Q: After fuel pump replacment, car uses more gasoline

asked by on August 17, 2016

My car has 25,000 miles and the fuel pump went out, so I had it replaced. Now the car seems to be using more gas than it did before the replacement. To explain: the dots on the fuel gauge move down quickly, but the gauge itself still indicates that the car is getting 25-26 mpg. It just isn’t making sense. I have driven my car for several years and I am always aware of how much gasoline that my car uses and recently it is literally drinking it. Before I call the service center, can you tell me if this sounds like this might be a problem resulting from the fuel pump replacement?

There is always a chance of something going wrong with a repair, but let’s not start there. There may be a new concern, such as a vacuum leak or a sensor causing false readings. Since there was a recent repair, start the diagnosis by double checking the work, and if there are no faults found, the next step would be to check the engine seals and electronics. If you would like this checked for you, a local expert from YourMechanic can come to you to inspect the perceived decrease in mileage in order to have this resolved.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Lights melted the headlights
Hello! Thank you for writing in about this problem. This issue is common in 2005-2011 Tacoma models. Toyota recently released Technical Service Bulletin (TSB) TC-14-025 that specifically covers this problem. An extended warranty has been placed on the headlamp assemblies...
Wheel locked up
Hi. The parking brake system on the Maxima uses 3 cables. One control cable from the handle, and one cable going to each rear wheel brake caliper. A visible inspection of both calipers needs to be administered with both the...
Power steering fluid leak
The best way to locate a fluid leak of any kind is to first clean the entire area that the leak is suspected to be coming from. Then allow time for the area to dry or use compressed air to...
My car shakes while driving and braking? What could the problem be?
Hello. The rack and pinion typically will not cause this. It is either caused by a warped rotor, a failing bearing or a tire that is separating. Typically if it is the brake rotors it will only wobble when using...
Exhaust manifold pipe rusted off.
Hey there, thanks for writing in. You would need to have it metal clamped or welded on at an exhaust shop. Welding it will give you a better seal if the rest of the pipe is not damaged or rusted....
If cylinder 3 misfires is that a bad thing?
Hi there. A misfiring cylinder can be expensive if allowed to continue. The catalytic converter can be damaged. If the cylinder is misfiring, the coil, wire, and/or spark plug could be the cause. First swap the spark plug between cylinder...
I have a p0410 code yet my air pump does operate however the flow doesn't seem to be very strong?
There is probably a filter in the pump and yes the filter could block flow. However, before you consider a plugged filter, inspect the check valves; they will commonly get plugged up or stuck. The pump flow is minimal and...
Have had altanator checked . A new battery put in 2 months ago . Was struggling to turn on after a couple days after new battery w
It is possible that the battery is not being properly recharged by the car's alternator, there is a parasitic load that is draining the battery while the car is off, or there is a deficiency in the starter motor or...
03 accord consumes a lot of gas
The crack in the intake hose should be repaired. Based on EPA data, you should be getting around 21 MPG city and 31 MPG highway driving. Overall, you should get around 25 MPG. If your results are at least 10%...

Related articles

Top 10 Bad Driving Habits That Damage Your Car
Even the best drivers are guilty of bad driving habits. Riding the brakes, not warming up the engine, and ignoring warning signs will damage your car.
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Fuel Pressure Regulator
Common signs include engine performance issues, fuel leaks, and black smoke coming from the exhaust.
How Long Does a Fuel Filler Neck Last?
Getting Getting gas from the pump to your gas tank is the only way to keep a car going. The fuel filler neck is a metal tube that is welded to the gas tank of a car. The gas cap...