Q: Is it mandatory to replace the rotors with a front brake pad replacement? 2010 BMW

asked by on March 15, 2017

is it mandatory to replace the rotors with a front brake pad replacement
My car has a manual transmission.

Hi there - if the brake rotor is worn below a minimum rotor thickness (stamped on each rotor), then yes, it can be mandatory to replace the rotor. This is for safety reasons. If the rotor is grooved and requires surfacing for the new pads, and this machining results in a disc that is too thin, it cannot be re-used and must be replaced. Surfacing the rotor to make it perfectly smooth provides the maximum amount of surface area for the brake pads to engage - maximizing brake performance. In many cases, it is less expensive to simply replace the brake rotor, rather than machine it smooth. Worn brake rotor symptoms are as follows.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

What Causes a Car's AC System to Rattle When It Is Turned On?
The cause of the rattle will depend on whether it is coming from inside the car or under the hood. Typically, a rattle would be associated with the compressor and underhood components. Let’s take a look by starting under the...
How Do Drive and Serpentine Belts Work?
Accessory drive belts are used to transfer rotational motion from the crankshaft to the other accessories on the engine. The driven accessories include the generator, power steering pump (https://www.yourmechanic.com/parts/power-steering-pump), air conditioning compressor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/parts/ac-compressor), secondary air pump, and the water pump...
Water pump might be bad. Car has coolant leak.
Hi there. Coolant can leak from a number of different spots on your vehicle. If the coolant is steadily leaking while the engine is running, then it is typically the water pump. If not then it can be the radiator,...
Car shakes when started
Hello, Having your car shake during start up is not a pleasant experience, to say the least. There are several factors that could lead to the symptoms your Monte Carlo is experiencing with shaking while starting. While the timing chain...
Honda Recall notice
Unfortunately warranty related things can only be handled by the dealership. This is because they need to carefully document the findings to report back to Honda whether or not your vehicle needs the repair. I would get this in as...
advancetrac and abs light on after cv axle replacement
This may be related to faulty wheel speed sensors which are located at each of the four wheels. These sensors monitor wheel speed which is relayed to the ABS system. When the ABS system detects an abnormal speed for the...
I drove my car about 50 miles without the oil cap it started rattling and cut off and now it wont crank
Having driven that far with no oil cap, it is likely that the engine oil level ran low enough to cause engine damage, possible seizing the engine. If that is what happened, adding oil will not help once the engine...
im having trouble looking for a replacement Trans for my Chevy Impala 2006 police pack 3.9l any other transmission i can use?
Hi Johnatan. Thanks for contacting us today. It's recommended to replace any OEM transmission with the same type of system from the same year, make and model of vehicle. You might find luck with a local transmission shop or ask...
Nissian Altima engine shaking after coil and plug change
You may have a timing chain tensioner or guides issue. You should try to identify where the noise is coming from and scan the computer to get codes and have a mechanic like one from YourMechanic come to you and...

Related articles

How Can You Tell When Your Brake Fluid Is Running Low?
Brake fluid is a vital part of your vehicle’s operations, and it is often overlooked. Most mechanics and other experts suggest checking your...
How Long Do Brake Shoes (Rear) Last?
Most Most of the older cars on the market have two different types of brake systems on the front and rear of them. Generally, the front brakes will be pads and rotors, while the back will be drums and shoes....
How to Diagnose and Repair Noisy Brakes
Squeaky car brakes are hard to drive with. If your car brakes are making noise, check the brake pads and brake rotors to see if they are worn down.