Q: New brakes

asked by on December 30, 2016

Went for A1 oil change. No problems with brakes however it does have 48000 miles. Upon inspection mechanic tells me I need all new brakes and rotors. No idiot light came on ... no squeal or pulsing. Why would my car need $1200 worth of brake work when I was having no problem?

My car has 48000 miles.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Failed smog check
Hi. This is a fairly common concern for smog failure, it indicates the computer has detected a large leak in the evaporative emissions system. 90% of the time this is due to the fuel cap not being secured properly. Sometimes,...
Burning smell from fuse box
An electrical burning smell coming from the fuse block is never a good sign. Your fuse block is a major junction in the supply of power to most of your engine management system and accessories. A proper inspection should be...
Problems after thermostat, digital cluster & cooling pump replacements
It appears you may have a few different issues going on. It seems unlikely that more than one cluster would fail. The most likely cause is a shorted wiring or open circuit causing the clusters to fail. If the car...
can a undercarriage light system (Undercarriage LED) drain the battery
Hi there. LED lights do not put much strain on the battery unless your leaving them on without the engine running for extended periods of time. Also, I have not know LED lights to be used as a GPS tracking...
brake pad lubricant
The black liquid is used as an anti-rattle coating for the back of the brake pads. You would normally put a thin coating on the backing plate, where it meets up with the caliper, and it is designed to keep...
My check engine engine light is on and the computer (ECM) said it's a crank sensor problem.
Check the crankshaft position sensor and see if there is a loose wire or if the remote wiring is disabling the sensor. If the wiring is good and the sensor is hooked up properly, then I recommend replacing the crankshaft...
No power. Transmission shifts down and engine revs up but doesn't go anywhere
Hi there. In some cases, what you're describing is caused by a restriction of fluid inside the hydraulic lines of the transmission, an inner seal that is damaged or the torque converter wearing out. This issue can sometimes be resolved...
Oil Gasket Leak
Without knowing what the leak is I would have to agree with the last diagnosis that it should be done ASAP. This is because most oil leaks can get worse over time and can cause the engine to get low...
My car cranks but won't start. I can hear it trying to start and then there is a single thump noise.
There are many causes of hard starting but illustrative ones are a faulty engine coolant temperature switch (sensor), worn spark plugs, inadequate fuel delivery or pressure (e.g., clogged fuel filter), dirty fuel injectors, contaminated or old gasoline, malfunctioning idle air...

Related articles

How Often Should Brakes Be Replaced?
Brake pads and brake rotors wear out over time. How long brakes last depends on the brake material, as well as your driving patterns.
How to Use a Gas Station Car Wash
It It is inevitable that your vehicle will need to be washed, and it’s convenient to do so when you go to a gas station to fuel up. Many gas stations have a car wash on site, whether it is...
A Mechanic's Guide to Maintaining Automotive Power Tools
How to maintain automotive tools like impact wrenches, air drills, air screwdrivers, polishers, sanders & more to keep power tools safe & durable.