Q: 2010 VW caddy 1.9 TDI- flywheel installation issue

asked by on January 04, 2017

I had to install a new Dual Mass Flywheel after a catastrophic clutch failure. While putting on the bell housing it appears to have scraped a small divot out of the smooth part of the rear of the flywheel, no damage to the teeth. Do I have to buy a new one and start over?

While it stay stable despite the slight gouging? For reference it is probably 1/8 in deep at the deepest, but it's approx 2 inches long. I'm just worried it can't stay balanced while spinning. I sure hope it's fine. This model flywheel was $600 (including clutch). Not to mention it's a beast of a job.
My car has a manual transmission.

Clutch is not working Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

I have to wonder if what you are actually looking at is a relief cut in the flywheel that is in the outer perimeter near the ring gear. It’s hard for me to imagine that you could really do significant damage to the flywheel installing the transmission unless you were really brutal with it. The factory relief cut is pretty clean and regular. If what you have looks like a gouge though, it probably is a gouge. My guess is that under normal driving conditions you might get away with it. But it’s difficult to say without seeing the flywheel itself. If you are driving the car as a high performance car, and really spinning the engine up, any imbalance could cause you trouble. If you decide you’ve had enough and want to delegate this job, you can contact Your Mechanic to have a technician come out to your home and look at this project and tell you what can be done with it.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Air bag light staying on and now the car won't start.
There has seen many same complaints of the air bag light on these vehicles and may be a manufacturer problem at this point. I would not recommend any one attempt a repair unless they are qualified to do so. The...
Car not starting up.
If your car is cranking but doesn't start, that points toward a spark or fuel delivery problem because there is only three basic requirements to run spark, fuel and compression. Have a certified mechanic inspect (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/car-is-not-starting-inspection) for fuel pressure spark...
Gas gauge malfunctioning and Service Engine Light on
Thank you for asking about your 2006 GMC Sierra 1500 HD. More than likely, the problem is the fuel sensor, which is built into the fuel sending unit. This assembly is mounted in the gas tank. This is a common...
Purge control solenoid stuck open, hard to start after refuling
Hello. If the computer is saying that the purge valve is stuck open it is usually because there is an EVAP leak in the system. If the purge valve is new I usually check the wiring and the signal going...
Brake piston compressed rather than turning
The rear calipers on this vehicle incorporate the parking brake system. The parking brake system uses a rotating screw inside the caliper that will push the caliper piston out when parking brake lever is rotated on the caliper. When the...
2011 dodge charger rear-end replacement
Unfortunately, replacing a rear end is not a service that yourmechanic.com can provide. A local repair or dealership service facility would be your best choice for this repair.
Engine sounds loud when first started then quiets down. Should I be concerned? 2012 Dodge Ram
Hi there - your symptoms suggest an oil supply or oil deliver issue when the engine is first started. Check the oil level first, then check to see what "weight" oil (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/what-type-of-oil-should-i-use) (i.e. 10W30) was used for the last oil...
I need the location for the oIL pressure sensor on the wife's 2013 ford flex
The switch is threaded into the engine block toward the front of the car. You may have to remove the underbody cover to see it and get physical access with the special socket that is used to remove this style...
My car won't go in 2nd gear
If you can select all other gears but 2nd, then the issue is likely to be internal to the transmission (as opposed to the clutch). To be sure, the external shift mechanism should be inspected but if that checks out,...

Related articles

A Buyer's Guide to the 2012 Volkswagen Beetle
Although Although it may be one of the most recognizable cars on the road, thanks to its unique design, perhaps you’ve never considered owning a Volkswagen Beetle before. There are a number of reasons the 2012 model should have you...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Volkswagen Golf R
The The Volkswagen Golf R has all-wheel drive, two or four door options, and a turbocharged engine for those who want a little extra power. The Golf R is upgraded from the GTI, giving it better handling and more aggressive...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Clutch Slave Cylinder
If your manual car has abnormal pedal feel, low or contaminated brake fluid, or any visible leaks, you may need to replace the clutch slave cylinder.