Q: What to buy, high mileage with repair budget or low mileage with no repair budget?

asked by on March 02, 2017

I want to buy a practical 4x4 pickup and I am looking at a early 2000's Chevrolet and my budget is 13000. I am wondering if I am better off buying an $8000 truck with 170000 miles with a 5000 repair budget or to buy a $13000 with 120000 miles and no repair budget?

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Fixed car after Service Engine Soon light came on. It's still not working right
I can understand how frustrating it can be to replace parts on your car only to have it continue to experience problems. There can be several reasons why your Pontiac has its’ Service Engine Soon Light illuminated. If there is...
My 08 scion xb vibrates at 55 mph
You did not specify the transmission you have but the problem sounds like an issue with the constant velocity inner joint. When these joints start to have problems with vibration they are known to exhibit problems under a load and...
Car misses and has a rough idle - 2001 Saturn L100
Hello. There are several things that could be causing your rough idle condition and therefore there are multiple possible solutions. Carbon buildup inside the intake manifold and valve train is a big cause of rough idle. This can usually be...
Car sat for years, trouble starting - 1971 Nissan 240Z
Hello. It sounds like the fuel pump is bad (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/fuel-pump-replacement) or the fuel filter is clogged. It is also possible that there is a lot of water in your fuel system. Dry gas or sea foam will need to be...
New car oil consumption before 1st oil change
Hi there. Either the positive crankcase ventilation valve (PCV (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/positive-crankcase-ventilation-pcv-valve-replacement)) or the turbo has excessive oil blow by. Check the PCV valve and see if its working. Check the air filter to the engine and make sure that its dry...
Cranking noises when I am turning on my car.
The problem may be the replacement starter itself or the transmission flex plate the starter drives to start the engine. If there was damage to the gear on the old starter, some of that damage may have transferred to the...
Power loss and black smoke from exhaust
Hi There, Black smoke coming from the exhaust is usually an indication of a rich fuel condition. When this happens, this can be the result of many things such as faulty fuel injectors, a failing mass air flow sensor or...
1996 Jeep Grand Cherokee with 180,000 miles. As I'm driving it starts to sputter but still going the speed limit.
Sounds like the crankshaft position sensor is loosing connection when driving. Check the harness to the crankshaft position sensor and see if there is a loose wires or if the contacts can be loose when pushed against. The harness could...
how hard is it to change 2013 Chevy Captiva Sport Camshaft Position Sensor L4 2.4L
Hi there. Like any other mechanical repair, the definition of 'easy' is relative based on the level of experience you have, access to the correct tools and detailed instructions. If you're going to replace this component, I would highly recommend...

Related articles

How All Wheel Drive Works
What What is All-Wheel Drive? All-Wheel Drive (AWD) vehicles send power to all four of the wheels. This can be done in a number of ways but the end goal is improved traction and performance for the vehicle. While All-Wheel...
5 Essential Things to Know Before Buying a Truck
Trucks Trucks are a popular option thanks to their overall versatility. They can haul people and things with ease, and they handle off-road adventures like champs. However, there are five essential things to know before buying a truck. Passengers The...
Helpful Tips When Buying Your Next Used Car
Checking the service history, getting a vehicle history report, and a pre-purchase inspection are all helpful tips to get the best deal possible.