Why Can’t I Top Off My Tank? | YourMechanic Advice

Why Can’t I Top Off My Tank?

Nearly everyone who has been behind the wheel of a vehicle has pumped gas into the fuel tank until the tank was full. When the tank is full, the nozzle makes a ‘clunk’ sound and the gas stops flowing. The nozzle is able to determine when the tank is sufficiently full and shuts off the flow both for safety reasons and for the benefit of the fuel vapor canister.

Even though it seems unlikely to have a part in the fuel system that is specifically not meant to hold liquid fuel, the fuel vapor canister plays an important role that most people don’t even know exists.

When gas is a gas...

Gasoline is usually abbreviated as just ‘gas’. This is a funny nickname, given that a gas is by definition not a liquid; but ‘gas’ is a liquid… or is it? Gasoline produces vapor that is explosive, toxic, and highly volatile. A cloud of vapor is also a lot harder to spot than a puddle of gasoline, so it is much less visible while being significantly more dangerous.

In the past, cars have relied on gas caps that allow the vapor to vent from the fuel tank to prevent pressure from building up. While this protected the fuel tank, the environmental consequences were severe. Gas vapor is an unpleasant gas that negatively affects breathable air, and is a big contributor to smog and poor air conditions in urban areas.

Unsurprisingly, modern cars have a much better solution to the problem of gas vapor in the fuel tank; and that solution is a fuel vapor canister. This neat little part is filled with carbon, like the filter in an aquarium, which keeps vapors in check and allows the vaporized gas from the tank (and carburetor if applicable) to re-enter the fuel system and get burned up in the engine. Liquid fuel reduces the effectiveness of this canister and can cause enough damage to render the vapor canister completely useless. This will lead to an expensive repair but it can be easily prevented.

Do not top off the tank after the valve in the nozzle stops the flow of fuel.

There are many ways to get around the little mechanism in the pump nozzle that stops the flow of fuel once the tank is sufficiently full. Some people keep pulling on the handle, making the pump stop over and over until they are positive it is full. Others lift the nozzle out of the filler neck to prevent the valve from closing. Either way, this practice can get liquid fuel into the vapor canister and can also cause gas to spill out onto the ground.

Spilled gas is an unnecessary hazard, and gas stations go to great lengths to prevent it. Topping off the tank can cause gas to splash out of the filler neck onto the person pumping and the ground around them. The best-case scenario after this happens is a car interior that now smells like gasoline. The worst-case scenario would involve a lot of fire and avoidable insurance claims.

You cannot top off the fuel tank because the fuel pump nozzle will alert the person pumping when there is a sufficient amount of gas in the tank by shutting off the flow. Even though it is possible to add more gas after this point, it is not advisable.


Next Step

Schedule Oil Change

The most popular service booked by readers of this article is Oil Change. YourMechanic’s technicians bring the dealership to you by performing this job at your home or office 7-days a week between 7AM-9PM. We currently cover over 2,000 cities and have 100k+ 5-star reviews... LEARN MORE

SEE PRICING & SCHEDULING

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Recent Oil Change reviews

Excellent Rating

(21,049)

Rating Summary
19,750
838
175
85
201
19,750
838
175
85
201

Shawn

11 years of experience
121 reviews
Shawn
11 years of experience
Toyota Camry - Oil Change - Lancaster, Pennsylvania
On time. Explained everything that was done and noted an issues that had occurred from a prior oil change that I could take up with the previous garage. I highly recommend Shawn.
Mercedes-Benz C300 - Oil Change - Norristown, Pennsylvania
Arrived on time and was very professional. Helped me diagnose a potential alternator issue. Was very polite and easy to work with.

Pardeep

20 years of experience
812 reviews
Pardeep
20 years of experience
BMW X5 - Oil Change - Santa Clara, California
Pradeep was punctual, informative, knowledgable and professional throughout . I would highly recommend him .
Ford Expedition - Oil Change - Saratoga, California
Called and came much sooner. Did a prompt and neat job. Friendly and very easy to communicate with. Recommend, based on my experience.

Stacy

23 years of experience
281 reviews
Stacy
23 years of experience
Audi A6 Quattro - Oil Change - Atlanta, Georgia
Very, very kind and thoughtful young man! I was very pleased with his demeanor and class! Quite an asset to your Co. Also a good mechanic, thank you for sending him!
Scion xA - Oil Change - Atlanta, Georgia
Quickly rotated my tires & oil change. Let’s me know what is going on with my vehicle during the process. Highly recommended.

Tinashe

12 years of experience
447 reviews
Tinashe
12 years of experience
Mazda 3 - Oil Change - Atlanta, Georgia
I have used Tinashe multiple times for my vehicle service. He is always quick and thorough with his top-quality work. I have never been disappointed!
Ford F-350 Super Duty - Oil Change - Alpharetta, Georgia
Tinashe I feel did a great job as he listened to my request and handled what I needed done. I will be requesting him again.

Need Help With Your Car?

Our certified mobile mechanics make house calls in over 2,000 U.S. cities. Fast, free online quotes for your car repair.

GET A QUOTE

Related articles

Symptoms of Bad or Failing Fuel Injector O Rings
Common signs include an odor of fuel in the car, fuel leaks, and the Check Engine Light coming on.
How Long Does a Fuel Filler Neck Last?
Getting Getting gas from the pump to your gas tank is the only way to keep a car going. The fuel filler neck is a metal tube that is welded to the gas tank of a car. The gas cap...
Does Gasoline Expire?
Gasoline Gasoline does expire if it is left unused for a long period of time. The problem with gas is its volatility. A volatile substance is prone to separating and vaporizing. This is especially bad if the fuel vapor has...

Related questions

Car only start when cold but dies once warm and wont start till complete cold

You may have more than one issue going on here for your 1987 Toyota Celica. The cold starting issue could possibly be caused by a failing fuel pump or even a temperature sensor. Heat increases resistance in electrical circuits, and...

What is the onboard refueling vapor recovery system?

Fuel vapors are pollutants – they create hydrocarbons in the atmosphere and add to the smog choking many US cities. Your Accord has quite a few different emissions control systems, including an onboard refueling vapor recovery system. When you fill...

replacing a crankshaft sesor in a suzuki XL7

Hi there, thanks for writing in about your 2008 Suzuki. It may be caused by a timing belt that has jumped a tooth. A bad crank sensor will typically cause the ignition to not fire at all. For a more...

How can we help?

Our service team is available 7 days a week, Monday - Friday from 6 AM to 5 PM PST, Saturday - Sunday 7 AM - 4 PM PST.

1 (855) 347-2779 · hi@yourmechanic.com