Q: catalytic converter going bad does it need to be replaced?

asked by on July 30, 2017

So my cat is going bad and a check engine light came on. As of now, there is no white smoke from my exhaust but I can tell there has been a performance drop. Do I need to replace this right away? I do not need to pass smog until next year sometime.

My car has 129000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

The catalyst should be replaced as soon as possible if it is bad. The backpressure on the engine will cause the engine to run with less power and may overheat the engine valves resulting in engine damage. the catalyst can be tested for excessive backpressure with a pressure tester put in the O2 sensor hole near the manifold. This verifies the catalyst is bad and not an O2 sensor after the catalyst is defective.

Hi there. The biggest issue with not replacing a damaged catalytic converter is that it will progressively create excessive build-up of carbon deposits further up the exhaust system. Eventually it will start building up on valves and can cause serious engine damage if not replaced.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $65/hr

What others are asking

My 2004 Tahoe warning light says REDUCED POWER. IT'S really cold out, had to be boosted when the warning appeared.

There will be stored trouble codes that need to be read and cleared. With any luck, that will be all there is to it. When you try to start a car with a dead battery, it really confuses the electronics...

Car stalling when put into gear.

It sounds to me like the engine might have drivability problems and the load from the transmission is overcoming the engine power at idle. Have a certified mechanic who is familiar with older carbureted engines inspect the timing and check...

Engine problems.

Hello. From what you describe it would appear likely that the backfiring and performance issues are a result of the fuel problem. A rich fuel mixture can be caused by a wide variety of issues. A few things I would...

AC causing knocking sound.

The knocking noise is the temperature blend door actuator trying to move the blend door. The actuator would need to be checked and replaced. I recommend having a certified mechanic, such as one from YourMechanic, come and inspect your vehicle's...

Can you bypass the AC compressor? 2004 Chevrolet Trailblazer

Hello - if the AC compressor clutch and bearing are still OK, you can simply unplug the wire to the compressor clutch, and the clutch pulley bearing will continue to turn with the belt, and no other action is necessary....

Heater blows out cold air

It is very possible that the coolant level in your 2014 Dodge Dart is low. The symptoms you are describing are almost always caused by a low coolant level. Likewise, low coolant level means there is likely a leak somewhere....

my car is rumbling at idle

It depends on the origin of the noise and/or problem. If the rumbling is due, say, to an exhaust leak and the leak is, say, in the exhaust manifold you risk carbon monoxide poisoning by driving the car. If the...

My audi smells like gasoline I read it could be a clogged fuel filter my mechanic wants to replace a plug on my fuel pump

What your mechanic says sounds more likely. There is no gasoline flowing to the turbocharger, so a flange or gasket leak is unlikely to be the cause. A leaking turbo flange would give you an exhaust leak and any odor...

I hear a clicking noise when engine starts

From the information provided on your Nissan Frontier, has lead me to believe that it may be experiencing an undercharged battery or even possibly a bad starter. To be 100% certain however, it may be time to enlist the assistance...

Related articles

2012 Chevrolet Silverado vs. 2012 Dodge Ram: Which One Should I Buy?
When you are looking for a way to get a load of mulch or gravel, or need to haul a large trailer or boat behind your vehicle, chances are you are looking for a truck. Trucks are not meant to...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Dodge Journey
The The 2012 Dodge Journey is easy to drive, and it’s not so large that you will have a difficult time parking it. It’s an attractive vehicle that has the power you need whether you are hauling a full carpool,...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Live in a City
Living Living and driving in the city means you’re faced with parking constraints, narrow streets, and the constant stop and go of traffic. With all of that said when you’re ready to purchase a used vehicle these are all things...