Q: Best water pump or "good enough"? 2004 Porsche Boxster S

asked by on February 09, 2017

rattling noise coming from waterpump area so i parked. fluid flushing out. Im about to trade in my Porsche for a new car, does it matter on the brand of water pump? $78-$289 bucks

My car has 125000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Water Pump Replacement $171.86 - $1147.02 Get a Quote

Hi - there is a certain value from the buyers point of view in being to able say you "only used OEM parts" - and I don’t mean necessarily ones that came in a Porsche box. Pierburg is an OEM supplier of these pumps to Porsche, for example, and they are available from Porsche aftermarket parts suppliers for $200 or slightly less. For assistance with this repair, I recommend a water pump replacement performed by a mobile, professional mechanic, such as one from YourMechanic, who will come to your location, and repair this issue with quality parts.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

What is the grinding sound coming from passenger side of engine

It sounds like this may be related to a couple of different possibilities. This could be a bad idler pulley bearing, which is a bearing inside an idler wheel that the serpentine belt rides on. When these bearings wear out,...

Car jerks

The problem is inside the transmission with pressures or shift solenoids and will need to have a transmission expert test and diagnose it to isolate the cause.

Wobbling fan

Hi there, thanks for writing in. I'd be happy to help. I suggest, with the engine off, to try and move the fan up and down to see if there is any looseness in the water pump or in the...

Losing coolant air conditioner and heat not turning on at all

Hey there, thanks for writing in about your 2003 Chrysler Sebring. The problem is that you are low on coolant and the A/C needs to be diagnosed to see why it is not working. If you have a coolant leak,...

Would leaking exhaust manifold throw a code?

If the exhaust system is not air tight, that will skew oxygen sensor readings and a consequence is a false indication of catalyst efficiency. In addition, the upstream sensor will not be providing a valid reading to the computer insofar...

Knocking/ticking noise before it died told that engine has no compression also told may be timing chain/belt,worth looking at ?

Hello, the damage to the engine could cost a lot money. When the timing chain breaks, the result can be bent valves and damage to the cylinder head. The effective repair would be to replace the engine assembly. With...

Squeaks when driving over bumps

The suspension is the most likely source of the noise. However, almost anything on a car can develop a squeak. Try your best to narrow where exactly the noise is coming from. Front, back, left, or right. This will help...

Check engine light came on and code was P0410

A P0410 can be a real bear on a Mercedes. But first you need to check the simple stuff. The Auxiliary air system is an emission control device that blows air into the hot exhaust stream to help burn up...

Key getting stuck in ignition of a 2004 Chrysler Pacifica

The shift linkage can have problems that the vehicle is not getting all the way into park so the ignition can not be turned all the way off. The shift cable bushings are known to fail and may need to...

Related articles

How to Replace a Water Pump Belt
A water pump belt fails when the belt frays, cracks, or there is a burning rubber smell or squealing noise coming from the engine.
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Water Pump Belt
Common signs include cracks or frayed nylon cords in the belt, squealing noises, and a burning rubber smell from the engine.
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Porsche Panamera Hybrid
Porsche Porsche is known for its prestige, power and performance, and its hybrid introduction to the Panamera line does not disappoint. While its hatchback design may put some off, the interior is nothing short of spectacular with well-appointed materials that...