Q: check enginelight is on and the gas range fluctuates often even after i changed the gas cap and had a smoke test done

asked by on April 19, 2017

my check engine light came on. took it in for repairs and based on the code, they replaced the gas cap. the light stayed off for a few days. I filled the tank and drove to work, all was fine. on my way home, as I started climbing a hill, I noticed the temp guage went up a little (almost to the 100 degree mark) then the light came back on. took it back in and the same code came up so they did a smoke test that did not detect any leaks. the light stayed off until I filled the tank up again and the exact same scenario occurred on the same hill. I took it to the MB dealer and they could not find any leaks either said that the light is not affecting the condition/driving of the car - but who wants to drive a car not knowing what is wrong with it. I filled it up last night and decided to watch the gas range. it fluctuated often and went from 507 miles at one point to under 400 miles in a 27 mile trip. and when sitting still, the range continued to drop every 12 seconds

Check Engine Light is on Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Codes can’t be the "basis" for replacing ANY part on a car. Codes ONLY provide clues to mechanics as to the origin of a fault and the ONLY use of these clues is they permit identification of the parts and systems that must be ACTUALLY tested and diagnosed. If a mechanic ever tells, you, "I just read Code Xxxxx, let’s replace "x part", run for the exits (literally). There may have been absolutely nothing wrong with the gas cap and if a non-OEM cap was installed, you may be worse off now because non-OEM caps, of sub-standard design and quality, will often themselves be a cause of EVAP system codes and for that reason non-OEM caps are not recommended. To best advise you, I would need to see the exact code as that code will be associated with quite a few items but if the Code happens to be P0455, or "close", there are lots of places where you could have a vapor leak, such as fuel pump gasket, or pinhole rust spot in top of tank that won’t show on smoke test. Furthermore, there are component faults, that have nothing to do with leaks, that will set Code P0455. As far as the gas gauge fluctuation, if the only code that has set relates to an EVAP system malfunction, the gauge fluctuation likely stems from a problem with the sending, or receiving unit (dash gauge) and/or the interconnecting wiring. The bottom line is if you request a check engine light diagnostic - Code P0455, the responding certified mechanic will get this resolved without further delay. If you have further questions or concerns, do not hesitate to re-contact YourMechanic as we are always here to help you.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I use the automatic dimming rearview mirror?
The rearview mirror can be dimmed for increased visibility at night. When it is dark outside, the brightness of headlights in the rearview mirror can make it hard for you to see, so you should always dim your rearview mirror...
Overheating after replacing water pump, thermostat and coolant temp. Sensor
Hello. That hole in the water pump is there to let you know when the bearing in the water pump is failing. It starts leaking when the bearing is going out so that it will be replaced prior to a...
A rattle sound underneath truck when starting or when driving and speeding up
Hey there. This could be a variety of things as most cars tend to vibrate a bit which will cause bolts to loosen or fall out over time. Especially depending on a person's individual driving habits and conditions. There may...
When the car is about to just fully stop it makes a squeaking noise to what seems to be in the rear breaks
Hello. This is likely the result of the brake pads wearing down to the "wear mark" which a certain thickness on the brake pads designed to alert when it is times to consider replacing the brake pads. This is not...
Truck runs really rough, smells like antifreeze in the cabin, testing said it was O2 sensor, and there is an overheating, hissing noise
Hello. You can possibly rent a cooling system pressure tester from a local chain auto parts store. With the engine off, remove the radiator cap and pump the cooling system to no more than 10 psi. You will be able...
Brake pads replacement
Hello, thanks for writing in. Generally most brake pads have a specific thickness tolerance that is used to warn the owner of the vehicle of when it may be time to replace the pads. What this means is that you...
Possible issue with transmission
It sounds like your transmission may be having trouble building up enough oil pressure to engage the clutches while it is idling. The oil transmission oil pump runs off of the input shaft and runs at engine speed. When things...
Difficulty starting my vehicle for a couple weeks until it would not start at all.
Hello, thanks for writing in. I believe you are saying that there is a problem with the car cranking; both before and after replacing the battery. And, that applying a booster power source did not improve the ability of the...
1999 Toyota camry le gets really loud when accelerating but muffler new
Hello. You are correct. The most likely cause is going to be a faulty gasket. Look at any joining sections of pipe from the exhaust manifold back. It is often hard to check certain parts, and that is where exhaust...

Related articles

P2193 OBD-II Trouble Code: System Too Lean at Higher Load Bank 2
P2193 P2193 code definition System Too Lean at Higher Load Bank 2 What the P2193 code means P2193 is an OBD-II generic code for the Engine Control Module (ECM) detecting the fuel control has reached its rich limits when the...
P2626 OBD-II Trouble Code: O2 Sensor Pumping Current Trim Circuit/Open Bank 1 Sensor 1
P2626 Code Definition The P2626 code is a generic powertrain code related to computer circuit output issues. This code appears when the...
P0489 OBD-II Trouble Code: Exhaust Gas Recirculation “A” Control Circuit Low
P0489 means that the exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) “A” control circuit is reporting a low voltage flow due to faulty wiring or clogged EGR passages.