Q: My 2002 Saturn Vue's rpms started revving into 4-5k when up shifting. Later that day the clutch went out. Now the starter is out.

asked by on May 02, 2017

My friend was driving my 2002 Saturn Vue's when the rpms started revving into 4-5k while up-shifting. I noticed but chalked it up to my friend adjusting to my car's sensitivity. Later that day the clutch went out while we were in a mountianous pass. There were no noticeable smells and id not had this issue before. The car wouldnt start after he turned off the engine. Now the starter is out completely. I get lights when i turn the key but only a sad, low whine when I try to start it. I have taken very good care of the car but the previous owner had not. I put about 30k miles on it last year and replaced the alternator 8 months ago. Is it toast? I feel like it's not worth replacing the parts because its an older Saturn. Should I scrap it?

My car has 210000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Clutch is not working Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Hello, thank you for writing in. The decision to invest in an older car is difficult, even more so when you do not have the car in front of you. A failed clutch can interfere with the flywheel causing the vehicle to have issues starting. From the sound of it, there is extra resistance on the starter keeping it from spinning. Since you know the clutch is bad, you need to start there. If the starter had no issues prior, this may have stressed it out and caused it to wear down. You may want to keep an eye on it, even if it starts after replacing the clutch. Regarding the choice to do the work or not, consider the price of labor and parts to what you would be able to get for it in current condition. Punching numbers may give you further insight. For more help with the clutch, contact our service department to schedule an appointment.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Where is the spare tire?
The spare tire sits under the bed of the truck, at the very rear. It is easy to remove the spare tire with your hands. Just use the jack handle to winch the tire down and unhook it from the...
Exhaust manifold pipe rusted off.
Hey there, thanks for writing in. You would need to have it metal clamped or welded on at an exhaust shop. Welding it will give you a better seal if the rest of the pipe is not damaged or rusted....
is the crv better than hyundai 2009
Hi there. I like the Honda CRV since I have a 1998 Honda CRV EX AWD that I have owned since 2005 and have had no major problems. I just recently passed the car down to my daughter for her...
Short quiet squeal accompanied by what feels like the engine 'catching' and sort of jerking slightly
Hello there, thanks for writing in. The vehicle squealing and catching can have a variety of causes on your 1993 Plymouth Sundance. When the vehicle catches and squeals like this it is likely a problem with the belt slipping. The...
My mechanic is saying the timing chain is bad (causing oil leaks). Does a timing chain cause oil leaks? What are your thoughts?
Hi, thanks for writing in. Timing change themselves cannot cause an oil leak but the timing chain cover can cause an oil leak. In order to replace the timing cover gasket, you will have to remove the serpentine belt and...
My RPM is very erratic and the engine surges on my 2006 Hyundai Elantra
Hello. I would usually start by scanning the computer for codes to see if anything comes up. If there are no codes then I would check and see if there are any sensors that are not reading correctly. It sounds...
My car overheated and now will not start. I believe I have a water pump issue and possibly a blown gasket.
A faulty water pump will not cause a failure to start. If the water pump is not working, all that will happen is after you start the car, the engine will overheat. If the head gasket has failed and coolant...
Front passenger airbag status light gets illuminated when I start the ignition and noone is seated on pessenger side. Please advis
It is normal for the passenger air bag off light to be on when no one is in the seat. This indicates the system is not activating the passenger air bag when no one is in seat. If someone is...
Battery saver system car won't turn and battery good and starter. Whole dash illuminates when I turn key though, no alter
Have the battery load tested (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/battery-is-dead-inspection) in case it was short circuited. Reverse polarity, at the battery, in a 12 volt electrical system on a car can cause a variety of effects including damaging the alternator, diodes and the numerous...

Related articles

How Long Does a Clutch Last?
It’s a fact of life that a car clutch will almost certainly wear out before your car does. That’s because, even...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Crankshaft Seal
If your car is reaching high mileage or is experiencing oil leaks, it may be time to replace the crankshaft seal.
How to Drive a Manual Transmission Car Without Using the Clutch
Manual transmissions have a clutch that allows you to change gears when needed. There may come a time when your clutch fails while you're on the road.