Q: Possible issue with transmission

asked by on October 25, 2016

Hi,

Thanks for taking attention of my problem.

I'm driving a 2007 Audi A4 1.8T and I started noticing a problem last night after engaging into D gear. The main issue is that upon releasing the brakes after engaging, I find the car to not be moving much at all - or even not move in some instance, and upon accelerating slightly, the RPM increases for a bit before the car jerks forward greatly. Some additional info;

• Problem seems to occur in this pattern - When I reversed, and engaged D after that i.e. when parking and adjusting.

• If I start my car the next day and go into P, there's no problem.

• It occurred once when I was a traffic stop and moving off.

• No fault codes

• Doesn't seem to have a transmission oil leak (according to a mechanic)

• Mechanic recommends taking the transmission apart and basically overhauling

• Mechanic suggests that replacing transmission oil will not help

• Car has around 90K Miles and is 9 years old.

Looking forward to responses.

My car has 90000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Transmission Fluid Service $140.08 - $502.73 Get a Quote

It sounds like your transmission may be having trouble building up enough oil pressure to engage the clutches while it is idling. The oil transmission oil pump runs off of the input shaft and runs at engine speed. When things get tired, be it the fluid thinning out or the clearances in the transmission getting larger, it takes a little more speed to build up the pressure you need to operate. You step on the gas, engine speed increases slightly, and then bam there is suddenly enough pressure to engage the clutch. Changing the fluid may not help, often by the time a problem gets bad enough to notice like this, the damage has already been done. But it could help, and it might get you a few more miles of service out of the transmission. There is one caveat - the fluid used has to be the FACTORY fluid. Since the late nineties, transmission makers have all been developing their own fluids and any substitutions can lead to more problems. If you would like to move forward with a transmission fluid service before taking it to the transmission shop, a certified technician from YourMechanic can perform this at your car’s location. It honestly may not be the complete solution to your problem, but it could temporarily help before you decide to bring the car in for a full transmission repair.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Bad tire pressure sensor
Many tire pressure sensors that are located inside the vehicle tire assembly have a built in battery that does fail over time. Once the sensor does fail, it should be replaced with a new one. For tire pressure sensor assemlies...
Oil or some sort of black sludge covering CV axle, control arm, etc.
After looking at the pictures you took, it looks to me like the inner axle boot has been slinging out grease from the CV joint. I recommend you clean off the inner CV boot and look for a loose or...
Transmission fluid is leaking out and the speedometer is not working.
Many common faults will cause your 1997 Ford F-150 to have a transmission leak and a speedometer that does not function. Transmission leaks can occur in various areas but the most common are the pan gasket, output seal, sensor seals,...
Lower Control Arm bushing
After viewing the pictures you supplied and viewing many different manufacturers of the lower control arms I do not thing the bushing is installed all the way in your control arm. I recommend you go online and print one or...
Exhaust Manifold Hot/Exhaust Leak
Hello. To say that they catalytic converter is good or bad is impossible without having the car here. If the manifold is heating up, and the catalytic convert has failed, you will see bigger signs of failure in the near...
I have a 2012 Infiniti QX56 and went through exactly what this person did with the truck going to the dealer in perfect order and
A/C systems that are leaking will function up to a "threshold", that is a minimum level of refrigerant charge, but once the charge drops below that threshold the system's low pressure cut off switch will shut down the compressor. The...
2009 NISSAN ALTIMA TRIED JUMPING AC COMPRESSOR FROM DRYER CNISTER WHILE CAR WAS RUNNING WHEN HE TOUCHED THE PRONGS TOGETHER THE CA
I can think of a few things. First off, was the jumper wire removed? if the a/c compressor is seized and the jumper wire is still in place sending direct power to it, it can prevent the vehicle from starting....
Hi Josh! If I provide the fuel pump kit and filter, how much do you charge for labor?
The labor to replace the fuel pump in the tank would depend on the exact model and labor rates in your area. The labor will be less than 1.5 hours if you supply parts to replace the pump i you...
Will I have to take out the whole transmission or apart just to get to to that piece (transmission speed sensor
The output speed sensor is replaced from outside the transmission and is located on rear of transmission. No need to remove transmission.

Related articles

How Long Does a Transmission Filter Last?
Your Your transmission filter is a very important component in your vehicle, because it’s the front line of defense when it comes to keeping contaminants out of your transmission fluid. Most automobile manufacturers recommend a transmission filter change every 2...
Is it Safe to Drive When a Car is Leaking Transmission Fluid?
Transmission fluid is colored green or red so it can be distinguished from other fluids in the vehicle. While it may...
How to Shift From First to Second Gear in a Manual Transmission Car
Shifting from first to second gear in a manual transmission requires accuracy and practice, as well as a feel for the car.