Q: clutch sticks halfway after pressing down, cannot engage gears

asked by on June 16, 2016

I had my master and slave replaced on my 2004 Toyota Camry 4 weeks ago due to the clutch sticking to ground when pressed and not engaging the gears. I am now having an issue with the clutch getting stuck halfway back up after pressing it in and it will not engage the gears. I am trying to find out more about the issue and get a second opinion, as Im being told the proportioning valve needs replaced.

My car has 140000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Clutch is not fully disengaging Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Hello. It is important when discussing master and slave cylinders to make it clear you are talking about the clutch and not the brake system – there isn’t a proportioning valve in the clutch system. Both have master cylinders and it is very easy (even for a seasoned mechanic) to confuse the two systems when having a discussion. I’m assuming this is what has happened with the mention of a proportioning valve.

My first question is, have you had the clutch replaced? A worn clutch can exhibit the same symptoms. 140,000 miles is about the time most clutches will need to be replaced on a Camry.

Next, it sounds like everything was working after the master and slave cylinder were replaced. It seems there are two possibilities left: something failed in the new components, or the clutch finally gave up, and it is a coincidence it happened four weeks after you had the hydraulics replaced.

A few more details about your hydraulic system. When the master and slave were replaced, were they leaking? Are they leaking now? If they are leaking, you should see a low fluid level to the clutch hydraulic master cylinder, as well as some fluid dripping under the car when you pump the pedal. If the system is full, there could be air in the system, which can be a more difficult problem. Clutch hydraulics can be problematic to bleed. And if it worked for a few weeks and now has air in the system, that means it is sucking in air someplace. This failure is hard to locate as it often happens intermittently, depending on temperature and how far you have driven.

Also, you won’t be able to engage the gears without a working clutch. The clutch releases the transmission so a gear can be selected. Without a working clutch to release the transmission from the engine, engaging the gears is possible but very difficult.

Hopefully I helped you get closer to an answer. Having a qualified mechanic take a look at it will give you more knowledge. A certified mobile mechanic from YourMechanic can come to your home or office to inspect your clutch issues.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Car hesitating first thing in the morning
Hi there. Your transmission consists of many different components which need to work in sync in order for it to perform properly. A lack of pressure, low fluid, fault shift solenoids, and valve bodies can be your issue. I'd strongly...
After alternator replacement, no power in SUV
Hello. It sounds like the cause of your problem is a blown battery fuse. The battery fuse is the main fuse for your battery, and if it has blown, the truck will not have any power until it is replaced....
My rpm gauge is jumping while car is not runnig
The issues you are having are going to need further testing. You will want to have your vehicle scanned for diagnostic troubleshooting codes. If a code has been triggered you will have a better idea if your issue is sensor...
Car does not turn on
Hi there. Assuming this is a standard type ignition switch, with the description of events you provided. I am concerned that the tumblers in the lock cylinder may have been damaged, when the half key was turned. The key turning...
Axle seal leak
The axle seal leak is unrelated to the flat tire you had. The purpose of the axle seal is to keep transmission fluid from leaking. Depending on the size of the leak, it may be okay to drive with a...
I have a 2000 Chevrolet venture. It seems to run fine while driving down the road but when I come to a stop light it's stars out
Hi there. The first thing a mobile mechanic would do here is complete a car start then dies inspection (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/car-starts-and-then-dies-inspection) on your Chevrolet Venture. This would allow them to scan your vehicle for any error codes, test drive the vehicle...
How reliable is a 2009 bmw 328i?
Hi there. Buying a BMW with more than 100,000 miles can be risky. Some cars are very well maintained and may serve you very well. However, if the car was driven hard, or routine service; especially transmission and routine fluid...
What is the cost to replace oxygen sensors P0139, PO159
Hi there. In general, there are two O2 sensors on your Toyota, an upstream sensor (located near the exhaust manifold) and downstream (located after the catalytic converter). Based on the error codes you listed however, it's not 100% certain that...
I was driving and my raidiator busted and my car shut down and It won’t start
Lending cars, Whew! it never turns out well. Its hard to imagine all those things going at once. The only scenario I can come up with is that the serpentine belt may have failed, possibly damaging the radiator, but also...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Toyota Camry Hybrid
More More and more manufacturers are offering their most popular passenger cars in hybrid models, and America’s top-selling passenger car is no exception. The 2012 Toyota Camry Hybrid is fuel-efficient, comfortable, and convenient. Key Features The upgraded HSD (hybrid synergy...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If Safety is #1
Maybe Maybe you’re a parent buying the first car for your teenager, or perhaps you’re a new parent and the safety of your little one is of the utmost importance. Or perhaps you're a safety-minded individual looking to make a...
How to Use a Prius as a Generator
Being Being without electricity due to natural disaster or repair work being performed on electric lines in your region is at best an inconvenience and at worst life-threatening, especially when you depend on electricity for essentials like heat in the...