Q: I can not shift unless my car is off.

asked by on November 30, 2016

When I go to put my car into 1st gear it won't budge. It will stay in neutral. If the car is off I can shift

My car has 74000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Not able to change gears Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Hi there. If the transmission will not shift with the engine running but it will shift with the engine off, then there is a problem with the clutch. Either the clutch is worn and will not disengage, or the clutch slave cylinder is not working properly. Check the slave cylinder and see if its moving properly. If the slave cylinder is moving and making the clutch fork move all the way, then the clutch needs replaced. If you need further assistance with your shifter not working properly, then seek out a professional, such as one from Your Mechanic, to help you.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Car has been sitting
Hello. If you have leaks, it is best to determine what fluids are leaking. Engine coolant usually has a green or orange color, depending on the type of coolant used. It is usually sweet-smelling, if it is relatively clean. Engine...
No rear lights
Hello. Depending on how they wired the trailer lights up, the wiring harness might need to be replaced. Some trailer lighting comes as an inline harness that plugs into the existing vehicle's wiring. This is the normally the best way...
While highway driving, rear tire blew out
The rubber tires on any vehicle can experience a blowout under a number of conditions. If the tire is low on air pressure, the added grip causes more friction, heat, and wear. If a tire has an unseen injury, a...
Rear pinion seal leaking. Would i also need to change the flange?
The flange is integral with a splined yoke. The yoke segment (of the flange/yoke) has a precision, machined, highly polished surface which mates with the rubber seal (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/pinion-seal-replacement). Since the rubber seal is spring loaded and is under tension against...
Engine misfires and hesitates while accelerating
If the issues only began to occur after the vehicle was fitted with a new MAF and different intake, then it may be possible that the issue is related to the recent work. The mass airflow sensor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/mass-airflow-sensor-replacement) is one...
Rattling noise when the AC comes on
Hey there. There are some obvious possibilities: the fan or blower noise due to motor defect; the A/C clutch is chattering or slipping, and/or the clutch bearing is worn, loose, or wobbly; the compressor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/ac-compressor-replacement) has an internal mechanical fault...
Tapping on acceleration Honda hybrid.
Hi there. The noise could be from the lifters not filling up with engine oil until the engine is warm or the pistons have too much clearance causing a condition called "piston slap". Check to see what brand of engine...
When I turn overdrive on my 2002 focus it makes a sound when I put my foot on the gas like its overworking itself.
Your transmission may be having a fault that is disabling the overdrive. If the computer is detecting a fault in the system it will do this or if the transmission is slipping or has internal problems will also do this....
96 mustang automatic will go in reverse but not drive the rear seal was replaced what could be wrong
Sometimes it seems like doing repairs on older cars is like opening Pandora's box. Failure of the transmission shouldn't have anything to do with replacement of the rear seal, but it seems it has. It could be that simply draining...

Related articles

How Often Do I Need to Replace the Transmission Fluid?
The basic definition of a transmission is the part of a vehicle that transfers the power from the engine to the wheels. How...
What is Transmission Fluid and What Does it Do?
Transmission fluid is used to lubricate the components of a car’s transmission for optimum performance. In vehicles with automatic transmissions,...
How to Do a Burnout in a Manual Vehicle
Almost Almost everyone who has seen an action movie or watched a high-speed car chase, has seen someone perform a burnout before taking off. A burnout occurs when the power going to the car’s wheels makes them lose traction with...