The Most and Least Expensive Cars to Insure

Schedule Pre-purchase Car Inspection
Service Area

$99.00

Upfront, Transparent Price
Average rating from 4,407 customers who received a Pre-purchase Car Inspection.

When it comes time to purchase a new car, the most important factor for most people is usually the price. But the MSRP on the window sticker is not the only thing to consider when thinking about price. The reality is that there are numerous factors to take into account when determining the cost of a vehicle. Yes, the retail price is the biggest factor, but maintenance cost, fuel efficiency, and insurance prices also play a big role.

Many people think insurance prices are only affected by the age of the driver and their driving record. However, the vehicle itself plays an enormous part in calculating insurance costs. Vehicles that have high safety ratings and aren’t normally driven hard or fast have the lowest insurance rates. Not surprisingly, sports cars and other vehicles that encourage a lead foot have the highest insurance premiums. Insurance providers have data showing how frequently different vehicles are crashed and how severe the crashes are. Insurance companies use this data to help determine the size and cost of insurance.

While insurance cost likely won’t be your deciding factor when picking a new car, it is certainly worth taking into consideration, and may help sway you when you’re on the fence about a vehicle. Using data from Insure.com, here are the five least expensive and the five most expensive vehicles to insure in 2016.

Five most affordable vehicles to insure

All of the vehicles on this list have a few things in common: they have excellent safety ratings, are very practical, and are affordably priced, meaning that an insurance company won’t have to pay as much if damage occurs to the vehicle.

Honda Odyssey

The Honda Odyssey leads this list, with an average insurance price of $1,113 annually. There are a few reasons for this, chief among them the Odyssey’s 5-star National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) rating. As a minivan, the Odyssey is also primarily driven by parents with kids in tow, which almost always results in safer driving. Long story short: Honda Odysseys get in accidents infrequently, and when they do, the damage is usually minimal.

Honda CR-V

It’s no surprise that Honda occupies the top two spots on this list. Hondas are known for being practical, safe, and terrific family cars. Like the Odyssey, the CR-V is a car typically owned by responsible drivers (often parents), and it also sports 5-star NHTSA rating. SUVs[' high ride height and usually heavier weight make them safe vehicles to drive, so a 5-star rating for an SUV goes a long way.

Dodge Grand Caravan

Dodge Grand Caravan

The Dodge Grand Caravan is pretty similar to the Honda Odyssey, and it shows in the insurance rates. The affordably priced minivan is usually owned by safe and responsible families, and the 4-star NHTSA rating makes it a fairly safe vehicle. Replacement parts for Dodge vehicles are usually quite affordably priced, making them less expensive for insurers to repair, which is also a factor in the Grand Caravan making this list.

Jeep Patriot

As far as affordability and safety go in an SUV, it’s hard to find a compromise as good as the Jeep Patriot, which blends a 4-star NHTSA rating with an MSRP under $18,000. For those who want an affordable SUV with great insurance rates, the Patriot is a perfect pick.

Jeep Wrangler

The Jeep Wrangler doesn’t have as good of an NHTSA safety rating as the other vehicles on this list, but there are other factors that contribute to its low insurance premiums. Four wheel drive and sturdy construction are some of the SUV's above-average safety benefits, and being a very popular, inexepnsive, and American-made vehicle means that it is quite affordable to repair should an accident occur.

Five most expensive vehicles to insure

The vehicles on this list are generally very expensive and therefore costly to repair. Most are designed to be driven hard and fast, so they see a higher rate of accidents than other cars.

Dodge Viper

The most expensive vehicle to insure (excluding limited-production hypercars) in 2016 is the Dodge Viper, with annual insurance premiums exceeding $4,000. The Viper is one of the highest-performing cars on the market: it has tremendous power and acceleration, but is available only with a manual transmission and lacks traction control entirely. This is a dangerous combination for many drivers. Add in the bespoke V10 engine which is pricy to repair, and you're left with a very expensive vehicle to insure.

Mercedes-Benz SL65 AMG

The Mercedes-Benz SL65 AMG is an extremely expensive luxury car, which automatically puts it in the upper price bracket when it comes to insurance. It's one of the fastest convertibles on the market, with a complex hand-built V12 engine producing over 600 horsepower. The pairing of exclusivity and performance mean that if it gets in even a minor accident, sourcing replacement parts is going to cost insurance companies a pretty penny, driving insurance premiums higher.

Mercedes-Maybach S600

The Mercedes-Maybach S600 is Mercedes' most opulent luxury sedan. It's covered in chrome and leather, and features a unique body not shared with other Mercedes models. This makes repairs very expensive, and the V12 engine under the hood has the potential to get drivers into trouble.

