Q: What Advantages Are There of Rebuilding an Engine Rather Than Replacing It?

asked by on December 02, 2015

What advantages are there for rebuilding an engine rather than replacing it?

When you are looking at the question of whether you should rebuild or replace a motor, you will first have to assume the original motor is rebuildable. If you do not know if your engine is rebuildable then the engine would need to be taken apart and inspected piece-by-piece to determine the parts that can be reused and parts that have to be replaced. To determine what advantages you will have by rebuilding your own motor or replacing your motor, you need to make a list of what you want to do. For instance, you can have your engine block cylinders enlarged and larger pistons put in so you can increase the engine’s cubic inches size. This will increase the horsepower. You can also replace the camshafts, cylinder heads, and intake manifold with high performance parts. This can have a drastic change to your engine power output. When you decide to increase the engine performance by using performance parts in the engine you will need to keep in mind that the fuel injectors, fuel system, cooling system, or other systems may need modifications to work with the performance improvements of the engine. Before you decide to rebuild your engine, you need to look at total cost versus benefit of the rebuild. You should know what you are putting in the engine and control every part and process to rebuild it.

A replacement engine you get will be most likely a remanufactured engine. Different rebuilders do different rebuilds and you only have control over who you purchase the engine from and not how they rebuild it or what parts are used. Some rebuilders may offer performance packages of different ranges. You may have some rebuilders that offer custom rebuilds that you can purchase or they may need your motor to do a rebuild for you if there are no engines in stock.

The bottom line is you can buy a crate motor with no control of what went into the rebuild, or rebuild your motor and control what goes into the motor. The quality of the parts and performance improvement parts can be controlled in your own rebuild.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Engine revving when I pump the gas

There are a multiple list of components which can cause your issue. Your vehicle is particularly known to have throttle body issues and engine vacuum leaks. A diagnostic needs to be performed with special tools to correctly determine the issue....

Multiple car problems

Hello. It sounds like you have a bit of a complex issue going on. The Aveo has a problem with the ignition switch that can cause strange issues like the ones you have described. That would be where I would...

Cost of an engine swap.

Replacing an engine does require some extensive work that can take some time. The cost will vary by shop as each shop has a different labor rate per hour. If you know what the labor rate of a shop is...

What Is the Difference Between a Water-Cooled Engine and an Air-Cooled Engine?

There are a few main differences between a water-cooled and air-cooled engine. Air-cooled engines utilize an engine cylinder design that incorporates cooling fins all the way around the cylinder and on top of the piston cylinder head. These fins draw...

Check Engine light on. Would the computer give all error codes in one shot? How do we know the engine's condition?

Hi there. From the description you have provided, I'm am inclined to agree with your assessment of a used engine being installed in your vehicle. An inspection of the engine, by a qualified technician could determine whether the engine is...

engine noise after starting

This may be an indication that the starter drive is not disengaging from the flywheel after the engine starts. The danger in this is that the starter drive may fly apart and damage the flywheel or engine aside from destroying...

Does this vehicle have an interference engine??

This engine is an interference motor that most likely bent valves when the timing belt broke. An issue like this calls for major engine repair. Whether you decide to fix the engine or get a new car, be sure to...

Turns over won't start. 2000 Chevy Metro

Hello. Sometimes there are torque specs that are required for tightening the rod bearings. If they are too tight or too loose, it could prevent the car from starting. I would check a Chilton Manual for the proper specs for...

Engine Power Reduced TPS

Hi! Yes the throttle position sensor could very well be the cause. I highly doubt that it is the oxygen sensor though. When the throttle position sensor goes bad the engine will put itself into reduced power mode. I was...

Related articles

What Does "Twin-Cam" Mean?
Twin-cam engines use two camshafts to operate the intake and exhaust valves. DOHC engines often have better power and efficiency than SOHC engines.
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Exhaust Manifold Gasket
If the engine is noisy, causing performance issues, or smells burnt, you may need to replace the exhaust manifold gasket.
How to Buy a Good Quality Engine Mount
Engine Engine mounts, also called motor mounts, are crucial to your vehicle’s proper functioning; providing a strong grip upon the engine is part of what makes the vehicle function as the damage that would certainly disable the engine if the...