Q: Car broke down won't start does a fast clicking sound when trying to crank

asked by on July 05, 2016

Van broke down yesterday. My wife was driving and it just died. When you try to turn it over it does a rapid clicking sound. Hooked it to jumper cables fired right up. Didn't let it charge on cables long to avoid draining other battery. When I unhooked it van kept running. My brother in law told me to unhook negative terminal and if it quit alternator was bad. I unhooked negative and van died but nothing I look up says to do that and I didn't leave van running long enough for it to try to charge itself cause I was listening to brother in law. Does it sound like I have bad battery or bad alternator?

My car has 250000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Battery will not hold a charge Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

The rapid clicking sound is definitely a problem with the battery. From the description of the failure, this certainly could be an alternator failure. Disconnecting the negative cable does confirm the alternator is not charging. The reason you don’t find any information about this test is that it is not good for the car and it isn’t a complete test.

You could have a blown fuse or wiring problem that powers the alternator. The Caravan in particular has a PCM controlled alternator that often fails. The fact that is uses the PCM to control the alternator is a good reason not to disconnect the battery cable while the car is running. When you do this, it creates an electrical surge that delicate computer systems don’t like.

The alternator and the battery work together to provide the electrical power your car requires to run. A comprehensive diagnosis of this charging system requires the use of a scanner and experience diagnosing Chrysler charging systems. If you need help with this, a certified technician from YourMechanic can come to your car’s location to diagnose the charging system for you.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I install a child restraint system?
Child restraint systems are very important safety features for young children and infants, and can be easily installed in one of the rear seats of your vehicle. Since each child restraint system is different, follow the instructions provided by the...
froze wheel hub bolts and calipers screw pins
When it comes to frozen, rusted, corroded and seized parts, it will take time, a lot of heat and liquid wrench. From personal experience, I find PB blaster works better than liquid wrench. Try getting the part real hot with...
the car revs high and at stop signs while slowing down then idles down suddenly and sometimes stalls, whats the cause?
The engine intake manifold seals or the intake tubes between the mass air flow sensor and the throttle body may have a leak that you cannot hear, but could be found using a smoke machine designed to find the leaks....
Odometer not working
The speedometer is calibrated to read the correct miles per hour and distance driven at the speedometer factory. Are you sure you misread the odometer to be 1.2 miles and not 12 miles? If the far right number is a...
Steering wheel hard turning on 2007 Volvo V50
According to the service I use to make recommendations by mileage, the change interval for the timing belt (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/timing-belt-replacement) is 120,000 miles. 100,000 miles is a little early, but it is better to perform services like these earlier rather than...
Rear end noise when going over bumps
You will need to replace the rear stabilizer bar, bushings and brackets using a new design part number from Mazda using kit part number B3Y0-28--10X. This is a new design that will fix the noise you are having. The part...
Water getting inside driver side door 2013 Honda Pilot
Hi - yes, it is quite likely the water leak (https://www.yourmechanic.com/question/i-have-water-that-s-getting-inside-my-drivers-side-back-door-and-floor-what-could-be-causing-this-by-lakeisha-j) you describe is the source of failed electrical functionality. If the weatherseal around the driver door glass is leaking, allowing water to splash on the master switch assembly for...
Where is the cam shaft position sensor located on a 2000 ford contour 2.0
Codes do not conclusively identify faulty parts. Any part referred to in a code that is suspected of being faulty must be separately tested, that is diagnosed, in order to determine if in fact there is anything wrong with the...
I have a 2008 Chevy Cobalt and will be replacing both CV Axle Shafts. Do I have to get an alignment after?
In short no you do not as long as the lower ball joint is taken loose and not the strut bolts. If you loosen the strut bolts then you will need an alignment.

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2013 Dodge Dart
It’s It’s back, and better than ever. In the first incarnation of the iconic Dodge since 1976, the Dart has been updated, beatified, and turned into a compact force to be reckoned with. This zippy little machine is tough to...
2011 Dodge Ram vs. 2011 Ford F-150: Which One Should I Buy?
Large trucks can be fun to drive, and even more fun to get dirty. Unfortunately, they may also cause you to get phone calls from friends who need to move into a new apartment. Fortunately, just having a truck may...
Understanding the Dodge Oil Change Indicator and Service Indicator Lights
Car symbols, or dashboard lights, are a car service reminder. The Dodge Oil Change Indicator lets you know when and what service your car needs.