Q: Unable to shift while the car is running. Able to shift when the car is off

asked by on November 11, 2016

I have purchased this car 10/20/2016 and have driven it since. I have not encontered any problems with the clutch during all these weeks. No slipping, shifting always smooth. Nothing to indicate anything was wrong.

I stop at a red light, put the car in neutral. Light turns greens and just like that THE CAR DOESN'T SHIFT IN 1ST. Nor 2nd... Or any other gear. The clutch pedal feels weak with almost no resistance.

I check the fluid, and CANNOT find a separate reservoir for the clutch. I come to the conclusion that the clutch fluid runs from the break fluid reservoir. It's full, but somewhat DIRTY.

I turn the car OFF, and I am able to shift in all gear.

With the car OFF, I put it in first. I try to start the car. It attempts to start and Jerk forward violently, but NEVER actually starts.

I call the tow truck and get it to my mechanics. My mechanic claims he is sure I need a CLUTCH KIT without doing much inspecting. Can this simply be a problem with maybe one of the cylinders

My car has 100000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I turn on the cooled seats?
There are Cooled Seats in your truck. These Cooled Seats are useful when driving in hot weather. To turn on the Cooled Seats. Press the Cooled Seat button for the driver. Press the Cooled Seat button for the passenger you...
Car starts, then won't restart, then starts again
Hi thanks for the question, problems like this can be as hard to diagnose as they are to live with. It sounds like you may have some intermittent electrical issue. This will require a skilled technician that has the knowhow...
What does the Seat Belt Reminder warning light mean?
The Seat Belt Reminder warning light is located on the instrument panel. When either the driver or the front passenger is not wearing their seat belt, the Seat Belt Reminder warning light will illuminate. Once the vehicle starts moving, the...
Shortage in wire leading to battery cable
Hello. If someone has changed the wiring from its original path without using the proper wires or connectors, it could cause a short. The wiring needs to be checked for any breaks or loose connections in order to make an...
When replacing rear brake pads on 2012 nissan rogue is it necessary to replace rotors at the same time?
Whenever brake pads are replaced the brake rotors must be resurfaced on a brake lathe or replaced outright. Putting new pads on a worn rotor is a guarantee that the new pads will wear irregularly, you will have vibration, and...
Hilux wont run properly.1995 Toyota Hilux
Hi there, congratulation on your high-miler! The first task is to review the problem codes stored in the on-board diagnostics. Although not OBD II, they should still be helpful in guiding your diagnosis. I would suspect fuel supply problems (https://www.yourmechanic.com/question/loss-of-power-sluggish)...
How do I know if I need a stabilizer bar in my 2010 Nissan Murano
Hello. If the vehicle has not been in an accident or has not had any serious suspension damage then you should not need a stabilizer bar. It is rare to need the bar itself. The bar is mounted to the...
Dodge ram misfires only when I do a cold start?
Hello, As you may know, there are a number of things that can cause a misfire ranging from faulty ignition parts to changes in air/fuel mixture, fuel pressure, timing an the list goes on. If you do know you have...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Dodge Durango
The The 2012 Dodge Durango is a more fuel efficient SUV yet still provides all of the room and power you need. The Durango can tow up to 7,400 pounds making it perfect for family outings and carrying lots of...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Clutch Safety Switch
If your manual car is not starting, starts while in gear, or has the Check Engine Light on, you may need to replace the clutch safety switch.
How to Double-Clutch Downshift a Manual Transmission Car
Learning how to double-clutch downshift on your cars manual transmission can optimize your acceleration, deceleration, and help maintain components.