Q: I noticed my starter sounds like it's having trouble catching the engine. is it the starter or just the solenoid?

asked by on March 07, 2018

the last few times I started my car, the starter sounds like it's having a problem catching into the engine. I've had to have the solenoid replaced before, but I don't know if the whole thing has to be fixed or maybe it's just the cold weather.

I know it's not the battery since it's new. Once it starts it's just fine. I'm trying to narrow it down, so I don't waste time or money on it if it doesn't need it.

My car has 119000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Car is hard to start Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Hi Karla. Thanks for contacting us tonight. If the starter solenoid has been changed before the actual starter has been, it’s likely that the starter is what’s causing the gear to have issues connecting to the flywheel. However, before you attempt any repairs, it would be best to have this inspected by a professional mechanic - so you ensure the right repairs are completed.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Battery and starter problems, car won't start even after replacing battery and starter.
I would check the fuses for the starter relay. You may have a blown fuse for the starter. I would have YourMechanic come and diagnose the starting problem further (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/car-is-not-starting-inspection).
How do I delete a paired phone?
If you would like to delete one of the Bluetooth paired phones, you can do so very easily: 1. Turn on the infotainment system. 2. Press the CONFIG button. 3. Use the MENU/SEL knob to select Phone Settings or Bluetooth...
Hood alarm sensor problem
You are right - this is the hood sensor that is causing this. This is very common, especially if the vehicle has never been in an accident. The switch typically is what is failing, but the hood may need to...
Coolant leaking out
It appears that you may have a couple of different issues going on with your Toyota. Addressing the coolant leak first is very important, as if it is left untreated, the engine can overheat and serious damage can occur. Coolant...
Buying a car--2016 Camry V6 with 6-speed auto vs. Accord 6 with the CVT
Yes it is true. I'd go for the Camry (https://www.yourmechanic.com/scheduled-maintenance/toyota-camry/) by far. Those 6-speed autos are tried-and-trusted transmissions. They can last a really long time. For Hondas (https://www.yourmechanic.com/scheduled-maintenance/honda-accord/), it has always had problems with the automatic transmissions and the CVTs...
My brake lights not working I changed the switch
It is possible both bulbs are burned out. The filament in each bulb should be tested with an ohmmeter. The bulbs can also be powered off the car to see if both filaments work but be wary of short circuits...
Wire for Check Engine Light was cut
The check engine light bulb should have one 12 volt hot wire that is run in parallel to other bulb lights. You can check for battery voltage between that wire (if you believe you have identified it) and ground. The...
Car wont start or crank
You need to verify the shift cable has not come off the transmission causing the car to not be in park so it can start. If this is okay then you may have a theft system problem if light is...
Question about oil
Synthetic oil doesn't seem to do a better job of lubricating, but it doesn't wear out as fast. So if you are bad about letting your oil go a long time between changes synthetic is a good idea. I use...

Related articles

How Long Does an Auxiliary Battery Last?
When When a dual battery system is added to a vehicle, it is usually because accessories have been added to the vehicle that are not factory-standard, and the primary battery in the vehicle does not deliver sufficient power to drive...
Mercury Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) Car Program
Drivers Drivers who are shopping around for a used Mercury vehicle may want to check out cars under their certified pre-owned program. Many manufacturers have a certified pre-owned (CPO) program, and each one is set up differently. Read on to...
Understanding the Mercury Intelligent Oil Life Monitor and Service Indicator Lights
Car symbols, or dashboard lights, are a car service reminder. The Mercury Intelligent Oil Life Monitor indicates when and what service your car needs.