How to Communicate Effectively With an Auto Mechanic

While many cars are built to last, eventually even the most reliable vehicles break down. When this happens, knowing how to talk to the auto mechanic and communicate the symptoms your vehicle exhibits goes a long way toward getting your vehicle fixed right the first time - and it saves you money by avoiding unnecessary repairs. To accurately describe a problem with your vehicle and make sure the mechanic understands what exactly is wrong with your car when you take it in for repair, take a few factors into consideration.

Part 1 of 3: Communicating your car’s symptoms

Clear communication ensures that your mechanic understands exactly what symptoms your vehicle is exhibiting. While you mostly likely won't know exactly what the problem is, if you can describe the symptoms accurately, you can ensure that the mechanic has a better understanding about what is wrong with your car so they can fix it more quickly.

Step 1: Write down the problems. When you start having issues with your vehicle, write down exactly what it is doing.

This helps you remember exactly what symptoms your car has exhibited when you take it in. Otherwise, if you try to recall from memory what is going on, you might miss an important detail.

You should include any specific sounds, sensations, and the behavior of your vehicle in your description, as well as any leaks or smells you have noticed.

Step 2: Explain the problem clearly. When talking to the mechanic, make sure that you describe the problem in language that they can understand.

Instead of simply stating that the vehicle is making a sound, describe the problem in more detail. The following is a list of common terms for auto symptoms:

  • Backfire: A loud bang that issues from a vehicle's tailpipe or engine.
  • Bottoming: This happens when the car bottoms out when going over a bump or high spot in the roadway. Often accompanied by a harshness felt through the steering column or by excessive noise.
  • Bucking: A lurching of the vehicle felt when changing gears or after the vehicle hesitates.
  • Dieseling: A term used to describe what happens after you turn the vehicle off and it continues to run briefly.
  • Hesitation: A common problem where the vehicle suffers a temporary loss of power when accelerating.
  • Knocking: A rapid rattling or knocking sound heard when accelerating.
  • Misfire: This happens when the engine cylinders do not fire like they should, leading to a loss of power.
  • Shimmy: When the vehicle exhibits a side-to-side motion felt through the steering wheels or tires.
  • Sluggish: When a car does not accelerate strongly or smoothly ands feels like it is bogged down.
  • Surge: The opposite of sluggish. When a car suddenly surges upward in speed and the engine exhibits higher RPMs.

Part 2 of 3: Test drive to demonstrate problems

If you cannot explain the problem properly to the mechanic, or the problem cannot be detected upon inspection, you might offer to let the mechanic take the vehicle for a test drive. This is especially important if the problem only occurs while the vehicle is in motion. Leave it up to the mechanic to decide who should drive during the test drive.

driver with mechanic

Step 1: Drive the car with the mechanic. Make sure to drive the vehicle in situations similar to when the problem occurs.

If you are driving, make sure to drive safely and observe all posted speed limits and road signs.

If the problem does not occur on the test drive, you may have to bring the vehicle back the next time the problem occurs.

Part 3 of 3: Get an estimate for any necessary repairs

The final part of the process is getting an estimate from the mechanic on how much it costs to get the problem fixed. It is important that both you and the mechanic understand exactly what needs repair, and that you understand the exact costs associated with the repair.

hand holding a clipboard

Step 1: Discuss the repairs needed. Have the mechanic explain what repairs your vehicle needs.

You need to know what is involved and the length of time it should take. This allows you to borrow a vehicle or get a rental car if needed.

  • Tip: Give the mechanic a good contact number to reach you. This allows the mechanic to contact you immediately, and can save time when making the repair. They also need the number to reach you in the case of any unforeseen problems.

Step 2: Discuss the costs involved. Next, have the mechanic tell you how much any repairs should cost.

At this point, it is OK to discuss which repairs are necessary and which can wait. Most mechanics understand that people are often on a budget, and will make recommendations on what they think are the most pressing repairs and which can wait.

Do not try to negotiate the costs, as your estimate includes the part and the time involved in making the repair.

  • Warning: Keep in mind that repair costs could go up if another problem is found while making the original repair. Make sure that the mechanic understands that you want notification in such cases. That way, the mechanic can explain the problem and you can make the ultimate decision on how to proceed.

