Q: Hard shifting and thunking noise at the rear end

asked by on July 08, 2016

I have a problem with the transmission on my car, for which I went to the dealership and had it replaced. The problem still exists despite having it replaced. When I apply the pedal to the limit and shift the lever, something starts happening with the lever. It feels as if it is hard to move and there is a grabbing feel to it. Also, there is occasionally a thunking noise that seems to be coming from the rear end. What should I do?

Car is hard to shift Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Hello. The shift lever should remain stable unless it’s moved by the driver. If it pops out of gear, even after a transmission replacement, I suggest inspecting the transmission mounts, engine mounts, and subframe bushings. Cases show that the subframe bushings on the rear would go bad and cause a thumping like sound.

Have a technician inspect your rear subframe and bushings. Also check for other component faults which could cause a similar thumping noise such as sway bar end links or strut mounts. I’d recommend enlisting a qualified technician to help you with these checks. Consider YourMechanic, as a qualified technician can come to you and perform these checks to accurately diagnose your shifting issue firsthand.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Brake lights staying on.
Hi there, Chances are the brake light switch is faulty. My advice is to have a mechanic, such as one from YourMechanic, diagnose and repair the brake light switch circuit (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/brake-light-is-not-working-inspection). Fuse 14 can be removed when the car is...
Having trouble trying to locate my knock sensor. It's throwing a code for it. 1,2,4,5,6 cylinder misfires
As you may know a knock sensor may fail for any of the following reasons: The knock sensor is faulty and needs to be replaced There is a wiring open/short/fault in the knock sensor circuit The PCM/ECM has failed Any...
Charging system - 1990 Ford F-150
Hello. I would suggest checking the voltage regulator (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/instrument-voltage-regulator-replacement). This is a unit that monitors the charging system to maintain the proper voltage in the battery by regulating the rate at which the battery is charged. When this is not...
Terrible squealing upon cold start and for a few minutes while driving afterward.
Hello. The noise you are hearing is that new serpentine belt sliding and skipping on the pulleys they are driving. This is typically caused by the belt being loose, or a pulley refusing to turn freely. Your vehicle is equipped...
Ocassional loss of power
Hi there. If your MB panel van is diesel, it's possible that the change in diesel fuel (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-does-a-diesel-engine-work-by-jason-unrau) (summer to winter blend) along with a clogged fuel filter (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/fuel-filter-replacement) or fuel injectors (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/fuel-injector-replacement) might be causing the stumbling issue you're...
My car won't start; the lights work, but the radio doesn't
Hi there. It appears as if you might have a battery that has lost it's cranking amps and thus can't start your car. Over time, the battery in your vehicle will wear out, causing it to lose amps but still...
I don't have any clue what happened!!!
Hello. The squeaky drive belt was the cause of the problem. It has likely failed. The water pump, which is driven by the drive belt, is responsible for the flow of coolant through the cooling system and the heater core....
what would be the average cost to own my vehicle over a ten year period
Typical "lifecycle" vehicle ownership and operation costs, such as you are inquiring about, are calculated on a 5 year interval. Going out 10 years has too much inherent uncertainly in inflation projections, and the costs of fuel, insurance, and repairs....
Buying a new 2017 Mercedez-Benz GLC300. Should I purchase the extended warranty? Also, what about the purchase protection plan?
Hello. I say it's a great idea to go ahead and get the extended warranty as well as the purchase protection plan that covers the wheels tires and etc. Mercedes are great luxury vehicles. They perform well and they always...

Related articles

How Often Do I Need to Replace the Transmission Fluid?
The basic definition of a transmission is the part of a vehicle that transfers the power from the engine to the wheels. How...
How a Cable Clutch System Works
If If you drive a car with a manual transmission, you know that to get your car moving, you depress the clutch pedal, choose a gear, and then give the vehicle a bit of gas. But have you ever wondered...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2013 Acura ILX Hybrid
Acura Acura returns from a spate of years devoted to the higher-end luxury market, and they do so in style with a car that practically invents its own segment. The ILX Hybrid is the half electric portion of the brand...