Q: Starter, alternator, or battery?

asked by on November 03, 2016

Car died the other day mechanic said my cars alternator was running 12.5 volts instead of the 15 it is supposed to run but it should be fine for a while. I turned my car off later the night and it would not turn back on the next morning, my neighbor jumped it again and it stayed on but once again after turning off it wouldn't start Could it be that I killed my battery completely or is it my alternator.
My car's transmission is unknown to me.

Car is hard to start Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote
Alternator Replacement $166.62 - $1297.14 Get a Quote
Battery Replacement $247.05 - $377.49 Get a Quote
Starter Replacement $169.22 - $1153.49 Get a Quote

Hi there. In most cases, when you’re pulling less than 15 volts from the alternator the issue is caused by an internal component failure within the alternator itself or the alternator relay. If the starter is not receiving the correct amps, it’s the battery that is at fault. With this type of situation, the best recommendation is to have a professional mechanic complete a no start inspection first. From there, they can determine if your VW issues are caused by the alternator, battery, or the starter. It may be a combination of two that need to be replaced - especially if the battery has not been replaced in the last few years.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I program the universal remote system?
Located on the headliner between the driver and passenger, the universal remote is comprised of 3 buttons. These buttons are programmable so that you can program them to work with your garage door. For a rolling code style garage door...
Car idles rough with sputtering - 2014 Cadillac ATS
Hi! You are right in thinking that since it is a new vehicle you should not be experiencing these issues. It may be a dirty throttle body that is causing the idle (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/car-idle-is-rough-inspection) quality problems. They can be cleaned. As...
Head Gasket
Hello. Unfortunately, there is not really anyway to tell whether or not a genuine head gasket was replaced or sealer used. I would recommend having an expert from YourMechanic come to your home to take a look at the car...
Tiny pin sized hole on hot water heater elbow connection
Hello, thanks for writing in about your Mazda. I believe the component you are describing is part of the heater core where the coolant hoses from the engine connect at the firewall. Most likely these copper or aluminum pipes are...
The front driver's side wheel feels wobbly while driving
Excess wheel play can be caused by several components. You will want to perform certain tests in a process of elimination to target the issue. Brakes and particularly the rotors can cause similar issues. You would notice the symptoms when...
Air conditioner blows warm air.
The most common cause for warm air when the air conditioner is commanded on is a low refrigerant charge, usually from a leak. One way to check the charge is to have a technician attach a manifold gauge set and...
Cost to fix: Spark plug #4 on passenger side blew out of its cylinder. Common on 5.4 Tritons. only need this spark plug 2000 Ford F150
Hi there. Unfortunately, this is a service that requires advanced machining tools; which our mobile mechanics don't typically have access to on site. As such, it's not a service we provide at YourMechanic.com. You might be better served contacting a...
is a purge valve solinoid the same as a evaporation vent soliniod?
In the EVAP system, the purge valve and the vent control valve are separate parts with different functions. If the gas mileage you are getting is very low, there is probably a fault in addition to the EVAP system fault....
Extreme negative fuel trims only when coasting, with rpm bounce
Fuel trim is a very valuable diagnostic parameter but to evaluate fuel trim, you generally check at fixed engine speeds namely idle, 1,500 rpm and 2,500 rpm, for about 30 seconds. If the sum of STFT and LTFT is less...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Volkswagen Golf
The The 2012 Volkswagen Golf offers comfort and an elegant design for a variety of transportation needs. The Golf is a solid vehicle, good size, and great value, especially when it comes to comparing prices of similar vehicles. Key Features...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Battery Cable
If you experience problems starting and powering the car or find corrosion on the battery terminals, you may need to replace a battery cable.
Industry News for Automotive Techs: October 1-7
Wireless electric car charging, VW diesel scandal payouts, 3D-printed car technology, new Cardone car parts, and high September auto sales.