Q: Do you suggest me getting a third opinion from another mechanic?

asked by on February 15, 2017

The first mechanic I took it to gave me a full inspect and told me that I would need Control Arms (Upper-Front), CV Axles (Front), all 3 Drive Belts are cracked, Brake Pads and Rotors (Front) and Tie Rod Ends (Left-Inner). He told me I should hear a clicking sound whenever I turn, but I haven't heard any of that yet. I do, however, hear a lot of squeaking noises when I hit any bumps or grooves in the road. I've experienced a burning smell as I drive (assuming it's the belts) and it takes my car some time to stop if I'm hard on the brakes. My second mechanic told me that I needed to fix the CV Boots, my Muffler isn't supported, Engine Air Filter, Drive Belts, a cracked Heat Shield, a cracked Driver Steering Rack Boot, a cracked Right Rear Brake Drum, a broken Radiator Top Support, a slow leak in the Wiper Fluid Resivour, my Parking Brake Cable and Fuel Tank Cap Gasket. Should I fix everything from both mechanics' lists? And if so, then what can wait and was needs immediate work?

My car has 245962 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

The odor of something "burning" should be investigated and completely resolved first before any other repairs are attempted. The odor might not be due to the belts and a possibility is oil leaking onto the manifold. Such would be a health and fire hazard and if that is the case, that has to be repaired first. Once the burning odor is completely resolved (and if not resolved, it’s pointless to proceed), the order of priority for repairs is: 1) repair exhaust system (if exhaust is leaking by the way, as with burning odors, it is pointless to repair other items until you have a 100% functional exhaust system); 2) brake drum; 3) brake pads and rotors; 4) Drive belts; 5) Parking brake cable; 6) Tie Rod Ends (Left-Inner); 7) Engine Air Filter; 8) Radiator Support; 9) CV Boots and Steering Rack Boot; 10) Control Arms (Upper-Front); 11) Cracked Heat Shield; 12) Fuel Tank Cap Gasket; and 13) Wiper Fluid Reservoir. All of these repairs can be done economically for you on a mobile basis saving you lots of money. To request mobile service, right to your door, performed by a certified mechanic, please call YourMechanic at Tel: 844-249-6752 or use the web inquiry form to request service. If you have further questions or concerns, do not hesitate to re-contact YourMechanic as we are always here to help you.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Fuel tank leak
Fuel tanks can not be repaired. If one is found to be leaking or damaged it should be replaced before continuing to drive the vehicle. A proper gas tank inspection (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/fuel-is-leaking-from-gas-tank-inspection) should be performed to ensure no other damage has...
Truck leaking power steering fluid
The source of the leak will need to be determined. The pump itself, the hoses, or the rack and pinion are all suspect. Once repaired and fluid is added, the wheel should be easy to turn. If you would like...
Blown head gasket
A blown head gasket is in most cases the final leg for an engine. This causes damage and allows fluids to mix which means other systems may have to be flushed as well. Many head gasket repair costs come close...
Codes P0420 and P0171 appearing
When it relates to the air conditioning system, the dealership does not have an advantage when it comes to hybrid air conditioning systems. These air conditioning systems require special evacuation machines that are different from that of a normal air...
ticking noise comimg from underneath ticks in all gears but 4th and only when clutch is out
If everything else looks good, there is one other thing that can create such a sound. Of course this forum is not replacement for a technician being present to diagnose the problem. What you need to check for next is...
Car Overheating 2004 honda accord
If your vehicle has overheated it is very possible that head gasket or head damage has occurred. I would recommend having the engine thoroughly inspected as well as pressure tested to determine if any coolant leaks exist. I would also...
My car sputters and dies - 2000 Ford Contour
Hi there. From the description you have provided, it leads me to believe there is a charging system problem. Apparently, the battery is being run down while driving (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/battery-is-dead-inspection). A good battery will recover on its own when it sits...
My car keeps stalling. What causes this?
This may be related to a dirty or failing idle air control valve. The idle air control valve reads the air intake as it is mixed with fuel prior to being injected into the engine at low speeds and at...
Cranks but won't start.
Hi there. It seems that the transmission position sensor / switch has a contact issue within it. Remove the harness from the transmission switch and see if there is any moisture on the plug. If there is moisture, then you...

Related articles

How to Buy Good Quality Brake Rotors
Also Also known as brake discs, rotors are the component of your braking system that get squeezed between the calipers/pads in order to stop the wheels from turning. Think of a big metal donut being squished between your thumb and...
How to Know What Kind of Hoist to Buy
When When it comes to vehicle repairs, maintenance, and storage, there is a segment of the population that takes it very seriously. Professional-grade tools, large home garages or shops, and even vehicle hoists are part of their repertoire for completing...
Top 10 Best-Selling Cars of 2016
Ford F-series pickup trucks, Toyota Camry, and Honda Civic are some of the best-selling cars of 2016 and all deliver on reliability and efficiency.