Q: What Is the Difference Between a Water-Cooled Engine and an Air-Cooled Engine?

asked by on December 01, 2015

What is the difference between a water-cooled engine and an air-cooled engine?

Car is overheating Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

There are a few main differences between a water-cooled and air-cooled engine.

Air-cooled engines utilize an engine cylinder design that incorporates cooling fins all the way around the cylinder and on top of the piston cylinder head. These fins draw heat away from the cylinder and radiate away the heat. As the vehicle is being driven, the air is directed over the fins to dissipate even more heat. Some vehicles may incorporate a belt driven or electric fan to blow across the fins to assist in keeping the engine cool. Some engines use the hot air off of the engine to heat the interior of the passenger compartment. Engines that are cooled by air have a harder time maintaining a constant operating engine temperature. This can affect engine operation during colder conditions or extreme heat conditions.

Instead of fins used to keep the engine cool, in water-cooled engines the engine block and heads are cast solid but with internals passages throughout the engine block around the cylinders and over the cylinder in the cylinder head. The engine will utilize a water pump that is connected to these passages on the engine. The water pump can be driven by belt, gear or electric motor. The system has a radiator that is used to radiate the heat away from the water (coolant) that flows through the motor. A thermostat is put into a passageway from the engine to the radiator. The water or coolant temperature is maintained by the thermostat. The thermostat controls flow of coolant into the radiator. As the water pump is turned, the coolant is pumped through the engine. The coolant absorbs and transfers the engine’s heat from the combustion process. As the coolant gets heated, the thermostat will allow the flow to be restricted to the radiator until the coolant temperature reaches a set temperature of around 190 degrees at which time it opens the flow to the radiator. The coolant then flows into the radiator and the coolant heat is transferred to the radiator fins to be dissipated out to the surrounding air like the fins on the air-cooled engine. The radiator has electric or mechanical fans to blow air across the cooling fins. The thermostat opens and closes as needed to maintain a constant engine internal coolant temperature; engine temperature is controlled better that air cooled engines. The coolant can also be routed into the passenger compartment to flow through a small radiator called a heater core to heat the interior of the vehicle.

Some engines may use a hybrid design that uses a water-cooling system mixed with some of the air-cooled engine traits to help keep the engine cool and to lighten the added weight of a full-size water cooling system. These systems may use smaller radiators or thin lightweight radiators and engine designs that have air cooled areas to dissipate heat.

The advantages of air-cooled engines are that they are lighter without the use of radiators, water pumps, thermostats, coolant, or hoses. The disadvantages are that they cannot warm up fast and cannot maintain a constant engine temperature. This will affect engine performance and emissions in climate changes like extreme cold or hot temperatures. A cold engine requires added fuel to run properly.

The advantages of water-cooled engines are that they can warm up quickly and maintain the engine temperature better than the air-cooled design. This helps maintain engine performance and emissions. The disadvantages of a water-cooled engine is the added weight of the engine design along with added weight of the cooling system components like the radiator, water pump, coolant, and hoses.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I use the convenience net?
The convenience net can be used to store small loads in the trunk. To use the convenience net, simply attach it to the cargo tie-downs. Be careful not to hold a very heavy load in the convenience net.
How do I open the fuel tank door?
Before filling up your car with gas, you will need to open the fuel tank door. This is a very easy task: Lift up on the fuel filler door opener, which is located underneath the driver’s seat, directly next to...
Bad key or ignition switch
Hi, the car is still fairly new and it is rare for the ignition switch to fail so early. Does the security light on the dash light up and flash when trying to start the car? This would mean the...
The transmission is slipping.
Hi, thanks for writing in. It seems that the clutch disc is most likely worn to the point that the pressure plate cannot fully engage and lock the clutch to the engine. If that is the case, you will need...
The car stalled out and the battery and oil light came on
When a car has that many miles on it, it could be just about anything. The temptation is to go shooting in the dark and just start replacing parts until the car works again. That method can get very expensive,...
Driver headlight having issues.
Check your fuses box for the headlights. Also possible there is a headlight relay which may have failed. Since only one side has failed, it could be a wiring problem to that one headlight (or a ground issue with that...
Fuel gauge stuck
This is a problem likely related to your fuel tank sending unit. The fuel tank sending unit is a small float type component (or sensor) inside your fuel tank that measures the level of the fuel inside the tank. As...
Would a blown coolant hose, at heater core, cause loss of power?
Yes, severe overheating will cause loss of engine power and also has a high potential to damage the engine as the pistons scuff the cylinder walls and the exhaust valves stick in the valve guides. If the overheating is severe...
We have a 1992 Chrysler lebarron convertible. When it rains the driver side floor holds water as well as the back floor on driver
There are several pathways that will admit rainwater and leave it where you have described. The leak can be pinpointed if you request a vehicle water leak diagnostic (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/clear-fluid-is-leaking-inspection). If you request that service, the responding certified mechanic will get...

Related articles

Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Thermo Coolant Fan Switch
Common signs include engine overheating, the Check Engine Light coming on, and a broken or shorter signal wire.
How to Troubleshoot a Faulty Car Thermostat
When you are concerned about the routine maintenance of your car, it is natural to get to a point where you will ask yourself,...
The Difference Between a Sports Car Engine and a Regular Engine
While they are similar in modern design, most everyday car engines are optimized for fuel efficiency and sports car engines for speed and performance.