Q: In 2nd gear, car feels like it might independently shift

asked by on September 07, 2016

When driving in traffic and beginning to accelerate, I am in 2nd gear when there is a feeling like the car independently changes gear and also feels like it might stall. Then it jerks and pulls off. However, the gear that I was in does not change. This is very annoying when I am in rush-hour traffic. When in slow traffic, it is even more uncomfortable and frustrating. I have taken it four different times to the same Audi dealer and whatever they did only fixed it on a temporary basis. It has gone back to the same problem! When I first noticed this, I thought it was just the engine running so I waited to see about it. This problem just keeps on and on. The technicians can not seem to replicate the problem. When I drive it all the time, it is definitely there. What do you suggest that might be the cause of this?

Oil/Fluid Leak Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote
Car is stalling Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

Hi there, thanks for writing about your 2011 Audi S5. Your vehicle’s transmission has 2 clutches that alternately engage and disengage, under computer software control, as the vehicle accelerates and decelerates. The software compensates for wear in most cases, but if the clutch gets oil on it from a leaky engine or transmission seal, jerky shift changes can occur. There is a software update for the transmission/clutch controller. Check with your Audi dealer for this software fix. If your car starts to stall, a technician from YourMechanic can come to your home or office to inspect your stalling problem.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Engine tick and check engine light.

Hello, thanks for writing in. It is possible that you have a fuel injection issue, but that is not that common on this vehicle. Most of the time when this occurs with a ticking noise also it is due to...

Plastic intake manifold on the North Star engine.

Hi there. The 1993 Northstar intake is made of magnesium, and has a different system for "blowout" or backfiring protection. It has been used by some folks who have had bad experiences with the "plastic" intake manifolds. There will be...

2005 saturn relay does it have a fuel filter

Start by checking for spark and fuel. If all fuses are good, possible causes can be a bad fuel pump if no fuel pressure is found at the injector rail. Also, it could be a bad ignition coil or bad...

trouble getting into reverse - 2010 Hyundai i20

Hey there. This is a common problem when the transmission synchros are going bad. These are small forks in your transmission that help get your car in and out of gear. When these get worn or break, you will experience...

Speedometer stopped working, how do I repair it? 2003 Audi A6

Hello - most likely the speedometer sensor has failed, or the wiring to it has become disconnected. Check that first. It's also possible that the speedometer sensor drive gear has failed (small plastic gear), or the instrument panel speedo gauge...

Sensor under intake manifold

Hi there, thanks for writing in about your 1993 Honda Civic del Sol. Your friend was probably referring to a failed MAP sensor. It does reside under the intake manifold and can cause mixture issues resulting in RPM surges. One...

Car temp gauge is saying overheating , idle engine

Hi there. I don't think that the V-Power gas has anything to do with your overheating issue. You indicated that when you turn the car off, you hear a sound as if the car is still running. That is most...

Car shuts off while idling

Hello. This can be caused by many things on this vehicle, but the most common one is the crankshaft position sensor. I have seen many of these fail on this car and cause this. I usually use a scan tool...

Hi - Knocking noise

Hello. If there is a knocking noise then it may have some bad fuel or it may be another failure like an internal engine problem or a bad sensor. I usually start the diagnostic process by scanning the computer for...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Get Motion Sickness
For For people that suffer from motion sickness, even on the shortest car trip, riding in a vehicle can prove to be unbearable. What’s great is that there are a number of cars on the market that can help to...
Understanding Main Gears Vs. Planetary Gears
Aspiring Aspiring mechanics spend hours learning about how main gears and planetary gears work in a car transmission, so a full dissertation simply isn’t possible within this relatively brief article. If you’re curious about how they work, though, this brief...
What Does It Mean When My Car Is "Burning" Oil?
Burning oil is usually caused by leaking oil that burns up on hot engine or exhaust components. Fix leaking oil to prevent expensive car repairs.