Q: Changing transmission fluid on a high-mileage car

asked by on May 17, 2016

I have a car with 198,000 miles. The automatic transmission fluid has a brown red tinted color to it. I'm not sure if the transmissionn fluid has ever been changed but it is not black. Is that a good indication that the ATF has been changed at least once?

It probably has been changed. Here is the problem with changing the transmission fluid. On a normal car, you should change it every 40,000 miles or so. So if you don’t, and you go 198,000 miles and never change it, then a fresh change can sometimes make it slip. It’s kind of a gamble. So if you buy a car new, change it every 40,000 miles, and you won’t have that problem. In your case, if it shifts okay, I personally wouldn’t do it, with that kind of mileage. Because you would take some kind of a gamble changing it now.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

How many liter of transmission oil? 2016 Mercedes GLA 250 4 Matic

Hi there - in terms of actual fluid capacity, Mercedes says 10 quarts. If your service center is using the "flush" method for changing this fluid, they may use up to 16 quarts since they are injecting new fluid into...

What type of transmission fluid should I use?

Just like engine oil, it’s important to have the right type of transmission fluid in your car. Adding the wrong type can be very bad. For automatic transmissions, Honda recommends using Honda ATF DW-1. For manual transmissions, Honda recommends manual...

Car wont shift into drive with dead battery

Rather than trying to shift into drive, try shifting into neutral. If you are trying to move the vehicle, drive will lock it in gear, but neutral will allow the wheels to spin freely. If you are having difficulties shifting...

My car's shifter is stuck in park.

Hi there. The shifter gets the power from the brake light switch as for a safety switch. In order to change gears, the brakes must be applied. Check the power into the brake light switch and the power out of...

Wont go in reverse and drive feels like you are holding brake on 2003 Chevrolet Malibu

Hi - your symptoms describe a very confused transmission. Check first for low transmission fluid (or too much). Check next for problem codes coming from the transmission, whether the Check Engine light is on or not. With this transmission (4T40E)...

Engine hesitation and blue smoke

The blue smoke coming out of the exhaust is an indication that the motor is burning excessive oil. The Mazda 3 engines are known for this. When the valve seals become worn this can cause oil to seep into the...

Car turns on like normal but won't move forward or in reverse.

Hello, the automatic transmission has three systems; electronic, hydraulic, and mechanical. You should check your fluid level as well as condition of the fluid. What you describe could be an internal mechanical failure with transmission. The electrical system which...

How does the automatic transmission work?

Automatic transmissions are simpler to operate than manual transmissions are, but you should still be familiar with how they work. The shift indicator in the dash shows you the gear selected. You can also see this on the...

A loud 'pop' occurred, and car will not drive foreword or back. Did my axle break? 2012 Dodge Journey

Hello - this scenario seems to me to be a failure of a CV joint the axle, or the transmission itself. Turning and accelerating puts a great load on CV joints. If this is no longer a warranty-covered item, I...

Related articles

How Long Does a Transmission Filter Last?
Your Your transmission filter is a very important component in your vehicle, because it’s the front line of defense when it comes to keeping contaminants out of your transmission fluid. Most automobile manufacturers recommend a transmission filter change every 2...
How to Check Manual Transmission Fluid
Transmission Transmission fluid is an important fluid in your car and needs to be topped up on a regular basis. If your transmission fluid is leaking, it can cause damage to your engine. Checking the transmission fluid in a manual...
5 Signs Your Car Isn't Shifting Correctly
Improper shifting is a sign of car transmission problems. The solution might be simple or complex, but get it inspected to avoid expensive repairs.