Q: knocking before wanting to start

asked by on April 07, 2016

My car sat for this last winter and developed a starting problem. It started knocking before wanting to turn over and run. The sound is coming from the transmission/ starter area. Eventually I had to get a new battery. It still made the noise though. I removed the starter, had it bench tested, and replaced the solenoid. After putting it back on its still making the noise and not wanting to start right. While removing the starter I did pull my tranny out to fix a clutch problem. Inspected the flywheel and got a second and third opinion as well. The flywheel was in good shape minus three or so teeth that had been nicked. What could be causing this knocking/ grinding?
My car has a manual transmission.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Engine chugging at low speeds when the weather is bad
It is very possible that moisture is getting into the connectors of the engine control module (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-engine-control-module-ecm). The connectors should be checked and cleaned if necessary. Di-electric grease can be used to help seal the connectors and keep the moisture...
Check Engine Light - Code indicates O2 sensor 1 error
The O2 sensor is a sensor in the exhaust system that reports to your car's computer how much unburnt fuel is in the exhaust gases, which then tells the fuel injection system how to adjust the fuel mixture. When the...
Car has electrical problems and starting issues
My guess is that the problem is with the body control module (BCM). The BCM functions as the power mode master (PMM). In this role, it receives an input from the ignition switch when the key is turned to the...
Cylinder 4 misfire, fuel injector looks to be the problem, only misfires on start up or idle, is it safe to drive?
Driving for an extended period with a misfiring cylinder can certainly do damage. That cylinder will run hotter because of the misfire and piston and/or valve damage can occur. If you need help having this repaired, a certified professional from...
Car won't start - 1999 Saturn SL1
Hey there. You will want to have the vehicle scanned for diagnostic trouble codes and start there. If you're getting power and the car still acting like it doesn't want to run (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/car-is-not-starting-inspection), your issue is very likely either spark...
Lack of power at full throttle.
Hi there. Your scooter has a fuel flow restriction which could either be in the tank, lines, or carburetor itself. Let off the throttle and open the throttle again. If the scooter fixes its self, then the float bowl in...
How would I know if I need to replace the rotors on my 2016 Mazda 6 sport without removing the tire?
Hello. Thank you for writing in. With the age of your vehicle, it is rather unlikely that you would have to replace the rotors already. The brake pads that stop the rotation of the rotors however do likely need to...
Why did my slip light and my ABS and brake light come on in my 2011 Honda Accord after replacing my battery
Hello. It is common for these lights to come on after a battery replacement. It is typically due to the fact that the system has lost voltage which causes these computers to set codes. I usually scan the computers just...
Oil Light comes on and car dies
Hi There, If your oil pressure falls below a specific level, the ECM (car's computer) will automatically shut the engine down to avoid further damage to the engine. This is done as a safety precaution. Typically, the oil pressure light...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're a Gardener or Landscape Architect
Gardeners Gardeners and landscape architects need to haul around quite a bit of gear. As a gardener, chances are you will need to transport a variety of mowing equipment, along with smaller implements. You may also need to move shrubs,...
How Long Does an Automatic Timing Advance Unit Last?
The The automatic timing advance unit is a component in vehicles with diesel engines. Of course gas and diesel engines both work on the internal combustion principle, but they are quite different, and require different means of controlling the flow...
How Long Does an EGR Temperature Sensor Last?
Are Are you familiar with the EGR (exhaust gas recirculation) system in your car? If not, this is something all modern cars have. The purpose of this system is to greatly reduce the amount of emissions produced by your car....