What it Really Costs to Maintain a Standard Car vs Luxury Car

If you’re ready to move on from your used Toyota Camry, chances are high you’ve looked at more premium offerings as a replacement. It’s a natural urge to desire a luxury vehicle after spending years commuting in a run-of-the-mill yet reliable sedan, but you shouldn’t simply jump ship without doing your due diligence.

Not only will maintenance costs increase, operating expenditures will affect your wallet as well. To better help you transition from losing your car in a parking lot, to ogling it after every trip, here are three scenarios detailing the switch from a regular car to a luxury model and the associated costs with each, including oil changes, replacement spark plugs, and other routine operating costs.

Toyota Camry to Lexus GS350

The Camry is loved by many for its dependability, longevity, and low operational cost – making it best-selling passenger car in the U.S. While this is great for current and prospective owners, it’s a bit disappointing for drivers wanting a little more exclusivity in their drive.

A natural progression up from the Camry is to another Toyota-built four-door, the Lexus GS350. This premium offering comes with top-tier build quality and rear-wheel drive performance, but the question is: it as efficient to run as the Camry?

According to our estimator tool, the price gap between the two for yearly routine maintenance isn’t that drastic – an approximate $28 difference. This is attributed to the way Toyota manufactures their parts as largely interchangeable. You should be aware of the Lexus’ thirst for premium fuel and increased cost for low profile tires, but other than that, you should be able to find it in your budget to treat yourself to a reliable, luxury offering.

Maintenance camry v GS350

Honda Accord to Acura TL

If you’re tired of the fact that your Honda Accord is too common, it may be time to upgrade to a more exclusive yet familiar offering: the Acura TL. Derived from the Accord’s chassis, the TL – especially in third generation flavor (2004-2008) is arguably one of the best front wheel drive offerings available to date and can even be had with a six speed manual transmission.

Even so, the TL is more expensive to operate than its more plebeian cousin. Our data indicates annual maintenance costs for the Acura are $324 – nearly one hundred dollars more than the Accord. Big ticket items tend to happen when the TL is eight-years-old as timing belt replacements at the dealership that be costly. You can cut down that price by working with the experienced mobile mechanics who will come to you and perform the replacement in your driveway, so bear that in mind.

Depending on the trim level and model year of your Accord as well, making the switch to the more premium Acura may not be that drastic of a change in terms of operational costs as the Accord progressed closer to the TL in terms of features and performance throughout the model years.

Maintenance Accord v TL

Nissan Altima to Infiniti M56

Tired of your four cylinder four door? Why not make the jump to a 420 horsepower, 5.6 liter V8 super sedan? While you may think Infiniti’s heavy-hitter flagship from the past five years may be too out of reach, used prices are less and average maintenance costs are only $83 a year more than the Altima. What you’ll need to be aware of, however, is the consistency of repairs needed to maintain the V8 Infiniti, so expect a higher frequency of mechanic visits.

Another point to consider is fuel costs. A 2.5 liter 2013 Nissan Altima can average 31 mpg mixed on regular grade fuel. With average gas prices at $2.37, a 15,000 mile a year commute would cost approximately $1,112. With the Infiniti and its 19 mpg mixed average and premium fuel needs, yearly gas expenditures nearly double compared to the Altima.

Maintenance Altima v M56

When deciding to go from standard to luxury, it’s important to weigh your needs with your wants. If your commute is long and mostly highway mileage, a jump to a premium sedan might not be that significant and could very well improve your mood and enrich your quality of life. If you spend the majority of your driving hours in city traffic, however, you might want to give a more fuel efficient, average sedan consideration and remember when you begin to tick boxes on an options list, an Accord can be outfitted to compete directly with its luxury counterparts.

Ask a Mechanic for expert advice on making the switch - they have real world, hands-on experience with all makes and models and can give you a realistic rundown of repair, maintenance, and operational costs.


