Q: ok, so my Kwik Kar oil change place told me the oil pan needs to be replaced because the drain plug is stripped. So they put a la

asked by on July 05, 2017

So my oil change tech told me the oil pan plug was stripped and I need a new oil pan. They put in a bigger plug temporarily. Two Qs: 1. They want $600 for a new pan parts and labor. This seems excessive esp. given that they may have been the ones who stripped the plug! 2. I can get a new pan on line for $60 or so - they want $250 for it. Should I spring for the $75 steel one or is the $60 aluminum one good enough? Seems like aluminum would strip again easily... we live in Texas so no road salt or freezing really... Thanks, Eric

My car has 170000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Oil Pan Replacement $270.38 - $1291.91 Get a Quote

Hi Eric. Sorry to hear this happened to you. Oil pan’s bolts don’t typically "just strip". It’s typically always due to either over tightening, or cross threading. The problem is trying to prove whether it occurred with the previous oil change or this last one. Regardless, these companies wouldn’t typically cover this type of damage. As such, this is a perfect example of where having one of our professional mobile mechanics come to your location to complete a oil pan replacement will most likely be the most affordable and correct option. You can request an estimate by clicking this link to the service page. Once on that page, select the Get a Quote blue button and enter your vehicle information. Once we receive the data, we’ll email you a quote.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $65/hr

What others are asking

How do I turn on the heated mirrors?

The heated mirrors are a safety feature that can increase visibility out of the side mirrors. The heated mirrors help get rid of condensation, fog, and ice from the mirrors, so that you can see better out of them. To...

Can you operate safely with the trunk lid open?

Having the trunk open while the engine is running is not a wise idea, although it may be necessary in some instances. Your car’s exhaust contains carbon monoxide, which is toxic and cannot be seen or smelled. If the trunk...

Engine knocking noise in 2003 Honda Civic

A knocking noise is never a good sign on an engine. If the sound appears once, then the engine is started and gets louder when you rev the engine then it may be a rod knock meaning that the engine...

How do I replace a license plate light bulb?

Your car has two small bulbs that light up the license plate for visibility (this is a legal requirement in most areas). Like other bulbs on your car, they’ll eventually burn out and need to be replaced. However, they should...

What does the color of the engine start/stop switch mean?

Cars equipped with the smart key system and a push-button start have a colored light on the start/stop button. This light can provide you with a lot of information about the condition of the system itself. Here’s a quick rundown:...

I have a new battery but my car won't start

The solution will depend on the symptom you are observing as you try to start the car. I recommend a no-start diagnostic which will identify the root cause. There are a lot of possibilities but if the engine does turn...

My 1998 honda civic lx has started to over heat and the check engine light is on what can i do to fix it

Your car is overheating and you mention adding coolant a couple times, but it is unclear if a coolant leak is a "cause" or an "effect" of overheating in your case. That is, if you have a coolant leak, eventually...

What does the check fuel fill inlet warning mean in the message center?

Today’s cars have very comprehensive emissions monitoring systems. Not only does the computer monitor the engine and the exhaust, but it also monitors your fuel system. If it detects an evaporative emissions leak (gas), it may display a warning in...

Where do I find the emissions control label?

The emissions control label gives you important information about the emissions system in the car, and what regulations it meets. This information may be necessary during emissions testing. You’ll find the label on the underside of the hood, on the...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Ford Escape Hybrid
Over Over the past few years, we’ve seen a major trend toward people choosing crossover utility vehicles (CUVs) over larger SUVs. The big motivator here, of course, is buying a more eco-friendly vehicle that will also save you a bundle...
2012 Honda Accord vs. 2012 Honda Civic: Which One Should I Buy?
The Honda Civic was the best-selling compact car as well as the third-best-selling car overall in 2012. With its unique blend of reliability, affordability and refinement, the Civic is a gold standard for transportation in general. While the Accord is...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Dodge Journey
The The 2012 Dodge Journey is easy to drive, and it’s not so large that you will have a difficult time parking it. It’s an attractive vehicle that has the power you need whether you are hauling a full carpool,...