Q: I was told to change my valve gasket and valve cover. Should I?

asked by on October 11, 2016

I got an oil change in mid-July and in September my oil light came on so I took it to the mechanic and he said I need a valve gasket. He has seen oil he said its going to cost 450. So I went and got another mechanic advice he told he that I need to change my gasket and valve cover. He said if I don't, I'll have problems and he is charging me 700. What should I do?
My car has an automatic transmission.

Valve Cover Gasket Replacement $101.41 - $1171.46 Get a Quote

Hi, thanks for writing in. Five years is a bit on the early side to have a leaking valve cover gasket. The labor time is 3 hours to replace that gasket and YourMechanic typically charges around $400 (part and labor) but there is some variance from region to region. The second estimate that you received is clearly high but not sure if that second estimate includes a new valve cover. The original cover is normally re-usable and if anyone proposes to replace it, they should show you clear evidence of a major problem. It is best not to have engine oil leaks, but if the leak from the valve cover is small, not dripping on a hot manifold (fire hazard) or dripping onto rubber motor mounts, wiring, and so forth you can wait a little while to repair it. Here at YourMechanic, we can have a technician come to your home or office to perform your valve cover gasket replacement for you.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

My elctronic power steering stops working when im driving

If a rusted fuse were causing an intermittent connection, of course that might explain the periodic steering interruption. Simply replacing the fuse though won't be sufficient. The contacts in the fuse holder will have to be carefully cleaned of all...

There is rubber stuck in serpentine pulley grooves

You will need to use a small tool to clean out the groves or the new belt will get damaged or slip and come off. If you cannot get the grooves cleaned then pulley will need to be replaced. ...

I fell asleep at the wheel and i drove over bricks in a yard my car is now running hot, coolant leaks pan under car fell off

Your car should be inspected to determine the origin of the coolant leak and, for your safety, to verify that no other undercar components were damaged in the incident. Once a complete picture is assembled, the mechanic will fully inform...

How many camshaft position sensor are on my 2012 BMW 328I 2.0 turbo

There are two camshaft position sensors on your model. Both position sensors, as well as the crankshaft position sensor, should be tested using an appropriate scan tool or automotive scope to determine if they are functioning. Due to the availability...

Car wont move when started

If the shifter is moving freely but the vehicle will not move, there can be a few causes, depending on the vehicle and the transmission type. For example, if it has a manual transmission, the clutch may have failed. If...

Transmission won't shift from first gear

You will need to have the car checked for the reason the check engine light is coming on? The vehicle is going into failsafe mode and not shifting transmission. Once you get the codes from the computer you can then...

I have a 2007 mdx and the check emission system light came on while I'm driving but not all the time. What can cause that issue?

For the transmission, check the fluid to see if it's low. If the fluid is low, then it will need to be topped off. If the fluid is full and is red in color, then there could be an issue...

Car won't maintain an idle.

Hi there. Try turning on the ignition to the ’ON’ position 3 times with 30 seconds each time to see if the fuel system had air in the rail. This will help with the air in the system. When starting,...

Overheating

Hello. Heater failure and transmission issues are signaling that the cooling system is having a complete meltdown. Both of these systems depend on the cooling system to work correctly. Typically when the entire system is struggling there is a severe...

Related articles

How to Buy a Good Quality Positive Crankcase Ventilation (PCV) Valve
The The positive crankcase ventilation (PCV) helps create the division of emission-control devices; it routes the leftover combustion gases from the bottom of the engine and the oil pan back into the crankcase where instead of escaping into the atmosphere...
How Long Does an Exhaust Pressure Control Valve Last?
The The exhaust pressure control valve is used in diesel vehicles as part of its EGR (exhaust gas recirculation) system. The EGR system is meant to bring down the amount of emissions that vehicles produce, as the gas that is...
How to Replace a Head Gasket
The cylinder head gasket is a seal located between the engine block...