Q: Failed engine, flywheel came off as well

asked by on November 02, 2016

Got a customer's car that broke 2 pistons and bent 2 conrods about a month ago. Customer took the car to another workshop to do the repairs, they replaced 2 pistons, 2 conrods, one valve that broke off the head and got jammed into one of the pistons, the cylinder head was damaged and broke a water gallery that caused the customer to keep adding water prior to the final demise of the engine and as he stated the water kept disappearing, which means there was already some sort of cylinder head damage occouring and water mixing in the sump (hydro lock?) When the engine broke the engine locked and seized.

Now a few weeks after this was done they have called saying the flywheel came off the crank, sheared all the bolts clean off the crank. They claiming we did the clutch repair back in June this year and the flywheel wasnt torque'd right which is BS as the remaining bolts in the crank are still in place with loctite and were torque'd as per the manufacturer specs with new bolts i might add.

Hi and thanks for contacting YourMechanic. When an engine is seized at an instant, especially when the engine is under a load, the flywheel will cause a big jolt. Now, the weight of a fly wheel is heavy when it comes to a rotational direction. With that said, as the engine is stopped at an instant, the flywheel will continue to rotate. If the bolts were new, the flywheel may survive the engine damage and just crack one or two bolts. However, if the bolts are used and old, then the flywheel will shier off the bolts. This has nothing to do with a loose bolt. A loose bolt will cause a vibration and make a ticking noise as the engine is running. In my career, I have seen cracked and broken flex plates, but have not had a flywheel come off due to non-torqued bolts with locktite on them.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Car making ticking noise
Hello! An oil leak should be looked at sooner, rather than later, to avoid possible engine damage. First, check to see that the oil level is full. You can return it to the shop that did the oil change, or...
The front tire is making a knocking sound when I accelerate
The noise could be a from a tire that is separated or one of the front axles joints being bad. If you do not feel anything in the steering when the noise is happening, then the noise is most likely...
Coil spring tower detached from the frame and steering quit
Hello. I hate to say that this is a common problem, and there really is not alternative way of fixing it. When the top mount wears out, this will occur causing the steering to bind. The only way to fix...
Squeak sound when drive on low speed and make turns . Sounds is loud when it is cold .
If the squeak is under hood, it can be caused by a few things including the timing or serpentine belt tensioners (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/drive-belt-tensioner-replacement) if they were not replaced, the alternator (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/alternator-replacement) or water pump bearing, and possibly the air injection pump...
Oil Pressure Light is on.
Exactly how low the oil level is inside the motor - which caused the Oil Pressure Light to come on - will determine whether or not there may be damage. Chances are, if it just came on briefly, the oil...
What else can cause an over heating engine. .
Overheating in stop and go traffic can be due to non functioning electric radiator cooling fans. A poorly functioning water pump can be a cause, too, for example if the drive belt is not tight enough. If the car is...
2005 GMC with Denali transmission grinding in all gears including neutral. It will not accelerate and also doesn't have park.
Hi there. Your transmission is slipping all of the gears inside and may be due to a broken stator clutch and a broken torque converter. A torque converter that has failed will cause a grinding noise if the stator breaks...
I have a 09 Nissan Altima 2.5 Base Sedan has about 85k miles. After driving the car for about 15-20 on really hot days it starts m
Hi there. In some cases, a problem with the EVAP system; either an EVAP canister or purge solenoid can cause this type of symptom on extremely hot days. Another possibility is that you have an obstruction of fuel somewhere in...
Does a 2006 jeep grand cherokee 3.7 need a fan clutch ?
The fan clutch was only used on the 4.7L engine. It will not be present on your engine (the 3.7L) and so you will only have the radiator shroud and fan assembly. If you are having any issues with the...

Related articles

What Is Engine Braking?
Drivers can use engine braking to slow the speed of their engine and vehicle. Engine decompression helps your brakes last longer and car stop sooner.
Top 10 Ways to Extend the Life of Your Car
Every driver wants a car that lasts a long time. Make your car last longer by checking your motor oil, parking in the shade, and keeping it clean.
How to Replace a Trunk Lock Cylinder
A car trunk is secured by a trunk lock, which works via a trunk lock cylinder. Replacing a bad cylinder is imperative to your vehicle’s security.