Q: Should I get rid of my car?

asked by on January 17, 2017

My 2004 Mercury Monteray has 94K miles. Purchased it 3 years ago from a dealer who showed all the work was done by the dealer and not one item was skipped. Purchased at 60K miles. Now at 94K miles there has been a transmission slip. It's sporadic and had disappeared for the past two weeks. The slip was there for about a month. So, with the mileage, I don't want to replace the transmission anytime soon. it's about $3500. The car is only worth about that much. Should I sell it?

If so, should I go for a used Toyota Highlander with no warranty, or a Certified Preowned Dodge Journey with 7 year 100K mile warranty?

Car is hard to shift Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

Transmissions are often repairable in the field, on or off the car. The cost of the repair will depend on exactly what has gone wrong with the transmission and so the best thing to do is get the issue properly diagnosed so that you can make an informed decision about how to proceed. Some transmission faults arise because the the fluid level is too low, there could be a plugged filter, faulty shift solenoids or other frankly mundane and easily (on the car) repairable faults. As far as the larger issue of how to decide between repairing a car that you already own versus buying "another" car, the economically relevant comparison is the total cost of the repair(s) versus the total cost of the alternative. In particular, the current "market" value of your car is irrelevant to ANY calculation because the simple fact of the matter is if and once your present car is repaired, it will be fully functional and provide the exact same transportation service you would get if you bought "another" car. The bottom line is, if your goal is to minimize your total cost, there are really only two numbers to compare: the cost to fix what you have versus the cost of buying another car. I have performed this calculation, and used this strategy, uncounted times over four decades: you will almost always be better off, often much better off, just fixing what you have and not buying "another" car. If you desire that the problem with the transmission be diagnosed by a certified Mechanic, dispatched by YourMechanic right to your location, please request a transmission shift diagnostic and the responding certified mechanic will get this resolved for you. If you have further questions or concerns, please do not hesitate to re-contact YourMechanic as we are always here to help you, particularly if you just need more information to make wise, informed decision.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

My car stopped while driving and wont go into gear

Hi there. What seemed to happen is transmission may have broke a something inside it like a thrust bearing or a drive sun shell. This is common for the transmission to do on normal driving as the vehicle ages. I...

Feels like car isn't shifting into second gear, cant go over 20mph in drive.

There is an issue with the transmission is the main valve either is disconnected inside the transmission oil pan on the controller or the controller has an internal leak or a check ball is not holding. I recommend seeking out...

Car crawls when first put in drive. When I stop at a stop sign the engine cuts off. 2001 Buick Park Avenue

This is a transmission internal problem most likely by solenoids sticking or the clutches are worn out. Have the transmission pressures tested to diagnose the transmission problem to see if solenoids work properly and if pressures are good. if they...

Transmission issues, slips from second to fourth gear

I would start by being concerned about these wires that are spliced in. If there is another circuit that is spliced in there then it can be causing this. If there was no issue previously then it may not be...

Replaced the air conditioning line twice due to rust

Hello. I would suggest that you get the A/C lines replaced again. Next time the A/C is recharged make sure they completely flush the system by adding fluid back into it, as crazy as it sounds. It's possible to flush it...

car makes a sandpaper rubbing type noise, the rpms don't want to go up as usually it shifts gears very weird

Hello. It sounds like the vehicle may have an issue with the drivetrain such as a transmission malfunction or a wheel bearing being bad. When some wheel bearings go bad they will lock up and cause your car to feel...

2012 genesis 3.8 shifts hard. What cost am I looking at to replace transmission

The shift issue should be diagnosed first especially considering the low miles on the transmission. It would be unusual for a transmission with only 78,000 miles on it to require total replacement (versus on the vehicle service). Anytime you are...

Antifreeze keep running out and overheating now

Hello there, you have a few problems with your 2007 Nissan Altima. If coolant ran out after it was put in there is a leak somewhere in the system. The most common places for a leak are the radiator, coolant...

I am thinking of buying a 98 Lexus LS400 with 200,000 mi for $3000. IT runs great and is in beautiful condition. Check Engine light is on 1998 Lexus LS400

Hello - as to the starter question, if the starter starts to spin immediately after you turn the key to the "Start" position, spins the motor over briskly without strange noises, hot or cold - the starter is probably fine....

Related articles

How to Check the Quality of a Used Car
If you’re looking to purchase a car, buying a used vehicle is a great way to save money. Used cars are usually cheaper than new ones and you may be able to buy them without having to take out a...
How to Fix Car Dents
Fixing car dents can be easier than you might think. You can use a plunger, dry ice, or a hairdryer to fix dents in your car body.
What Does an Engine Inspection Entail?
An engine inspection is the first step in diagnosing engine problems. A pre-purchase engine inspection helps you know if a used car is a good deal.