How to Diagnose Your Brake Issues

There are a few warning signs that you should be aware of regarding your vehicle’s brakes. A hard-to press-pedal, grinding sounds, and vibrations in the pedal are all signs that something isn’t working properly. With this guide, you will learn a few ways you can test for and identify issues with your brakes.

Part 1 of 4: Testing the parking brake

While the parking brake may not seem as significant as your normal brakes, it is very important that it works properly. You need to use your parking brake when parked on a hill to save your vehicle’s transmission - and in emergencies, it may be able to help slow your vehicle down.

parking brake handle and person depressing parking brake pedal

Step 1: With the engine off, apply your parking brake. You shouldn’t have to push or pull too hard to apply the parking brake.

Typically, you’ll hear about four to seven clicks as you engage the parking brake. Pedal-type parking brakes should not go all the way to the floor.

If you have to pull or push the brake lever all the way to its limit and the brakes don’t engage, the linkage is malfunctioning. The cable may have been stretched out or the linkage in the brakes may be broken. This should be repaired as soon as possible.

Step 2: Start the car engine. With the parking brake still applied, put the car in drive and move your foot off the brake.

Make sure you have space in front of you in case your car doesn’t stop. It is okay for the car to move a few inches, but it shouldn’t move very far.

  • Note: For manual transmissions, stop the car on an incline or decline, put it in neutral with the parking brake on, and move your foot off the brakes. The parking brake should hold the car.

Step 3: Release the parking brake. Make sure the car can move with no resistance and that the parking brake does fully disengage.

Like before, if the parking brake does not fully disengage, the cable or linkage is most likely the cause. The cables can be adjusted to compensate for the stretching over time and if it is too tight, there won’t be enough slack to disengage the brakes.

Part 2 of 4: Testing the deceleration brakes

foot pressing down brake pedal

Step 1: Park your car in an empty parking lot. Start the engine and press on the brake pedal until you feel resistance - this resistance is the brakes being pressed against your rotor or drum.

The pedal should not travel more than a quarter of the total distance to the floor before you feel the brakes engaging.

If you have to press fairly far, or the pedal feels spongy, there is likely air in your brake lines. The most common fix for this issue is bleeding the brakes. This will remove the air from the lines so the brake fluid can transfer the power to the brakes successfully.

Step 2: Press and hold your foot on the brake pedal. Use firm and steady pressure. You want to make sure the pedal doesn’t start sinking to the floor as you’re holding it.

A sinking pedal usually means that the main seal in your master cylinder is failing and allowing fluid to leak around it. It could also mean there is a leak somewhere and every time you press on the pedal, you are pushing fluid out. This is a serious issue and should be fixed as soon as possible.

Step 3: Pump the pedal quickly a few times. Note what position the pedal returns to.

If it is higher than before, this is another indication of air trapped in the lines. As you pump the pedal, the air causes the fluid to heat up slightly and expand.

Step 4: Put car in drive or first gear. Get the car moving and let it coast with your foot off of the gas pedal.

With the windows down, listen for scraping sounds while the car is moving.

A scraping sound while moving - without the brake pedal pressed down - usually indicates the brake pads are not returning to the rest position, but are constantly rubbing against the rotor or drum.

  • Tip: Having a friend outside the car listening can help identify where the sound is coming from. It can be hard to determine the direction while you are in the vehicle.

Step 5: Press lightly on the brake pedal to engage the brakes. Don’t stop the car immediately: let it come to a slow stop.

Keep listening for odd sounds while the brakes are engaged.

Step 6: Test at a higher speed: If the parking lot is big enough, accelerate a little faster and press on the brakes harder, still keeping an ear out for any abnormal sounds.

Also see if the steering wheel starts to pull in one direction or the other. This indicates the brakes are working better on one side of the car than the other. The difference in wheel speed causes the car to start changing direction.

Part 3 of 4: Visually inspect the disc brakes

Materials Needed

  • Breaker bar
  • Floor jack
  • Jack stands
  • Socket for lug nuts
  • Torque wrench

  • Note: The most common lug nut sizes are 19 and 21mm for metric, and ¾” or 13/16” for older domestic vehicles.

Step 1: Lift the car up. Use your jack to lift the car and place jack stands underneath so the car doesn’t fall while you are inspecting it.

person holding wheel at the top and bottom

Step 2: Grab one wheel at the top and bottom. Rock it back and forth to see if there is any movement.

Note: While this doesn’t test the brakes, a worn-out wheel bearing can cause similar issues to malfunctioning brakes.

Step 3: Spin the wheel by hand. Listen for any scraping and feel for any resistance while the wheel spins.

Step 4: Step on the brakes while the wheel spins. The wheel should stop pretty much immediately. If it doesn’t, there may not be enough pressure getting to the caliper to fully engage the brake.

  • Tip: Have a friend step on the brakes while you watch the wheel.

remove the wheel

Step 5: Remove the wheel to expose the rotor and caliper. Now you can look at the caliper, pads, and rotor.

