Q: My car won't shift out of first gear

asked by on November 16, 2016

We changed the transmission hoping that will help but it's doing the same thing. When I step on the gas it just revs up while picking up speed.

My car has 96000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

If the torque converter is defective that could cause shifting problems, and other symptoms as well. There are stall speed and hydraulic pressure tests than can assist in diagnosing the condition of the converter.

Other possibilities include the external controls and sensors, for example the vehicle speed sensor. Transmission related sensor outputs from the engine to the PCM, and thence to the electronic transmission controls, including the shift solenoids, should be tested because if those are not all functioning properly, you will get the stuck in gear condition you are reporting.

If there are any downloadable Diagnostic Trouble Codes from your Onboard Diagnostic system, that would certainly help to pin it down. Of course, check the fluid level to be sure it is correct as low fluid is an obvious cause of failure to shift.

If you can’t resolve the issue, a certified transmission specialist from YourMechanic can perform a diagnostic for difficult shifting to figure out the root cause of the problem for you and then let you know of your repair options.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Lightingbolt came on and engine light i have a 2017 jeep patriot and it was working fine all of a sudden it wont turn on

Hi Jessica. Thanks for contacting us tonight. If the lightning bolt light is red, this is typically an indication that the electronic throttle control is either damaged or has a blown electrical relay. Unfortunately, it could also mean that the...

My car is buzzing even when car is turned off

Hi Samsin. Thanks for contacting us today. In most cases, this type of noise is caused by a stuck electrical relay or a ground wire short within the steering column or the ignition switch itself. Although most mechanics would start...

Where is the solenoid purge valve located in a 2012 Chevrolet Captiva Sport?

Hi there. The purge solenoid valve is typically located on the passenger side of the vehicle, under the hood and attached to the firewall. In order to locate yours and to review the correct removal and installation procedures, I would...

I put on a CAI...and 2 days later my check engine light came on..and it was bank 2 po174

Hi there. One minor, yet highly important detail that most aftermarket part manufacturers fail to tell customers is that the installation of their components will impact the operation of the sensor that monitor systems on OEM vehicles; like your BMW....

Car won't start can't get vehicle in netural to tow.

Hi there. You could take a long pick and put it into the little slot that the shifter has a the top and push down on it. At the same time as you push down, take the gear shifter and...

There is a knock under the body.

Hi there. Try putting the transmission in drive and reverse back and forth. If the clunk is heard in both directions and the clunk changes in sound pitch, then there is a universal joint that has the bearings burned up...

Truck shuts off when i stop before I hit the brake pedal but idles just fine. What can cause that to happen?

Hello. Engine stalling can be caused by many things. A few common causes are issues with the fuel, ignition, or engine management systems. If any of the components to one or more of these systems fails or has an issue...

What's wrong with my variable timing solenoid?

Hi there. I can certainly understand how you were freaked out by what was said to you. However, no diagnosis is an exact diagnosis without uncovering the root cause of the failures. The variable timing solenoid could be sticking, failed,...

2002 Jeep Liberty Limited 3.7 misfire bent spark plug tip with rough idle

I can't find any information suggesting there is a recall for your vehicle. Either way, you need to figure out what has failed in cylinder number two. Replacing all the injectors is not going to fix the problem in cylinder...

Related articles

How Long Does a Kickdown Cable Last?
In In order for a car to run smoothly, the engine and the transmission will have to work together. With all of the different components in the engine and transmission of a car, keeping up with them all can be...
How Long Does a Throttle Body Last?
There There are so many components involved in a vehicle running properly, but some of the main ones are rather basic in their role. The throttle body is one of those parts. This component is part of the air intake...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Transmission Speed Sensor
Common signs include harsh or improper shifting, cruise control not working, and the Check Engine Light coming on.