Next Step

Schedule Timing Belt Replacement

The most popular service booked by readers of this article is Timing Belt Replacement. YourMechanic’s technicians bring the dealership to you by performing this job at your home or office 7-days a week between 7AM-9PM. We currently cover over 2,000 cities and have 100k+ 5-star reviews... LEARN MORE

SEE PRICING & SCHEDULING

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Recent Timing Belt Replacement reviews

Excellent Rating

(1,312)

Rating Summary
1,230
44
7
6
25
1,230
44
7
6
25

Chris

22 years of experience
2223 reviews
Chris
22 years of experience
Toyota 4Runner V6-3.4L - Timing Belt - Anaheim, California
Chriss was really great. I appreciated his knowledge of my vehicle. He shared maintenance tips. Oh and he did a really good job with a difficult ask. New timing belt, drive belt, Radiator. Thank you!
Honda Odyssey - Timing Belt - Murrieta, California
We always use Chris for our auto repairs when he is available. He is very reliable and does a good job.

William

34 years of experience
517 reviews
William
34 years of experience
Ford Ranger L4-2.3L - Timing Belt - Phoenix, Arizona
I was scammed out of 2300 dollars by another mobile mechanic who said I needed a new engine. William came out and replaced the timing belt and water pump. He explained everything to me and was honest when asked certain questions. I will use this service again because William is now my mechanic. Great service.
Honda Pilot - Timing Belt - Phoenix, Arizona
Awesome person, friendly and did a great job. Had my timing belt done with the pulleys, water pump and thermostat. Defenitly knowledgeable in his field of work and will be using him again in my future repairs.

James

30 years of experience
873 reviews
James
30 years of experience
Honda Pilot V6-3.5L - Timing Belt - Kissimmee, Florida
This was a great first experience with YourMechanic. James was professional and worked diligently to get the job done. Highly recommend and will be using him again. Thanks!
Chrysler Sebring - Timing Belt - Orlando, Florida
James kept in touch with me the day of the repairs. Hard-working guy! Stay and finished job till late evening. Timing belt, new water pump and valve cover. So far so good! Thank you James!!

Jermaine

24 years of experience
244 reviews
Jermaine
24 years of experience
Lexus GX470 V8-4.7L - Timing Belt - Clarksville, Maryland
Jermaine always does a great job. He has worked on three of my cars, and done efficient and flawless work. He's a great guy too.
Honda Ridgeline - Timing Belt - Rockville, Maryland
I want to thank Jermaine for the quick, professional service on my 06 Honda Ridgeline. Outstanding. I didn't know what to expect, but after he completed the work and was explaining what he inspected afterward, I was very pleased. He was very professional and was able to help diagnose another potential issue. This is the first time I used "yourmechanic.com" and from the estimate I received (both timeframe and money), compared to the auto shops around town, I couldn't believe what could be done outside my home. After this experience, I will be a returning customer.

Need Help With Your Car?

Our certified mobile mechanics make house calls in over 2,000 U.S. cities. Fast, free online quotes for your car repair.

GET A QUOTE

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're Over 50
Shopping Shopping for a car when you’re over the age of 50 begins to shift a bit, as your priorities tend to change. Suddenly it’s not so much about what the vehicle looks like, or how much space it has...
How to Buy a Good Quality Brake Master Cylinder
The The master cylinder acts as the brake fluid reservoir on your vehicle. It’s necessary that this part be in good repair in order for the brake system to work properly – that means seals intact, pistons functioning optimally, and...
How to Budget to Buy a New Car
Saving money for a new car or a used car (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-buying-a-new-or-a-used-vehicle) that’s new to you doesn’t have to be a source of stress. With the proper planning, you can simplify the process without making a huge financial sacrifice all at...

Related questions

Used car issues? 2002 BMW 323xi
Hello. The issues you describe are relatively minor and likely will not require extensive repairs. A gas cap that does not lock is probably bad and will likely need to be replaced. A replacement cap can be sourced easily and...
Should i buy this Acura RSX Type S with a idle control valve that need to be fix?
Hello. This is a very low price for an otherwise great car. I would recommend having an expert mechanic inspect the car (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/pre-purchase-car-inspection) prior to the purchase to check for other potential issues. Although, the two issues you have described...
Check Engine light on. Would the computer give all error codes in one shot? How do we know the engine's condition?
Hi there. From the description you have provided, I'm am inclined to agree with your assessment of a used engine being installed in your vehicle. An inspection of the engine, by a qualified technician could determine whether the engine is...

How can we help?

Our service team is available 7 days a week, Monday - Friday from 6 AM to 5 PM PST, Saturday - Sunday 7 AM - 4 PM PST.

1 (855) 347-2779 · hi@yourmechanic.com