10 Best Stores to Buy Auto Parts in New York, New York

Whether you’re in need of a new headlight bulb to replace the blown one in your car, or new floor mats to protect your car’s carpeting, you need a trusted part store. Finding the right one can be a challenge. Thankfully, we’ve created a list of the 10 best stores to buy auto parts in New York, New York so you can save time and sanity.

1. Advance Auto Parts

428 Grand St
Jersey City, NJ 07305
View in Google Maps
(201) 616-7549

Ranking: 5 Stars on Yelp

Customers state that this store is always well stocked and that the prices are lower than expected. The staff are also happy to help ensure the right part is purchased.

2. Steinway Auto Parts

2225 Steinway Street
Astoria, NY 11105
View in Google Maps
(718) 274-0306

Ranking: 5 Stars on Yelp

According to customers, this store offers some of the best prices in the city. The staff are also very helpful, and can ensure the right part is chosen. Inventory levels are also good.

3. Myrtle Discount Auto Parts

6925 Cooper Ave
Glendale, NY 11385
View in Google Maps
(718) 381-6300

Ranking: 5 Stars on Yelp

This store is ranked highly because it carries parts for current makes and models, older cars and vintage vehicles. Customers also state that the prices are very low, and appreciate that this is a locally owned and operated store.

4. Advance Auto Parts

77 Bloomfeld Ave
Bloomfield, NJ 07003
View in Google Maps
(973) 566-0158

Ranking: 5 Stars on Yelp

Customers state that this part store usually carries parts on hand even for older cars that are hard to find elsewhere. Prices are low, and customers also appreciate the knowledgeable staff.

5. Advance Auto Parts

6120 Fresh Pond Rd
Middle Village, NY 11379
View in Google Maps
(718) 366-5030

Ranking: 4.5 Stars on Yelp

Customers appreciate the fact that this store has later hours in the evening, as well as the low pricing on parts. Staff members are knowledgeable and able to help locate the right part from amongst multiple similar options.

6. Advance Auto Parts

2401 Kennedy Blvd
North Bergen, NJ 07047
View in Google Maps
(201) 866-8015

Ranking: 4.5 Stars on Yelp

Customers like that the staff are willing and able to answer questions about cars and auto parts, as well as the fact that this store usually has any needed part on hand, and that their prices are low.

7. Dave’s Auto Parts and Accessories

660 Newark St
Hoboken, NJ 07030
View in Google Maps
(201) 792-9721

Ranking: 4 Stars on Yelp

The staff at this shop are happy to provide guidance and advice on part replacement, and most parts are on hand at all times. However, customers do note that prices are sometimes slightly higher than at chain stores.

8. Advance Auto Parts

4802 Queens Blvd
Woodside, NY 11377
View in Google Maps
(718) 779-6232

Ranking: 3.5 Stars on Yelp

Customers cite competitive pricing, as well as high part availability, even on accessories like bumper covers and the like. The staff are also helpful and willing to provide guidance on part installation.

9. AutoZone

975 Atlantic Avenue
Brooklyn, NY 11238
View in Google Maps
(718) 789-9744

Ranking: 3 Stars on Yelp

Customers note that this store almost always has the part or parts they need. Prices are low and in line with other chain stores, and the staff are knowledgeable and willing to help locate the correct part.

10. AutoZone

464 Coney Island Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11218
View in Google Maps
(718) 435-6827

Ranking: 3 Stars on Yelp

Customers like that they can almost always find exactly what they need at this store. The staff are rated as being knowledgeable, and are capable of both looking up part numbers and locating items on the shelf.

If you’re already a certified mechanic and you’re interested in working with YourMechanic, submit an online application for an opportunity to become a mobile mechanic.


