Q: Are Code Readers and Scan Tools Different?

asked by on December 01, 2015

Are code readers and scan tools different?

There are differences and similarities between code readers and scan tools. With the advent of the vehicle on board diagnostic system (OBD) there have been many different makers of scan tools and code readers. The code readers were the first to be made once the manufacturers allowed the information to be retrieved for a mechanic to access it.

Before there were code readers and scanners (scan tools), the mechanic would have to put the system into test mode and count a blinking light or a meter needle sweep to obtain a code, then hook up a tool called a breakout box. This box was installed between the vehicle computer and its wire harness. The mechanic would have to test each computer input and output using a multimeter to get the readings of sensors. This was very time consuming and not a convenient way to find a problem. Later, large vehicle scanners were made that could not leave a mechanic bay due to size. Then they started getting smaller and smaller. They still had very limited diagnostic use for a trained mechanic, but were needed for extended diagnostics.

Then the code reader was created. The code reader was about the size of a small book and would hook up to a diagnostic connector that was specific to one manufacturer only. The code reader would be used to test the vehicle engine only and get trouble codes output to a small screen. The code was used by a mechanic to do a pinpoint test using other tools before they repaired and retested the system to see if the code was gone. There was no other use except to retrieve the codes and no other information was given. With the advent of the OBD II system in 1996, the code reader got a generic connector that is used by all manufacturers. The code reader can still retrieve codes and clear codes.

With the OBD II system, manufacturers got more information that is given through the OBD connector. To access this information, a scan tool (scanner) can be used. A scanner can be very simple and only get basic information like engine codes and engine emission monitors, and also be able to clear codes. The scanner can also get very comprehensive with the ability to see live data input and outputs of the computer, access other systems data and codes like the anti-lock brakes, suspension, powertrain, body control, and air condition system. The scan tools today can even have reprogramming capabilities using manufacturer’s calibration files. However, not all scanners are the same as the more expensive ones have more functions. The manufacturers’ dealers will have scanners that have proprietary information that most aftermarket scanners have access to. This is so the dealer can have access to information like manufacturer specific codes and data, anti-theft systems, or other systems the manufacturer does not want the general public to have access too.

The bottom line is code readers can only retrieve codes and clear them, while scan tools can also test other systems and data usage to help diagnose problems better than just a code reader.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Do all cars have an OBD system?

Virtually all vehicles from the 1987 model year to the present day have an OBD system. Some earlier model year vehicles, but not all, have some semblance of an OBD system. However, their diagnostic abilities are severely limited. There are...

I need to know the diagnostic procedure for dtc p0717. Want to test wires before taking out transmission

If the sensor only has two wires, it is a reluctant AC sensor. If the sensor has three wires then it is a hall effect DC sensor. A two wire sensor will produce a sine wave signal: '()(-)()(-)(_)' or steady...

After parked overnight, car loses all electrical power

Hello. This may sound strange, but were you parked under a street light when the battery died? I have experienced faulty florescent lights putting out RF signals (the signals that your remote fob use) that do not let the car...

I scanned my mercedes ML 250 CDI 4Matic W166 with icarsoft MB 2 scanner. Its showing trouble code U144f00. What does it mean ?

The fault being reported is within a Controller Area Network (CAN) function (wiring or device) but the code itself is generic. According to MB, the particular scanner that you are using will have an accompanying description of the code as...

I have questions about my 2009 kia spectra's CEL and the codes I had read. Car run's good and was running good when light came on.

Given the three codes, a known issue with sensor wiring in that vehicle (to be discussed momentarily), and only 89,000 miles on the engine, I would judge the likelihood of sensor failure to be "average". That is, there are lots...

was getting PO440 CODE.

These valves are controlled by the PCM so the circuit will not be closed until commanded by the PCM and that closure can be through the ground side. If the circuit is competed through the ground side, you will always...

Does the Mechanic verify the replacement part I think I need is what a actually need?

If you call out a mechanic to install a part that was diagnosed by another company then to answer your question is no. The mechanic that is to install a previously diagnosed parts cannot in most cases verify the part...

How do you get Check Engine Light reading with no OBD-II plug?

All vehicles that are newer than 1996 and sold in the United States are required to have an OBD-2 system. The scanner plug may have been removed for some reason by the previous owner or mechanic. If this is the...

how do i know if i have an bad PCM

PCM's are usually replaced at the end of a "process of elimination". That is, with most engine management control failures, there are a whole host of common causes that are evaluated first. Once that long list of most common causes...

Related articles

P006A OBD-II Trouble Code: Manifold Absolute Pressure (MAP) - Mass or Volume Air Flow Correlation
P006A means there is a signal correlation problem between the engine computer and MAF or MAP sensor, likely due to a faulty intake system or sensor.
B1898 OBD-II Trouble Code: Chime Input #2 Circuit Short to Ground
B1898 means there is a circuit issue with chime input 2, most likely due to a damaged electrical component.
Should I Buy My Own Code Reader or Scanner?
All All cars made from 1996 onward have an onboard computer that detects faults in the engine, transmission and emissions systems, and communicates problems through lights in the dash (your Check Engine Light, for instance). There’s also a connector located...