How to Know When It's Time to Buy a New Car

happy couple driving in car

Changing vehicles is a big decision, and it’s not something you do every day. Chances are, you have developed an intimate connection with your current car. After all, it takes you to and from work or around town to keep up with errands or social engagements. You and your car have a lot of time invested together, so deciding if it’s time to replace that car can be a difficult time. Whether you are considering a replacement due to potentially expensive repair costs to your current vehicle or as a change of pace, take time to review your options carefully before making any long-term commitments.

Method 1 of 2: Deciding between replacing or repairing your car

Step 1: Get an assessment for the cost of repairs. You can’t make a rational decision on whether it’s in your financial best interest to keep your current car and fix it or find an entirely new vehicle unless you know how much it will cost you to repair it.

You will also want to have your current car checked for any other repairs that may be needed in the near future.

KBB ford escape value
Image: Kelley Blue Book

Step 2: Determine the value of your car with and without repairs. You can get an idea of how much your current car is worth in both its present condition and if you decide to get it fixed by using the wizards available on the Kelly Blue Book or NADA websites.

auto calculator
Image: Bankrate

Step 3: Determine replacement cost. Price how much your potential replacement car will cost, taking into account making payments if you cannot purchase it outright.

Assess your finances to see if you can handle a monthly car payment. Use an online calculator to find out how much.

Step 4: Make the choice. Make the executive decision on whether to keep or replace your car once you are well-informed of the associated costs of both options.

Unfortunately, there is no set formula because there is a wide array of variables at play. It is wise, however, to opt for replacing your car if the repairs will cost more than its worth in good condition. Otherwise, you will need to weigh the benefits and drawbacks of your unique situation.

Method 2 of 2: Deciding whether to replace or keep a car

Step 1: Consider why you may want a new car. While you may want a sports car capable of going 200+ mph with tons of luxurious extras, it may not fall under the category of necessity.

On the other hand, you may have received a big promotion at work and have an image to uphold. These are situations that go beyond the black and white of mathematical equations and are dependent on subjective factors.

Step 2: Determine cost of desired replacement. Research how much your desired replacement car will cost, taking into account if you will have to make payments and what interest rate you can likely lock in.

Step 3: Assess your finances honestly. While you may be able to make the payment on your desired replacement car today and in the near future, financial situations can change in the blink of an eye due to unforeseen factors like illness or job loss.

  • Tip: If paying for a new car will be a financial burden, it may be in your best interest to wait.

Step 4: Make a list of pros and cons to aid you in your decision. If your current car is in good condition and you own it in full, you can save quite a bit of money by driving it as long as you can.

  • Tip: This savings can go toward the down payment on a new car down the road or toward larger purchases, such as a house.

With a secure financial situation, this may not carry as much weight in your decision-making process. Regardless of which avenue you ultimately pursue, your judgement will be more sound when you understand the pros and cons of each option fully.

Knowing how to make a smart choice about when it’s time to replace a vehicle is a situation you will be faced with more than once in life. So, be as informed as possible before you decide, and learn from the experience for future decisions.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Ask a Mechanic
(100% Free)

Have a car question? Get free advice from our top-rated mechanics.

Ask A Mechanic
Over 10,000 questions answered!

More related articles

The Traveler’s Guide to Driving in Malaysia
CraigBurrows / Shutterstock.com Malaysia is a popular destination for many tourists today. The country has amazing sights and attractions that you will want to explore....
P2422 OBD-II Trouble Code: Evaporative Emissions Control System (EVAP) Vent Valve Stuck Closed
Diagnostic Trouble Code (DTC): P2422 P2422 code definition Evaporative Emissions Control System (EVAP) Vent Valve Stuck Closed Related Trouble Codes: P2441: EVAP Vent Valve Stuck Open EVAP trouble...
What are the Car Pool Rules in Hawaii?
Hawaii is widely regarded as a land of vacation and relaxation, and as such, its scenic roads and routes are far better known than the state’s freeways. But, as with all...

Related questions

Q: Is a 14' to 15' Altima 3.5 SL worth buying?

With the proper care and maintenance, many of the vehicles today meet and exceed mileage old car makers could only dream of. The key is the proper maintenance and not to abuse the vehicles drivetrain. Consider having a pre-purchase inspection...

Q: Recommendation on choosing an SUV to buy--Honda CR-V or RAV 4

Yes, but a Rav 4 without a doubt would outlast it by far. I'd buy the Rav 4. They are going to last longer. Hondas used to be really solidly built, but they've gone downhill in the last decade, decade-and-a-half....

Q: I'm car shopping

Hey there, that is pretty low mileage for a 10 year old car. To be safe, I would suggest scheduling a pre-purchase inspection on the car before making a final purchase. This way, you can have a local expert give...