Q: What is the difference between replacing a head gasket and replacing the engine?

asked by on July 20, 2017

I want to know if I should replace my head gasket or the entire engine. Which I cheaper?

My car has 188000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Hi there. This is a very good question actually. When it comes to ’which is cheaper’, it’s important to understand the common problems that come with a head gasket replacement or an engine swap. When you compare the basic services, repairing a blown head gasket is always the least expensive initial repair. The problem is that most of the time, when a head gasket is damaged, other components like the cylinder head itself, pistons, and cylinder head hardware are often damaged as well. These issues are not commonly replaced during a head gasket replacement job. It’s also common for electrical harnesses and other engine components to be damaged when a car overheats and causes the head gasket failure. In the end - replacing the engine is typically the best ’value’ - especially when you’re going to keep the vehicle for an extended period of time.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $65/hr

What others are asking

Electric Cooling Fan Remains On Even When Car is turned off

The radiator fan will be controlled by the engine ECU (electronic control unit) through a relay. The relay is most likely your problem. When the fan shuts off, it can cause a small arc on the relay points that will...

What does the tire pressure Warning Light mean?

The tire pressure Warning Light is located on the instrument panel. If the light is solidly illuminated, then one of the tires is experiencing dangerously low tire pressure. Check your tire pressure and adjust as you need to bring them...

Brakes squeaking as I reverse out of garage

You are correct about the noise happening when the rotors get wet and then sit overnight they will get a light film of rust on the rotors and this will cause a squeak in the brakes until you stop a...

my car does not move in any gear

You've probably lost a CV joint. The CV joint is a joint that enables the front wheels to be under power even though they are steering. When the joint fails, the transmission looses its connection to the wheels so it...

4wd engages but vehicle bucks like 4wd is slipping.

There is likely an internal issue going on within your transfer case. The most common cause of transfer case slippage is low fluid. I suggest that the transfer case fluid condition and level is checked. If the two wheel drive...

What's wrong with my car

The oil light will come on if the oil pressure drops too low for adequate lubrication of moving parts in the engine. If the light does come on, you should quickly shut off the engine, but only once you are...

How often should I change brake fluid?

You should replace the fluid every time you do a brake job or every 3 years. The only time to get it done when not scheduled is if it get contaminated with wrong fluids.

There is a delay when the car tries to shift into the next gear

This may be related to the transmission being low on fluid or potentially a bad transmission control solenoid. As you may know, every time a gear change is required, the car's computer activates a transmission solenoid, which directs transmission fluid...

P0420 code comes back repeatedly, emissions readiness issue. Takes about a week for Check Engine Light to come back on.

If this is the only code that keeps coming up, and the data stream on the oxygen sensors are reacting correctly, the only real other thing left would be the convertor. If there was a wiring issue, or a sensor...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Toyota Camry Hybrid
More More and more manufacturers are offering their most popular passenger cars in hybrid models, and America’s top-selling passenger car is no exception. The 2012 Toyota Camry Hybrid is fuel-efficient, comfortable, and convenient. Key Features The upgraded HSD (hybrid synergy...
Top 10 Best-Selling Cars of 2016
Ford F-series pickup trucks, Toyota Camry, and Honda Civic are some of the best-selling cars of 2016 and all deliver on reliability and efficiency.
How to Turn Off the Reverse Beep in a Prius
The The Toyota Prius is designed to shut off the engine when stopped as an energy-conserving measure. When the accelerator is depressed, it starts to back up, so you can go about your business on the road. When your Prius...