Q: Hard shifting and thunking noise at the rear end

asked by on July 08, 2016

I have a problem with the transmission on my car, for which I went to the dealership and had it replaced. The problem still exists despite having it replaced. When I apply the pedal to the limit and shift the lever, something starts happening with the lever. It feels as if it is hard to move and there is a grabbing feel to it. Also, there is occasionally a thunking noise that seems to be coming from the rear end. What should I do?

Car is hard to shift Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

Hello. The shift lever should remain stable unless it’s moved by the driver. If it pops out of gear, even after a transmission replacement, I suggest inspecting the transmission mounts, engine mounts, and subframe bushings. Cases show that the subframe bushings on the rear would go bad and cause a thumping like sound.

Have a technician inspect your rear subframe and bushings. Also check for other component faults which could cause a similar thumping noise such as sway bar end links or strut mounts. I’d recommend enlisting a qualified technician to help you with these checks. Consider YourMechanic, as a qualified technician can come to you and perform these checks to accurately diagnose your shifting issue firsthand.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Nissan NV 400 hissing noise from servo when you push brake pedal lightly 2013 Nissan NV 1500

Hi there - yes, I believe you are correct. Sounds like the diaphragm in the booster has ruptured, and is leaking air (to the engine), resulting in little or no brake pedal effort assist. I recommend a brake booster replacement](https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/hydraulic-brake-booster-replacement)...

I have a 2013 Acura Ilx. When I push button on handle on drivers side it no longer beeps and locks.

Hello. This is a programming issue within the door locking system. The programming can become corrupted and cause this. You will need to take the vehicle to the dealer in order to get it reprogrammed.

white smoke

Hello Mr. Anderson, thank you for writing in. Lets start by saying that most vehicles will produce a small amount of white smoke right when starting. This is happening because condensation builds up in the exhaust and engine compartment. This...

Charging system failure

It sounds like you may have a problem with a weak battery or potentially a failing alternator which will cause this light to come on. As you may know, the alternator is responsible for charging the battery while the engine...

Battery leaking and car overheating

Hi. The battery can be serviced, but I recommend you replace the battery it to avoid further complications. Be sure that any fluid that has leaked onto other parts in the engine is cleaned up. The Check Engine Light most...

Front transmission seal is leaking. Quoted $700 to fix it, with a 30-day warranty.

Hi, thanks for writing in. This is a pretty good deal for this sort of work considering that the whole transmission will have to be removed from the vehicle in order to replace that seal. This labor is even more...

Is the Hyundai Getz a good reliable second hand car to buy?

Hi there. Unfortunately, the Getz is not a vehicle we're familiar with in the United States. The Excel however is a very good and dependable vehicle; so I would assume since the Getz is manufactured with similar components; it is...

Loud squeaky noise and bad wobbles

A squeaking noise from brake pads, right after installation, is sometimes due to a high metallic content in a low cost aftermarket pad. The safest thing always is to use OEM specified brake pads, on OEM rotors, because the vehicle...

Error code p144c

Hello, thank you for writing in. The code you are receiving pertains to the EVAP canister purge valve. This valve is one of the components that the computer tests immediately upon start up, and then continuously during operation. With that...

Related articles

What Does It Mean When an Engine "Knocks"?
If your engine is making a knocking noise it means there's a problem. The wrong fuel octane, carbon buildup, and bad spark plugs can cause knocking.
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Have 3 or More Kids
If If you have three or more kids, you could probably get by with a mid-size sedan if all you want to do is take them from Point A to Point B. Realistically, though, having kids means music lessons, athletics,...
How Long Does Transmission Fluid Last?
Transmission Transmission fluid lubricates all the moving parts of your car transmission, and in an automatic transmission, it also acts as a coolant and viscous fluid that delivers engine power to the transmission. What kind of transmission fluid to use...