Step 3: Decide how to proceed. With the costs in mind, make a decision on what repairs to have done, if any.

If you feel the mechanic's estimate is too high, consider getting a second opinion or check with other repair shops to see what their rates are to fix the same problem and how long repairs will take.

  • Tip: Keep in mind that most mechanics are not out to rip you off, but do need to make a living too. What they charge to fix a problem is what they charge - if you disagree with their prices, then you are free to take your vehicle elsewhere. Most repair shops charge a fee for a diagnostic. Ask what they charge before you have them look at your vehicle.

A vehicle that needs repairs can lead to unwanted stress. By taking your vehicle to an expert mechanic, you find out what is wrong with your car and what you need to do to have it repaired, including the cost and the time involved in making the repair. If you are unsure how to proceed, you can Ask a Mechanic with YourMechanic to get advice you can trust regarding how to proceed in this or any other auto-related situation.

Next Step

Schedule Car stays running when I shut the key off Inspection

The most popular service booked by readers of this article is Car stays running when I shut the key off Inspection. Once the problem has been diagnosed, you will be provided with an upfront quote for the recommended fix and receive $20.00 off as a credit towards the repair. YourMechanic’s technicians bring the dealership to you by performing this job at your home or office 7-days a week between 7AM-9PM. We currently cover over 2,000 cities and have 100k+ 5-star reviews... LEARN MORE


The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Recent Car stays running when I shut the key off Inspection reviews

Excellent Rating


Rating Summary


24 years of experience
818 reviews
24 years of experience
Chevrolet Colorado L5-3.7L - Check Engine Light is on - Orange Park, Florida
Brian is a very experienced mechanic. Billing not so sharp. Wrong time (corona-19).to be stiff with adding up, Informing the older customers what to expect? Very sorry to say goodbye to a great mechanic!
Chevrolet Lumina - Battery - Jacksonville, Florida
Brian was terrific. He changed my battery quickly. He checked my alternator to make sure it was OK. He let me know of items on my car that needed attention. He was very professional. He treated my car like it was his own. Thanks Brian.


27 years of experience
326 reviews
27 years of experience
Buick Century V6-3.3L - Car stays running when I shut the key off - Tempe, Arizona
Terry showed up on time. He was friendly and professional. Inspected and determined repair that was needed. Unfortunately parts house didn't have part in stock(the car is a '91), had to be ordered so could not complete the repair.


21 years of experience
75 reviews
21 years of experience
Buick LaCrosse V6-3.8L - Car stays running when I shut the key off - San Antonio, Texas
Gustavo was very courteous and helpful. Enjoyed meeting him and appreciate his evaluation of my car.


42 years of experience
10 reviews
42 years of experience
Acura MDX V6-3.5L - Car stays running when I shut the key off - Durham, North Carolina
He's very friendly and did good work!

Need Help With Your Car?

Our certified mobile mechanics make house calls in over 2,000 U.S. cities. Fast, free online quotes for your car repair.


Related articles

How to Get an EPA Technician Certification
The EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) technician certification program educates people who wish to repair automotive air conditioning systems.
How to Get a Smog Technician License
A smog technician license will allow a mechanic to perform smog inspections and repairs in states that require cars to undergo regular smog checks.
High-Paying Mobile Mechanic Jobs Near Me
Our comprehensive guide to finding great-paying mobile mechanic jobs near your location. Nationwide mobile auto technician job opportunities.

Related questions

Advice on how to become a mechanic
I learned from my grandfather who was a mechanic. I started when I was 14, but he wouldn't teach me anything, he'd only let me watch. Over time I practiced and figured things out myself. Today, you can learn a...
Mechanic as a career?
If you're interested in cars, you might want to train to become a mechanic. The guys at YourMechanic were telling me that, for qualified mechanics, pay rates start at $40 an hour. Of course, you are not a qualified mechanic...
am studient but i would like to learn more about that so i need your help
This is a Forum to ask questions on automotive repairs. I was an automotive instructor for over eight years and can answer most any question you may have. You will need to ask specific questions since this Forum is not...

How can we help?

Our service team is available 7 days a week, Monday - Friday from 6 AM to 5 PM PST, Saturday - Sunday 7 AM - 4 PM PST.

1 (855) 347-2779 ·