Q: Car keeps cranking over when not holding key, but still wont start

asked by on October 13, 2016

My cars rpm keeps going up and down, while it is chugging and getting ready to die. I put car in neutral and press on gas to keep it running. When I. Shut car off and try to restart the car cranks and will not release, it keeps cranking even when I let go of key. When it stops the car still will not start. Took to dealer and they don't know what's wrong with it since it didn't do that to them, it started for them. This car has left me stranded 4x already. I just don't know what it is or what to have fixed

My car has 73000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Starter Replacement $169.22 - $1153.49 Get a Quote
Car starts and then dies Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

It sounds like you have 2 problems here, the starter and an engine stalling problem. The starter problem is probably the starter solenoid, a power switch (integrated into the starter assembly) that takes a small current from the ignition switch and engages a large current at the starter. The contacts in the solenoid can burn over time, "sticking", which can cause the starter "run-on" like you described, and a "no crank" condition, because the same burned contacts don’t pass heavy current very well. The poor idling may be due to a dirty idle air control valve, dirty throttle body, or air leak in the intake system of the engine. I would recommend having YourMechanic dispatch a mobile, professional mechanic to your location to do a (Starter Replacement)[https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/starter-replacement] and car starting trouble inspection.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Lots of rust on a newish car, what happened?
Unfortunately, there is no stop to rust. It happens to all cars that are regularly exposed to the elements, but some parts of the country are worse than others. But don’t worry, Nissan is aware of the issue and has...
What is the Cruise Main indicator light on the dash?
Cruise control is a valuable asset. It allows you to set the speed you want to travel and then take your foot off the gas. That can help alleviate fatigue and tension on long drives. The Cruise Main indicator light...
Timing chain replacement on a 1999 Chevrolet Lumina
Don't waste your time this early. Timing chains are made of metal. If it's a rubber timing chain, then yes, you may want to change it. But the metal timing chain isn't worth it if it's only at 68,000 miles....
Cooling fan will not turn off
The cooling fans are controlled On and Off by the engine ECM. The ECM commands the cooling fan relay module box (on left front of engine compartment) to turn on the fans when needed. If the fans are on all...
Transmission replaced, but still slipping - 2009 Kia Borrego
There's a lot going on here. As far as the transmission concerns, your repair should be under warranty since you had the work done at the dealer. For the rest of the concerns, you may want to hire another technician...
The Check Engine Light is on
Hi there. There are a lot of things that can cause the Check Engine Light to be illuminated. A flashing check engine light is a sign of serious trouble. If the light is not flashing, then I would use a...
How do I fill the cooling system in my 1994 C220 Mercedes
To properly fill your cooling system, you need to start with the engine cold. With the engine off, fill the radiator slowly until the level is about 1"below the neck. Leave the cap off and with the car in park...
AC Compressor
It sounds like you may have a faulty AC Compressor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/ac-compressor-replacement) or potentially a leak in the AC lines somewhere. Car air conditioners work on a simple principle of heat transfer, relying on the fact that heat will always transfer...
Ford Fiesta TDCi starts and stall immediately
If the engine overheated, there is the possibility of engine damage (stuck valves, etc.) so it might be necessary to test for basic cylinder compression. If the engine is mechanically sound, what you are describing is diagnosed in a stalling...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're a Dog Trainer
If If you are a dog trainer, you expect a lot from your vehicle. You want a ride that is safe, roomy, and of course, dog friendly, since your training operation will often mean that you need to transport the...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If Your Kid's On the Soccer Team
If If you are a soccer mom (or dad), you know that you need a lot of space to transport your budding World Cup contenders, along with their gear. From time to time, you can also expect to be bringing...
The Top 5 Selling Cars in Alaska in 2012
Alaska Alaska requires a different kind of vehicle to handle both the terrain and the wintery conditions. While some of the most popular options for the Alaskan terrain in previous years included options such as the Subaru Forester and the...