Q: I was told I needed a new transmission. I am not sure if that is the problem.

asked by on March 01, 2017

I took my car to my mechanic on Monday to get serviced. They fixed my ball joints and my passenger wheel bearings. I am satisfied with that being that my car drives smoothly now. However, on the previous Friday, after I had purchased some gas my car started to lose power and drive different. I was convinced that it was the fuel pump or fuel line that was causing my car to act the way it was acting. I've had the car 5 years. They put it on their machine twice before telling me that it was my transmission, they told me that it wasn't my transmission. I am not sure what to do at this point being that I don't have the thousands of dollars to replace or get my transmission rebuilt.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Car is slow to accelerate Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

If the transmission was always shifting smoothly, but only after purchasing fuel that day you immediately experienced reduced performance, I would first suspect (and try to rule out) bad gas. Excepting frankly easy to detect significant, and non intermittent, electrical faults in transmission controls, transmissions do not generally abruptly stop working. As far as what to do now, you can’t do anything until you get a specific, accurate diagnosis of what the underlying problem is. Telling someone "they need a transmission" is NOT a diagnostic and that is not information that is sufficiently specific to make an intelligent decision. If a specific fault was identified by a mechanic, or a specific component was condemned, based on actual testing, that is another matter. Transmissions involve hundreds of parts, not to mention external electrical controls, some of which are easily repaired or replaced while the transmission is on the vehicle. And, of course, the problem you are having may not be in the transmission at all but could be due to an engine management problem. To sum up, you should ask the mechanic to explain to you EXACTLY what is wrong with the transmission, where exactly means "what part", "what component", and so forth. Once you have that information, we can help you interpret it. If, by chance, the mechanic cannot give you any account of the problem, simply request a rough running diagnostic/poor acceleration from YourMechanic and the responding certified mechanic will get this resolved for you. If you have further questions or concerns, do not hesitate to re-contact YourMechanic as we are always here to help you.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Transmission is not shifting out of first and won't start have to tap the starter it's a used transmission I just put it in.

Hi there. Check the brake switch (same as a neutral safety switch) to see if its working. This switch keeps the engine from starting in gear and only allows the transmission to be in park or neutral to start the...

Power train warning light displayed on my Ford Fiesta 1.5 . Only had it four months and done just under 2000 miles. ( 24000 miles

The best way to determine the cause of a check engine light is a check engine light inspection. This will include checking the vehicle for trouble codes with an OBD2 scanner. Once this has been done, the code that the...

Wheel bearings - safe to drive? Ford Focus

Hi there - wheel bearings are fairly durable, although pot holes cause damage and knocking noises as you are experiencing. As for whether this is safe to drive, I would treat this scenario as you would driving around with an...

AdvanceTrac ISsue

The sensor output (from that wheel position) can be viewed on a scan tool and/or an oscilloscope. Once you confirm the output is there, and the waveform is correct, you should trace the circuit back to the ABS controller or...

Transmission Lurching Issues?

The lurching is not caused by a fault in the transmission. Rather, the misfiring is probably the cause as the engine periodically gains and loses power as the misfiring occurs. Diagnostic Trouble Code P0301 means that Cylinder No. 1 is...

Backed up the drive way then put it in drive while stopped gave gas the car made a sound then it wouldn't go anywhere 2007 Honda Accord

Hi there - I suspect you have sheared off either the CV joint, or the axle shaft on the front side that was spinning on the ice. When the tire went from spinning freely (under power) to a full stop...

Car only cranking when gas pedal pumped

The first thing that causes this particular engine to run rough is the ignition coil and usually will start to fail around 75,000 miles. The secondary winding in the coil will fail and not provide enough voltage to get a...

Short in Amps of mustang causes battery drain. With fuse removed mustang runs fine. Will replacing amps fix this?

If there is water leaking into the convertible top well and trunk area, this should be addressed first. Replacing electronic components while still having a water leak issue will only cause damage to the replacement components. If the leak has...

how much automatic transmission fluid to switch for 2007 camry

Hi there. I'll try to clarify this for you as it can be a bit confusing. When you replace the standing oil (or oil inside the pan of the transmission) it typically is around 4 quarts of ATF. During a...

Related articles

Does Gasoline Expire?
Gasoline Gasoline does expire if it is left unused for a long period of time. The problem with gas is its volatility. A volatile substance is prone to separating and vaporizing. This is especially bad if the fuel vapor has...
How Long Does a Fuel Filler Neck Last?
Getting Getting gas from the pump to your gas tank is the only way to keep a car going. The fuel filler neck is a metal tube that is welded to the gas tank of a car. The gas cap...
How Long Does a Fuel Pump Last?
With With all of the different components that allow your car’s fuel system to function, it can become very hard to keep up with them all. Having malfunctioning components in your fuel system can lead to a variety of issues...