  • Note: You may have to lower the car back to the ground to loosen the lug nuts.

close up of smooth and shiny rotor

Step 6: Inspect the rotor. The rotor should be smooth and shiny with a uniform silver color. Look for uneven, grainy texture or discoloration.

An uneven, grainy surface indicates abnormal wear; the rotor needs to be replaced if this is found.

Blue or purple spots indicate that the metal has gotten too hot from braking too hard - this can cause multiple issues. When the metal gets that hot, it becomes tempered and gets harder, while the metal around this spot will be softer and will wear out more quickly. Soon there will be a bulge in the rotor - which causes a nasty grinding sound.

Overheating can also cause the rotor to warp, which will create a pulsating feeling in the brake pedal when trying to slow the car down. Warping can also occur from letting the rotor get too thin.

As the rotor gets worn down, a sharp lip on the edge usually starts to appear from the metal getting cut away. Turning the rotors will get rid of this lip, show you how much metal is left on the rotor.

  • Note: Whenever you replace your brake pads, you should get the rotors turned if you are not replacing them.

hands holding new brake pads

Step 7: Inspect the brake pads. Check the wear indicator on the pad, typically a small slit in the brake material.

If there is no slit visible, then the pads need to be replaced as the material is too thin.

Check the inside and outside pads to make sure they are wearing evenly. If they aren’t wearing equally, the caliper isn’t able to apply the same pressure to both sides of the rotor - so only one pad is fully engaging.

Make sure there is no oil or grease on the pad material itself. It’s okay for some grease to be on the backing of the pad where it rides against the caliper, but the rotor and pad itself should be completely dry.

arrows indicating brake lines, looking for leaks

Step 8: Inspect for leaks. Look all around the back, front, and sides of the caliper for any indications of leaking fluid.

Check the brake line for tears or rips, and where the line goes into the caliper. Also check the bleeder screw for dried liquid as these can develop leaks over time.

master fluid reservoir

Step 9: Inspect the master cylinder. Make sure the fluid level is okay. Check the lines coming out of the master cylinder for any indications of leaks.

  • Note: It is normal for the fluid level to not be at the max. As the brake pads wear down, more fluid gets drawn into the lines, lowering the overall level in the master cylinder. As long as the fluid is above the minimum, you should not add more fluid. If it is below the minimum, there is a leak somewhere that needs to be found and remedied.

Part 4 of 4: Visually inspect the drum brakes

wheel off and drum exposed

Step 1: Follow Step 1 through Step 5 in the previous section. If you haven’t already, follow the above steps to test the wheel bearing and brakes to rule out other causes. Then remove the wheel so you can look at the drum.

drum removed and showing inner components

Step 2: Remove the brake drum. All the components are hidden inside the drum - you’ll need to take it off to inspect the shoes.

There may be a screw on the front of the drum that needs to be undone before the drum slides off.

If the drum doesn’t come off readily, it may have rusted to the wheel hub on the inside surface. Tap the drum lightly with a hammer to loosen the rust. Be sure not to damage the wheel studs.

  • Note: If the drum still isn’t coming off after loosening any rust, then the pads most likely have worn into the drum surface and created a lip. This will prevent you from moving the drum over the brake shoes, and you may need to enlist the help of a certified mechanic to help you remove and replace the brake drum.

arrow pointingt brake shoes

Step 3: Inspect the brake shoes. The shoes should be smooth with a dull appearance. A shiny or “glazed” look means the material has gotten too hot and isn’t as effective.

Move the brake shoes back and forth; they shouldn’t move very much.

Also look for cracks in the material and make sure both pads are wearing down evenly. Similar to disc brakes, it is possible for the brakes to apply uneven pressure to the pads, causing only one to wear down.

inside of brake drum

Step 4: Inspect the inside of the brake drum. Like a rotor, the inside surface that the shoes rub against should be shiny and smooth. Look for grainy, uneven surfaces and discoloration.

springs and linkages inside of drum brakes

Step 5: Inspect the springs and linkages of the brakes. Drum brakes have more linkages and connections on the inside compared to discs. Nothing should be loose.

All the springs should be connected at both ends. Give them a light tug to make sure they are not loose.

close up of wheel cylinder

Step 6: Inspect the wheel cylinder. The large cylinder at the top is what contains the hydraulic piston that pushes the shoes out against the drum.

When the internal seals begin to fail, liquid will leak from the rubber seals on the sides. Make sure there is no indication of leaking fluid around this area.

anchor pin

Step 7: Make sure both shoes are in contact with the anchor pin. Right above the wheel cylinder is the anchor pin. The indents at the top of the brake shoes should be around the pin, and the springs should be hooked on as well.

finger pointing at self adjuster

Step 8: Inspect the self adjuster. At the bottom of the brake shoes is the star wheel self adjuster. Make sure it is seated properly against both shoes.

There should be a metal lever with one end inside the star wheel. When you step on the brakes, this lever pushes up against the star wheel and will begin to rotate it.