Mercedes-Benz S63 AMG

It’s no surprise that there are three Mercedes-Benz vehicles on this list. With cars as well made and expensive as these, even a small scratch or dent can be very costly, so insurance companies have to charge a large price to make sure that all repairs can be effectively covered.

Porsche Panamera Turbo S Executive

The Panamera Turbo S Executive condenses Porsche's decades of racing experience into a large luxurious sedan. With an MSRP over $200,000, any damage is extremely costly. With performance figures rivaling dedicated sports cars, the Panamera Turbo S Executive is often driven by enthusiastic drivers who try to push it to its limits – but might find that just because they can afford it doesn't mean they necessarily have the skill to keep it under control.

There are numerous qualities that can affect the insurance costs of a vehicle. Insurance price isn’t usually the most important factor on anyone’s checklist when purchasing a vehicle, but as these lists show, it’s not inconsequential either. So whenever you’re purchasing a new or used car, consider the potential insurance price, and you may also want to have a pre-purchase inspection performed by a reputable technician.


Next Step

Schedule Pre-purchase Car Inspection

The most popular service booked by readers of this article is Pre-purchase Car Inspection. Yourmechanic’s technicians bring the dealership to you by performing this job at your home or office 7 days a week between 7AM-9PM. We currently cover over 10k cities and have 100k+ 5-star reviews... LEARN MORE

SEE PRICING & SCHEDULING

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Recent Pre-purchase Car Inspection reviews

Excellent Rating


YourMechanic Pre-purchase Car Inspection Service

Average Rating

4.9/5

Number of Reviews

4,407

Rating Summary
4,100
168
35
34
70
4,100
168
35
34
70

Chris

21 years of experience
1719 reviews
Chris
21 years of experience
Lexus ES300 - Pre-purchase Car Inspection - Garden Grove, California
Very professional, but although cool in a sense. On time actually arrived at site earlier than expected that was a plus. Also very thorough, and gave recommendations. Thanks alot Chriss.
Jaguar F-Type - Pre-purchase Car Inspection - Mission Viejo, California
If I could give Chris 100 stars I would. Above and beyond in every way. He's super knowledgeable, informative, responsive and above all patient. He doesn't hesitate to make sure all your questions are answered and that you feel comfortable taking the plunge buying a car sight unseen. He was our eyes when we couldn't be there to inspect the car, and informed us of any red flags regarding how the car operates now and what to look for in the future. Ask for Chris, he's fantastic, an expert in automotive knowledge, and a first class professional.

Willie

23 years of experience
28 reviews
Willie
23 years of experience
Hyundai Elantra - Pre-purchase Car Inspection - Stanton, California
Had Will inspected two Hyundai Elantra SE at different dealers. He was prompt and provided great feedback on the cars. Really value his experience and recommendation. We're highly satisfy with Will and his service.
Dodge Avenger - Pre-purchase Car Inspection - Long Beach, California
Willie is a hard and reliable worker. Fixed the problem. 3rd experience with him I think. Very satisfied

Raymond

36 years of experience
155 reviews
Raymond
36 years of experience
Ford Explorer - Pre-purchase Car Inspection - Las Vegas, Nevada
Very happy with the pre-inspection service. He was in contact from when he left to when he arrived at dealership to a FULL Sheet of info right after the inspection. Raymond helped make me feel at ease buying the car after having his professional opinion that everything was good. The one thing he did recommend I mentioned to the dealership and they took care of it before I even bought the car. :) Thanks so much for your expertise. I would definitely use this website again for any future services I may need.
Subaru Baja - Pre-purchase Car Inspection - Las Vegas, Nevada
Raymond was early, Very Professional, & very thorough. Answered all my questions and was very informative. Did an Excellent job !

David

12 years of experience
287 reviews
David
12 years of experience
Honda CR-V - Pre-purchase Car Inspection - Marietta, Georgia
Prompt and knowledgeable. David arrived early to do our pre-purchase car inspection and completed it in a timely fashion. He communicated his findings, recommendations by phone and text message, which was nice. I appreciated the information and details he provided.
Mercedes-Benz E400 - Pre-purchase Car Inspection - Kennesaw, Georgia
David called when he arrived and called shortly after he finished inspecting the vehicle. Unfortunately, due to the inefficiency of the sales representative at the dealership, David was not able to drive the vehicle as the final phase of the inspection.

Need Help With Your Car?

Our certified mobile mechanics make house calls in over 2,000 U.S. cities. Fast, free online quotes for your car repair.

GET A QUOTE