Q: Can a mechanic crack a rim while changing a tire?

asked by on September 03, 2017

I took my car for a car inspection and was told that I needed 4 new tires. OK, no problem. A few days later, front passenger tire is flat. I put the spare on and took it back to the garage. I am told the rim is cracked. The rim has been fine for the past 5 years and suddenly it's cracked. I did NOT hit a curb or pothole. My question is: can a mechanic crack a rim while changing a tire?

Thanks!!

My car has 200000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Hi Adeline. Thanks for contacting us tonight. With today’s tire changing machines, cracking a rim during removal and installation is incredibly difficult to do - however, it is possible. If the tire is busted off the bead (which is a technical term, not an indication of damaging anything) and the ram is accidentally placed on the wheel and not in between the bead, it’s possible to cause a crack on an alloy wheel. Proving whether the tire shop created the crack would be very difficult. In all honestly, if the wheel was cracked prior to entering the facility, the existing tire should have been going flat before the tire change. It is possible however, for the wheel bead to have been slightly cracked prior - even if you haven’t hit a pot hole or curb, especially if a vehicle drives over speed bumps frequently.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $65/hr

What others are asking

When I start my car on a cold morning I have to pump the accelerator to get it to start.

As a general rule, car engines do not like cold weather and do not do operate as well in cold weather. When you start your car in the morning and turn the key to on, the coolant temperature sensor immediately...

A/c controls go in and out and now when i turn the car off and take the keys out, the lights are still on. Honda accord 2000.

Hi there: Most of the time, this issue is caused by an electrical relay that has been damaged. It's possible that during your radio swap, this may have caused an electrical issue with your AC system. However, it's also possible...

Loud rattling coming from bottom of car

Hi. This should be inspected soon as damage to the underside of the car can be costly. There are metal and rubber mounts that hold up the exhaust system which over time can become loose. This could also cause damage...

I have a 2008 nissan maxima sl. The car cut off while driving. Trying to restart it all I'm getting is a clicking noise.

Hi Joy. Thanks for contacting us today. Usually the "click" noise while starting is an indication that the starter motor is either not receiving power to engage the motor. This could be due to a dead battery, damaged electrical relay...

Crankshaft bearing replacement cost 2008 BMW M3

Hello - unfortunately, this is not a service YourMechanic offers at this time. Thanks for thinking of us though!

Check Engine light came on

An illuminated Check Engine Light can be caused by many different issues on a vehicle that is 15 years old; it could be anything from a gas cap, to a bad sensor. I recommend hiring a mechanic, such as one...

Knocking sound under car

Hi there. Either the tires are out of balance and causing the front end to shake and make the steering parts move around or there is a loose steering or suspension part that is moving around as the vehicle is...

Car won't go in gear when hot?

Hi there, thanks for writing in. I'd be happy to help. Your transmission is a computer-controlled transmission which can be affected even when something as simple as a weak battery is the issue. I would first suggest checking the battery...

Car idling high

The problem you are experiencing may be the vacuum modulator leaking in the transmission. The vacuum leak will cause the engine to idle high and the transmission will not shift correctly. The vehicle should be tested for any problems with...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Mercedes Benz S-Class
If If you’re looking for a vehicle that delivers top-of-the-line features, comfort, performance and safety, all while showing off the prestige of the driver, the 2012 Mercedes Benz S-Class is your choice. Key Features With Active Body Control and...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Mercedes-Benz SL-Class
Nothing Nothing says true sport luxury like a Mercedes hardtop convertible, and the SL more than delivers on the name’s promises. While both the SL and its sibling, the SLK, offer superior luxury, handling, and comfort, the SL boasts the...
The Most and Least Expensive Cars to Insure
Car insurance quotes depend on the car make and model. The Honda Odyssey is the least expensive and the Dodge Viper is the most expensive to insure.