be to do a proper full pinpoint test indication in the troubleshooting charts for the code that you got. This test will check the wiring, connections, ECM connections and the ECM itself. If you do not...
After ice storm my car won't start.
Hi there. Check the starter wires and make sure that they are tight and clean. If the wires are good, then try tapping on the starter solenoid. If you hear a click when trying to start the engine, then the...
Hey what is the part behind the idler pulley on a 2006 Honda Civic? There is a big crack and I want to know what part it is.
Hi there. Seems to be the tensioner to the idler pulley is cracked. Remove the drive belt from the engine and check the pulley tensioner and see if it can move around. I recommend seeking out a professional, such as...
I have a 90 honda accord,while driving headlights go dim then eventually car dies out and wont start up
What you are describing sounds like an ignition coil pack that may be failing. Ignition coils are prone to this type of erratic functioning or heat cycling when they are beginning to fail due to the temperature fluctuations under the...
Question about buying radiator for 1999 ford ranger v4 2.5l
Hi Javier. Thanks for the question today. In cases like this, you want to replace what you currently have active, as it's possible that the previous owner has removed the OEM transmission cooler, which may be the reason for the...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Chrysler 200
In In 2011, Chrysler completely overhauled, updated, and remodeled their entire line, including the introduction of the new Chrysler 200. This reimagining of the old, boring Dodge Sebring sedan was already an exciting move for Chrysler, and the 2012 Chrysler...
How to Buy a Good Quality Brake Wheel Cylinder
Drum Drum brakes, which are still in use today on the rear of many vehicles, operate on a hydraulic basis, using brake fluid to apply pressure to pistons in the wheel cylinder, which in turn presses the brake shoes against...
How to Decipher the EPA's Fuel Economy Label
The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), in conjunction with the National Highway Safety Administration (NHTSA), puts out a series of labels for motor vehicles of varying fuel types. The labels allow car shoppers to compare the various fuel mileage (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-to-determine-your-vehicle-s-gas-mileage-and-octane-requirements-by-mark-vallet) numbers...