Over time, as the brake material gets thinner, the lever will push the wheel more - which in turn unscrews the adjuster and widens the gap between the shoes. This keeps the distance between the brake material and the inner lining of the shoe constant so you don’t have to push further on the brake pedal.

brake lines on backside

Step 9: Inspect the brake lines for leaks. Drum brakes will have similar lines to disc brakes. Inspect them for cracks and leaks, as well as inspecting the bleeder screw on the back side of the brake.

Step 10: Inspect the master cylinder. Make sure the fluid level is okay. Check the lines coming out of the master cylinder for any indications of leaks.

  • Note: It is normal for the fluid level to not be at the max. As the brake pads wear down, more fluid gets drawn into the lines, lowering the overall level in the master cylinder. As long as the fluid is above the minimum, you should not add more fluid. If it is below the minimum, there is a leak somewhere that needs to be found and remedied.

With these methods of checking your brakes, you’ll be able to inspect most of the components of the braking system. Keep in mind that small squeaks can be caused by metal rubbing, even if the pads and rotors are still in good shape - so if you can’t find the source of the sound, you may just need to get the brakes lubricated. Our certified technicians here at YourMechanic are always available to assist you in diagnosing any brake issues you might encounter if you need extra help.


Next Step

Schedule Oil Change

The most popular service booked by readers of this article is Oil Change. YourMechanic’s technicians bring the dealership to you by performing this job at your home or office 7-days a week between 7AM-9PM. We currently cover over 2,000 cities and have 100k+ 5-star reviews... LEARN MORE

SEE PRICING & SCHEDULING

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Recent Oil Change reviews

Excellent Rating

(21,699)

Rating Summary
20,382
845
179
87
206
20,382
845
179
87
206

Matthew

33 years of experience
991 reviews
Matthew
33 years of experience
Volkswagen Passat - Oil Change - Hampton, Virginia
Matt always does a great job. Very professional. I look forward to my next appointment.... A++++++
Ford Expedition - Oil Change - Hampton, Virginia
I am so please to have Matt work on my vehicle, he is very friendly and personable, and always does a great job.

Greg

22 years of experience
37 reviews
Greg
22 years of experience
Audi A3 - Oil Change - Queen Creek, Arizona
Job well done! Greg was on time and professional. He treated my vehicle with care. He completed the job smoothly and so far so good. First time using Your mechanic and it was a pleasant experience. I will be looking into them again. Thanks Greg!
Ford Explorer - Oil Change - Scottsdale, Arizona
Greg was very friendly and professional. Communication was great, he let me know what he was doing. He went above and beyond to make sure everything was running smoothly. I would 100% recommend Greg!

LAVELL

27 years of experience
93 reviews
LAVELL
27 years of experience
Buick Encore - Oil Change - Oakland, California
Another home run! Really appreciate the flexibility regarding my service appointment. Due to my work schedule I desperately needed a late appointment. So grateful my car is receiving top shelf professional service. Replaced a oil pan drain plug that was seriously damaged and stripped by a competitor that will NEVER get my business again! All services were quickly completed. Thank you so much for another great experience with my.... Your Mechanic Lavell 5 ⭐️ Service consistently.

Brian

23 years of experience
483 reviews
Brian
23 years of experience
Porsche 911 - Oil Change - Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida
Brian is extremely knowledgeable and very personable and has taken very good care on my 911. I would recommend Brian to any one who has mechanical car challenges. I would recommend Brian to all My friends and family

Need Help With Your Car?

Our certified mobile mechanics make house calls in over 2,000 U.S. cities. Fast, free online quotes for your car repair.

GET A QUOTE

Related articles

What’s the Difference Between Drilled and Slotted Brakes?
Brake Brake rotors are a fundamental part of a vehicle’s braking system. They’re a simple system, but made up of many different parts. The driver applies the brakes by pressing on the brake pedal, which signals the rest of the...
Can a Leak in the Brake System Cause Total Brake Failure?
Although Although there are several issues that can lead to total brake failure, the most common one is some form of brake fluid leak. When a brake leak is present, it affects the fluid pressure in your system. Since it...
How to Replace a Car Combination Valve
The combination valve balances your brake system. If broken, it should be replaced to ensure a safe driving experience.

Related questions

Advice on buying a 4-wheel drive vehicle with minor and major repairs

Minor are the stuff like brakes, water pump leaking, radiator caps with holes in them - stuff that doesn't cost that much to fix and what you can easily do by yourself. But, if the transmission or the engine have...

Why would my brake light come on in my 2011 Mini Cooper Clubman

Hello. The cost to repair this would depend on what the issue is. If the brake light came on most of the time that is because the brake fluid is low. It usually gets low due to low brake pads....

Brakes unresponsive only one time

Inoperative brakes are a definite safety concern. If it happened once, it will happen again. Unfortunately, if the vehicle isn't currently acting up, it may be difficult to diagnose. The mechanic is correct that the most likely cause of your...

How can we help?

Our service team is available 7 days a week, Monday - Friday from 6 AM to 5 PM PST, Saturday - Sunday 7 AM - 4 PM PST.

1 (855) 347-2779 · hi@yourmechanic.com