Next Step

Schedule Headlight Bulb Replacement

The most popular service booked by readers of this article is Headlight Bulb Replacement. YourMechanic’s technicians bring the dealership to you by performing this job at your home or office 7-days a week between 7AM-9PM. We currently cover over 2,000 cities and have 100k+ 5-star reviews... LEARN MORE

SEE PRICING & SCHEDULING

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Recent Headlight Bulb Replacement reviews

Excellent Rating

(1,172)

Rating Summary
1,106
40
10
3
13
1,106
40
10
3
13

Alexander

6 years of experience
108 reviews
Alexander
6 years of experience
Chrysler 300 - Headlight Bulb Replacement (Driver Side Low Beam, Driver Side High Beam) - Groveport, Ohio
It was pleasant and was well mannered. He was on time and finished the task at hand in a timely fashion.
Volkswagen Passat - Headlight Bulb Replacement (Driver Side Low Beam) - Columbus, Ohio
I was very impressed with Alexanders knowledge,competence, in the way in which he goes about doing his job. I would request him again.

Mostafa

19 years of experience
27 reviews
Mostafa
19 years of experience
Nissan Altima - Headlight Bulb Replacement (Driver Side Low Beam) - Atlanta, Georgia
Very helpful....went into detail about his entire process. Informative as well. Gave me a heads up on things to keep an eye on. He was sent with the wrong bulb to change my headlight....fortunately, there was already and extra one that he was able to use, and gladly did it. I feel better about being on the road now.

Colby

14 years of experience
14 reviews
Colby
14 years of experience
Acura TL - Headlight Bulb Replacement (Driver Side Low Beam, Passenger Side Low Beam) - Denver, Colorado
He did the job well and did it fast! Unfortunately couldn't complete one of the services, but it wasn't due to him it was due to the part we had. Still did a great job, wore a mask, was very courteous. I would use his services again!!

Mike

26 years of experience
51 reviews
Mike
26 years of experience
Chevrolet Traverse - Headlight Bulb Replacement (Passenger Side Low Beam) - New Boston, Michigan
BEST car repair service experience EVER!!!! Not only did Mike, a highly skilled 25yr experienced mechanic, replace my passenger headlight and rear wiper, he did all of this, along with a full car inspection and more, in my own driveway, without breaking my bank. I highly recommend Your Mechanic for any small scale auto servicing needs, especially if you don't have time to go to the shop for minor concerns, which can potentially become major. They can do oil changes, brake repairs, headlight replacements, and so much more, all without you having to leave your home. Mike was thorough, professional, and quick. He even walked me through what was done, with explanations, and provided recommendations to keep my vehicle healthy. It's the professionalism, no waiting, good work, and cost efficiency that does it for me!! This mobile auto service ROCKS!!!! 

Need Help With Your Car?

Our certified mobile mechanics make house calls in over 2,000 U.S. cities. Fast, free online quotes for your car repair.

GET A QUOTE

Related articles

10 Best Stores to Buy Auto Parts in Boston, Massachusetts
Automotive technicians rely on auto parts stores to add and replace car parts. The best auto parts shop in Boston is Talewsky's.
10 Best Stores to Buy Auto Parts in Tampa, Florida
Automotive technicians rely on auto parts stores to add and replace car parts. The best auto parts shop in Tampa is Advance Auto Parts.
10 Best Stores to Buy Auto Parts in Cincinnati, Ohio
Automotive technicians rely on auto parts stores to add and replace car parts. The best auto parts shop in Cincinnati is AutoZone.

Related questions

There is a part on the throttle body that broke, where and how would I go about finding another?

if you are referring to the plastic case that contains the "throttle position sensor" (TPS), the TPS is readily available in the new aftermarket or even as a new OEM (dealer) part. The throttle body itself, and all associated parts...

Right wheel shaking when driving

Being unable to drive your vehicle due to a shaky wheel is not a great experience. Unfortunately there could be a variety of reasons that can cause your right wheel to shake when driving. A failed strut, loose suspension components...

I am missing parts of my car, it's the part between the front tire and the engine, it looked like a cover of some sort

This is called the inner fender plastic liner and protects from water and dirt from getting into the engine area. You may have to special order a new one from a dealer or if you contact our customer service they...

How can we help?

Our service team is available 7 days a week, Monday - Friday from 6 AM to 5 PM PST, Saturday - Sunday 7 AM - 4 PM PST.

1 (855) 347-2779 · hi@yourmechanic.com