Q: My car has a low idle and will stop at lights or stop signs

asked by on November 06, 2016

The problem with the car developed gradually where it eventually idled so low that it would stall at startup or at a light, I have replaced the serpentine belt, mass air sensor, PCV valve, coolant temperature sensor, oxygen sensor, air filter and spark plugs, and next I'll change the throttle position sensor, not worried about changing all of these sensors and things, it was probably about time to. 1 mechanics said that it was the Transmission lock up, because the car stalls when put in Drive, but does not stall when put in reverse, but that does not make sense to me because if I give the car a little gas, it will not stall in drive and will operate normally until I slow down to stop at a light and the idle becomes so low that it stalls again. My question is, can a Transmission lock up malfunction in that way, only at idle and only in forward? Also couldn't the throttle position sensor be a better answer?

My car has 159000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Car is stalling Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Hello. The symptoms you describe can be caused by a few different things. A few other possible causes are issues with the idle air control valve, with the transmission, or with the throttle position sensor. The idle air control valve is the component that maintains and adjusts the engine idle speed, and can cause all sorts of issues, including stalling, if it has a problem or fails. Similar symptoms can also be caused by issues with the vehicle’s transmission.

If one of the sensors or components, such as a speed sensor, shift solenoid, or the shift interlock solenoid have an issue they can also produce the symptoms you are experiencing. Another possibility is the throttle position sensor. Though less likely, it does play a role in the vehicles shifting and idle behavior. Stalling can also be caused by a wide variety of other issues, such as problems with the fuel, ignition, or engine management systems.

I would recommend having a professional technician, such as one from YourMechanic, come to your location to determine if the cause of the stalling.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Battery draining.
Your Saturn does not have any direct relation between the door locks and the anti-theft system from the factory. If you are having issues with both of these systems in the vehicle simultaneously and the battery is draining then it...
Something dragging on ground
Hi. You should have this inspected soon as there could be costly damage as a result. Over time the mounts that hold the exhaust system and muffler can become loose allowing them to swing around or drop lower than intended....
Car not moving in gear
If your Buick does not move in either drive or reverse, I suspect an internal mechanical problem. The reason for this is that a vehicle will generally be able to move forward and backward if the main mechanical components are...
Replaced Master and Slave clutch cylinders, feels like I have a clutch but can't put into gear while running.
You may still have some air in the clutch hydraulics, or you are having an issue with the clutch not fully releasing. This can be from the air in the system causing the clutch slave cylinder to not move far...
Change direction of wipers
This would require modifying the windshield wiper motor which could be costly. If it is an issue of the quality of the job they do, I would suggest purchasing better quality wiper blades.
Blown head gasket?
Hi, thanks for writing in. Unfortunately, white smoke in the exhaust, overheating and rough running all point to engine coolant getting into the combustion chamber. This is generally caused by a crack in the head or block or more commonly...
Front end problems and I am a basic car mechanic. I do the easy work. I worked at a Toyota Dealership for a few years and never encountered this problem.
Hi there. Sounds like that the CV shaft (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/axle-cv-shaft-assembly-replacement) is failing on that side of the vehicle. The outer bearing in the CV shaft is what you are hearing for the clicking sound. The bearing is probably dry and needs...
Why do I have a p0016 trouble code?
The cause for a p0016 trouble code could be normally be tracked to one of two areas. The code is set when the computer does not see synchronized information being received from the cam and crank sensors. It will be...
Whining noise when the engine is at idle.
Hi there. The whining noise that you are hearing is the gears and timing chain in the engine. This is a normal condition and all of the Porsche engines have the same sound. If your engine has an inner cooler,...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're a Pizza Delivery Guy or Gal
If If you deliver pizzas, you want to be sure that your car is reliable and won’t break down. After all, you have hungry customers waiting, and you don’t want the pizza to get cold. You want low gas mileage,...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Have Kids
Once Once you have kids, the kind of car you have becomes very important. Suddenly, the amount of space, entertainment features, reliability, safety, and easy to clean interior become the top priorities. Here’s a list of vehicles meant to satisfy...
Industry News for Automotive Techs: October 29 - November 4
Toyota and Getaround's smartphone key, future McLaren cars, DMCA car hacking, a fire at Ford's headquarters, and Chevrolet's SEMA 2016 show cars.